It has been said in a few places "Foreign Managers aren't holding back young English Managers. Old English Managers are."
I agree, but would widen the "English" to "British" . It's like musical chairs of: Big Sam, Hodgson, Pardew, Redknapp, Pulis (Welsh), Moyes (Scottish).
In Spain, when the ageing Managers fail, they employ young Spanish Managers from the lower leagues who have impressed. Italy pretty much do the same.
I think it's a major reason we are never get anywhere near competing in major competitions with the National side.
Under 19 side has an English Manager. Undr 21s have an English Manager. Neither would be linked with any Prem jobs. You never hear them even linked at Championship level. But look what they are doing at youth level! They are getting them to play class football and winning competitions against world players who are the next generation for their countries. Southgate is a nice appointment. Because it's using an English Manager who has worked at club level, and worked at England youth level. I'm happy that has happened. I am not sure of his ability, but I put more blame on the players than the Manager for the dire performances. But this is the kind of thing we should be doing.
In the same way as "Just because Klopp and Wagnar were youth team coaches and Dortmund, It doesn't mean every single youth team coach they have will be a class Manager". Just because Southgate is English, fairly young and came from the youth system, doesn't mean he is the one! But he is the one at the front of the line for English Managers to have a go. He is bringing in and capping young prospects who have been raved about for years. That is positive
Some players who are amazing for their club are terrible for England (is that coz they dont take a wage?) and a lot of players pull out because they want to be fit for their club. Kind of limits the selection process.
Another thing we are doing wrong is working the friendlies. It's fair enough to want to test ourselves against the best countries. Very often our main players pretend they are injured for friendlies. So if we have to play back ups, it's not "testing our side against the best in the world" because come the world cup, all these "injured" players will suddenly be totally fit. The more friendlies you lose or draw the lower you are ranked. There are teams much higher than us who are just as bad, but they just play hardly any friendlies. So they get no minus points. So their rank is higher, so they get seeded for competitions. I think Poland are one of these countries. I can't remember the others.