I don't disagree with any of that.
But there is always a much bigger picture and a hidden cost in a globalised world. It is impossible for there not to be.
Think about the massive increase in demand for lithium, cobalt and manganese for EV batteries. Where's that all coming from and how is it being extracted from the Earth? No one stops to ask that when they're cruising along the M3 all smug in their Tesla.
Think about the heart of palm scam, sold to the world as a nice healthy organic food and then lo and behold it turns out to make the stuff you need to deforest thousands of acres of land.
Or all the twats walking around with their latte and avocado toasts. 1kg of avocados requires 2000 litres of water. No one knows this stuff because politicians make sure it is never discussed.
Over the past 50 years, the UK has become a world leader in two exports: workforce, and pollution.
I couldn't give a toss how many wind turbines they've blighted the Cornwall countryside with if it costs the taxpayer more and still leads to a global net rise in pollution. It is the epitome of vanity politics.
What you have to bear in mind though is that these are transitional technologies. With regard to EVs, yes there is an ecological and human right issue with the extraction of cobalt and rare earth minerals, but once those minerals are extracted, they then produce a battery that will likely outlast the lifetime of the vehicle. And once that battery is depleted, those minerals will be recycled into making another battery.
If you compare this with a combustion car, there is all of the energy that goes into making it, the steel, aluminum, even rare earth metals like platinum are used in catalytic converters. And then for the entire lifetime of the car, it relies on oil extraction to make the fuel to run it.
With EVs all of the energy consumption is up front. Then they become very sustainable to run, especially if you’ve got solar panels on your roof.
Also, lithium battieries are a transitional tech, the Chinese are already producing sodium solid state batteries that do not require rare earth minerals. And these will hit the market later this year.
It’s easy to criticise renewables for the environmental impact that they do have, but as I mention you have to see this in a step change way, each time we are moving towards more and more sustainable ways of producing energy.