Mafia 4

Status
Not open for further replies.
Mummy said:
So Hacker, Recruiter and Assassin left.

We don't know how/when they can use their powers. No recruit or kill last night. I wonder why? Strategy, forgot, or can only use one power at a time perhaps? Hacked Journalist?

Would expect the most likely course of action for them tonight is that they recruit (unless we can find the recruiter).
Click to expand...

Well I think it best to leave ibwt's comment about restrictions behind and focus on task at hand

Those could be anything so our job is to find who did what and who is who

For example;

Town team. We still only know sky for sure but if we dig in the votes is there evidence of mason actions or evidence of innocence anywhere?

Mafia; who acted for ibwt with actual votes? How did it end? Were those last votes innocent in confusion or not?

What do we make of brb? He killed ibwt after all.


What do we know about day 1?

Ibwt was playing cute with his role? Why?

What do we know about day 2?

Mafia have 3 members??? Therefore 4 vote = magic number to kill anyone

11 v 3 and tomorrow can be hardest day, everyone will have a theory we could start all over again.


I don't know but can speculate

1. Ibwt might have convinced the mafia that like game 2 that I ran to save other actions and made up this cutsey little ploy

2. The mafia were not allowed to do anything until day 2 or even 3 and so they. Again rather than hiding came up with this ploy based on again ibwt feeling if mafia did nothing he'd be fingered

I feel we must assume nothing and focus on finding next mafia and assume the three have thier powers intact
 
ValleyGraduate12 said:
I don't think anyone could have foreseen BRBs panic attack. I had an image of BRB akin to Mr Bean pressing the nuke button at the white house and having a meltdown <laugh>
Click to expand...


Having BRB on board certainly makes it more entertaining... although he's not entirely good for the town! <laugh> Can count on entertainment when BRB is in the game. I can see why IBWT is peeved- but I do find last night's actualities to be amusing!
 
Mummy said:
Having BRB on board certainly makes it more entertaining... although he's not entirely good for the town! <laugh> Can count on entertainment when BRB is in the game. I can see why IBWT is peeved- but I do find last night's actualities to be amusing!
Click to expand...

It was worth joining this game just to witness the last 45 seconds <laugh>
 
moreinjuredthanowen said:
Town team. We still only know sky for sure but if we dig in the votes is there evidence of mason actions or evidence of innocence anywhere?
Click to expand...

As I said, I think BRB is most likely innocent. He might be guilty- but his actions last night were bloody stupid if he were guilty.

Mafia; who acted for ibwt with actual votes? How did it end? Were those last votes innocent in confusion or not?
Click to expand...

Under normal circumstances I would say Bod, AFC, and Valley (all voted for someone other than IBWT in dying seconds- or after 7:59) were huge suspects... however, with BRB acting like he did- they might have been trying to keep up and balance out his influence- so I'm not as certain as I would be.

What do we make of brb? He killed ibwt after all.
Click to expand...
He's a nut- but most likely (but not certainly) innocent.


Ibwt was playing cute with his role? Why?
Click to expand...

It's what he does. Over-confidence for similar actions working in Mafia 2 & 3.


2. The mafia were not allowed to do anything until day 2 or even 3 and so they. Again rather than hiding came up with this ploy based on again ibwt feeling if mafia did nothing he'd be fingered

I feel we must assume nothing and focus on finding next mafia and assume the three have thier powers intact
Click to expand...


Mafia are only allowed to do one thing a night- and night one chose to hack the next Newspaper maybe? Don't know. Want to save their powers until they have a clearer idea of which townsperson to take out? Confusion? Someone new to the game not knowing they had to PM Astro? Could be anything.


Don't have a whole lot to go on in day 2.
 
Do you guys think the morning paper will have more info about mafia activities or what? 10am?

I dunno. It's all up in the air
 
ValleyGraduate12 said:
I didn't vote for anyone in the dying seconds <grr>
Click to expand...

You had this:

ValleyGraduate12 said:
Hold on, I voted Gerrez ages ago
Click to expand...

at 8:00- bolded makes it look like a vote. (Gerrez was not your last vote prior to that). If not a vote it implied you wanted at that point your vote to be on Gerrez.

(if your vote were counted on Gerrez instead of BRB at that point then IBWT would have been safe).
 
Mummy said:
You had this:



at 8:00- bolded makes it look like a vote. (Gerrez was not your last vote prior to that). If not a vote it implied you wanted at that point your vote to be on Gerrez.
Click to expand...

If you look a bit earlier brb asked me to vote Gerrez. I'd already told him that I had prior to that post. Didn't realise I'd voted brb instead. I also knew the cut off was 7:58 like I've since stated <ok>
 
I said I was happy as long as the coin flip had some combination of IBWT, brb, gerrez and valley who were my early suspicions (though I'll point out I don't have particularly good reasons for the suspicion, but it was day one). Wasn't bothered if it was three or four or even two people in the toss as long as we were putting pressure on the suspicious people. Then brb went nuts and basically stopped us every time we had coin flip on the go. He seemed determined to kill someone so my late vote was an attempt to counter the destruction of brb lol

I did say very early on that I'd change my vote to even things up if someone was out in front alone on day one!
 
right u lot before you all start with your suspicions....I'm working tomorrow...so it saves you from my reckless shotgun as Swarbs would put it lol....so probs won't get on until the last hour of voting...
 
brb said:
right u lot before you all start with your suspicions....I'm working tomorrow...so it saves you from my reckless shotgun as Swarbs would put it lol....so probs won't get on until the last hour of voting...
Click to expand...

forgot to add....i reiterate i dont trust afc
 
brb said:
right u lot before you all start with your suspicions....I'm working tomorrow...so it saves you from my reckless shotgun as Swarbs would put it lol....so probs won't get on until the last hour of voting...
Click to expand...

Oh good god <laugh>
 
brb said:
right u lot before you all start with your suspicions....I'm working tomorrow...so it saves you from my reckless shotgun as Swarbs would put it lol....so probs won't get on until the last hour of voting...
Click to expand...



So we can only expect 12 votes from you before the next nightfall then! <laugh>
 
brb said:
right u lot before you all start with your suspicions....I'm working tomorrow...so it saves you from my reckless shotgun as Swarbs would put it lol....so probs won't get on until the last hour of voting...
Click to expand...

I'm looking forward to it already :D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom
Back