Mafia 4

Status
Not open for further replies.
I appreciate that and thank Astro for hosting but my point was there is no rule saying we as players can't post a table and I've not seen Astro object to this either. We can post what we like (within the rules) so why wouldn't we be able to include people that haven't been voted for in the table?

Like you, I'm happy to update the table (I usually do) too. Suspect I'm not going to need to though. Very rarely do it on the first day as I don't see much point and I think my stubborn luck is due to run out :)

table done...
 
Can't you use your mafia experience from other games (or this one)?

Gerrez will know from last game and a few of you remember from previous game I liked to do what casts doubts in people's minds. Most of the time that's being really in obvious and really random.

If I was in Mafia I'd probably do the 'don't vote for anyone and put it on someone that hadn't been online between last night and 10am this morning' like I did with chris and his convert in Mafia 2.

I certainly wouldn't have put suspicion on my own team so early in the game wih only 4 people, each one with a role to play.

Making me vote for sky has put doubt in people's minds but atm it's doubt that I'm
Mafia, more than I'm innocent so it was never going to be a clever move if I was Mafia and bluffing :huh:
 
I appreciate people helping to keep track of the votes. I don't mind about the format so long as the information is clear and correct.
 
Gerrez will know from last game and a few of you remember from previous game I liked to do what casts doubts in people's minds. Most of the time that's being really in obvious and really random.

If I was in Mafia I'd probably do the 'don't vote for anyone and put it on someone that hadn't been online between last night and 10am this morning' like I did with chris and his convert in Mafia 2.

I certainly wouldn't have put suspicion on my own team so early in the game wih only 4 people, each one with a role to play.

Making me vote for sky has put doubt in people's minds but atm it's doubt that I'm
Mafia, more than I'm innocent so it was never going to be a clever move if I was Mafia and bluffing :huh:

As soon as the Batphone from Astro rang though you knew it was a nightmare <hug> Voting for Sky makes you number one target....but as a townie it's better you're number one target than Sky is....that in fairness goes for all the rest of us townies too.

Sky is our biggest identifiable asset. Many may have to fall on their swords to protect him <yikes>
 
Gerrez will know from last game and a few of you remember from previous game I liked to do what casts doubts in people's minds. Most of the time that's being really in obvious and really random.

If I was in Mafia I'd probably do the 'don't vote for anyone and put it on someone that hadn't been online between last night and 10am this morning' like I did with chris and his convert in Mafia 2.

I certainly wouldn't have put suspicion on my own team so early in the game wih only 4 people, each one with a role to play.

Making me vote for sky has put doubt in people's minds but atm it's doubt that I'm
Mafia, more than I'm innocent so it was never going to be a clever move if I was Mafia and bluffing :huh:

But having team up with you last time, I'm also aware of how well you can send people down the wrong route too :)
 
As soon as the Batphone from Astro rang though you knew it was a nightmare <hug> Voting for Sky makes you number one target....but as a townie it's better you're number one target than Sky is....that in fairness goes for all the rest of us townies too.

Sky is our biggest identifiable asset. Many may have to fall on their swords to protect him <yikes>

sky is only an asset as he can speak as well though. he cannot be converted so either he gets killed but he should be the one setting the tone for the rest of the town. Hopefully he can do this unlike last game where connection killed it. I like how it allows the other town roles work in the background.
 
As soon as the Batphone from Astro rang though you knew it was a nightmare <hug> Voting for Sky makes you number one target....but as a townie it's better you're number one target than Sky is....that in fairness goes for all the rest of us townies too.

Sky is our biggest identifiable asset. Many may have to fall on their swords to protect him <yikes>

If I'd been forced to vote for Sky on the first day I'd have waited until 7.55pm before voting knowing full well that I would be allowed to shout from the roof top about it after 10am tomorrow (going be the previous thread suggestions).

Obviously, I'd still keep my eye ont hings and would happily sacrifice myself if I had to to save Sky.
 
sky is only an asset as he can speak as well though. he cannot be converted so either he gets killed but he should be the one setting the tone for the rest of the town. Hopefully he can do this unlike last game where connection killed it. I like how it allows the other town roles work in the background.

100% this!
 
In the last game sky was a rubbish Freemason! I hope he is better as the Cop!

Just managed to catch up on reading through the thread. Brb and Valley jumping on gerrez after I put my vote there as a place keeper, bit of an odd one if innocent...

I won't be leaving my vote on gerrez if he is out on his own for the chop. I'm thinking getting a few people in there is the best option.
 
In the last game sky was a rubbish Freemason! I hope he is better as the Cop!

Just managed to catch up on reading through the thread. Brb and Valley jumping on gerrez after I put my vote there as a place keeper, bit of an odd one if innocent...

I won't be leaving my vote on gerrez if he is out on his own for the chop. I'm thinking getting a few people in there is the best option.

On the other hand, it is only Gerrez...
 
If I'd been forced to vote for Sky on the first day I'd have waited until 7.55pm before voting knowing full well that I would be allowed to shout from the roof top about it after 10am tomorrow (going be the previous thread suggestions).

Obviously, I'd still keep my eye ont hings and would happily sacrifice myself if I had to to save Sky.

I have footvall tonight and don't normally get back until 7:30 and didn't want to risk it in case got stuck in traffic couldn't make it back before 8 and then killed off by default.
 
I might swap my vote for afctw he was a bit of a game player last time and takes this very seriously...where Gerrez is well....just a sly one sneaking around the unlit alleys in his tipped gangster trilby...I can save my bullet for Gerrez later...they will probably form a pact to take me out but at least others will get an idea of whether they are on opposite sides or not...let's see what rattles the wood work....

afctw
 
sky is only an asset as he can speak as well though. he cannot be converted so either he gets killed but he should be the one setting the tone for the rest of the town. Hopefully he can do this unlike last game where connection killed it. I like how it allows the other town roles work in the background.

He is of course hence me using biggest identifiable asset :) He may not be the biggest asset in the long run but at the mo he is one we can protect <ok> As a town all we have to do is target any who vote for him (accepting that one may well be forced). If we all stick to that then the only vote they can ever get on him is a forced one and their own. Any player forced to vote for Sky will always allude to it anyway surely. Sky should only ever get one vote max.

Normally in the opening round we literally have nothing to go on (unless someone admits to a role), this time we have a player to focus on....some might even say...A God <hallelujah>:D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.