Think that's a touch unfair Beddy, he certainly had his trouble early in the season with defensive lapses, but I think since around the time Shaw came into the team he has defended very well. Averages third most tackles per game after Morgan and Clyne, and second most interceptions again after Morgan. And if Shaw set off on a long run it would be Cork or Schneiderlin's responsibility to drop into the gap rather than Lallana's. If anything I feel like Shaw has had a tougher time defensively since Lallana has been injured, not that tough mind, but before Lallana got injured he was an absolute rock but since then he has made a few little errors whilst still playing very well.