First scalp

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Christiansmith said:
The excitement was getting fever pitch on the RS board at half time. Then after the match, everyone disappeared. Not a word. That match never even existed haha. :)
Click to expand...

I know I shouldn't rise, but...

As opposed to this board, where there were 8 posts on the match thread during the game and none after, with none being from Man U fans? :emoticon-0114-dull: And are you really complaining about Liverpool fans going to bed at 3 in the morning after a friendly?
 
Few thoughts...

- Referee was shocking
- Rooney celebrating was a bit embarrassing + was unsporting for the non-goal incident - no need in a friendly.
- Both teams were pretty poor
- Score flattered United
- Two terrific finishes regardless (Rooney + Lingaard (sp))
- Sterling should've had two penalties
- Herrera has a nice weight of pass but a 33yr old Gerrard bullied him most of the game and was hindered by verrrry tetchy officiating (see point 1)
- Martin Kelly needs to go far away from Anfield unfortunately
- I stayed up to 4 odd for that ****e
 
Yoda

Referee was indeed shocking but for both teams. When you lose it can't always be the refs fault especially when you take into account the help you had from the officials last season!

Have another look at Rooney's "celebration" of the disallowed goal.
 
weararedbonnet said:
Guess the force wasn't with you Master Yoda, and with all the crap of your summing up the match, its hardly surprising. Tad biased maybe?
Click to expand...

Droll... will gladly reply on whatever point you desire if you can reply properly :)

Madinat said:
Yoda

Referee was indeed shocking but for both teams. When you lose it can't always be the refs fault especially when you take into account the help you had from the officials last season!

Have another look at Rooney's "celebration" of the disallowed goal.
Click to expand...

He was shocking for both teams... I didn't specify a team! Don't assume things!

He gave a big smirk and walked off did he not? I was referring to his celebration for his first goal however. Compare it to Gerrard's.
 
Madinat said:
Yoda

Referee was indeed shocking but for both teams. When you lose it can't always be the refs fault especially when you take into account the help you had from the officials last season!

Have another look at Rooney's "celebration" of the disallowed goal.
Click to expand...


Actually... if you look at our forum on our discussion- a great deal of criticism of the ref happened whilst we were winning. That's when the ref was being his worst.

My theory- after giving us the penalty he wanted to "even things up". A lot of refs do that... after giving a major decision to one team they feel they have to give a bunch of decisions to the other team so people won't think they're biased.

If it's a penalty- it's a penalty... no reason to "even it up".
If it's not a penalty- it's not a penalty... don't give it.

"Evening" things up is never a good idea. Prior to the penalty- the ref was fine. Between the penalty and your second goal he was giving every call to United. After your second goal- the ref went back to being fine. If you read the match thread- you'll see that most people complaining about the ref was complaining about him whilst we were ahead.
 
Milk said:
Actually... if you look at our forum on our discussion- a great deal of criticism of the ref happened whilst we were winning. That's when the ref was being his worst.

My theory- after giving us the penalty he wanted to "even things up". A lot of refs do that... after giving a major decision to one team they feel they have to give a bunch of decisions to the other team so people won't think they're biased.

If it's a penalty- it's a penalty... no reason to "even it up".
If it's not a penalty- it's not a penalty... don't give it.

"Evening" things up is never a good idea. Prior to the penalty- the ref was fine. Between the penalty and your second goal he was giving every call to United. After your second goal- the ref went back to being fine. If you read the match thread- you'll see that most people complaining about the ref was complaining about him whilst we were ahead.
Click to expand...

<laugh><laugh><laugh><laugh><laugh><laugh>...
 
Clutching at straws guys. You were undone to all three goals in open play by some slick passing and movement. Add to that some downright amateurish defending, and United stroked the ball home on each occasion with ease. Form what I have seen, the referee had no involvement in the goals except to confirm they were legitimate goals
 
Milk said:
Actually... if you look at our forum on our discussion- a great deal of criticism of the ref happened whilst we were winning. That's when the ref was being his worst.

My theory- after giving us the penalty he wanted to "even things up". A lot of refs do that... after giving a major decision to one team they feel they have to give a bunch of decisions to the other team so people won't think they're biased.

If it's a penalty- it's a penalty... no reason to "even it up".
If it's not a penalty- it's not a penalty... don't give it.

"Evening" things up is never a good idea. Prior to the penalty- the ref was fine. Between the penalty and your second goal he was giving every call to United. After your second goal- the ref went back to being fine. If you read the match thread- you'll see that most people complaining about the ref was complaining about him whilst we were ahead.
Click to expand...

Sounds like a lot of whining and excuses.
 
and as for Stevie me, the reason he didn't celibrate was that without the sewer rat, he couldn't see any one else scoring for his team. The lack of celebration was knowing that he had woken up the beast, which was proven by the final score. Bet he didn't find a camera to kiss either
 
Recorded the game last night, just finished watching it. Not impressed with the defence, they were up against **** and still looked dodgy ( have been very impressed with Tyler Blakett on this tour though). So many players last night couldn`t make a simple pass for some reason (Fletcher and Evans in particular). On the plus side, Young looks like he has been replaced by a good clone, Nani looks like he is willing to put effort in and Herrera looks to have a bit of cynical steel about him as well as his obvious class when in control of the ball.
Overall i think we have very good strength in depth throughout the team once we get people like Carrick, Raphael and Van Persie back (perhaps a little too much depth in attacking mid). We are good to go for the season but a top class centre half would be most appreciated.
 
weararedbonnet said:
give them chance to adopt LVG's system Diego, and they will be fine. And if our defence was dodgy, it doesn't say much for the Brenda brigade.[/QUOTE]

Thats what i said, they were up against **** and still looked dodgy. Still, they did ok against a world class team like Madrid so i am not too worried.
Click to expand...
 
luvgonzo said:
All these posts over a game that didn't mean a thing, can't wait for the season to start. :biggrin:
Click to expand...

Every game means something Luv, i am gutted any time we lose (even a testamonial) and delighted every time we win. It just goes with being a supporter as far as i`m concerned <ok>
 
Swarbs said:
Not quite true luv. It means we're definitely winning at least one more trophy than you this season <ok>

#theyallcount
Click to expand...

Agreed, I was being sarcastic. Games between us will always have a bit more edge even in a friendly. It's going to be an interesting season for both our clubs can you get back in the top 4 and can we stay in the top 4. If we're both up there then the games between us will be crackers.
 
Haha there's no point in trying to 'debate' on this board sometimes.

But it's nice that we're the 'first scalp' considering you've beaten Madrid... If Christian thinks we're bigger and better who are we to argue :)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back