As much as I hate you guys, I have to admit it is some kind of sick joke that they can actually watch the replays and not only uphold the ban but not bad Young for diving either! 
Massive incompetence!
Massive incompetence!Derry Appeal
- Thread starter jeffranger
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
I would like to say I'm surprised, but,,the FA are NEVER going to asccuse a Manure player of cheating...NEVER
Saw this coming a mile away....Its Manure's league, what they say goes.
Move on and lets spank the Swans...
Saw this coming a mile away....Its Manure's league, what they say goes.
Move on and lets spank the Swans...
This decision is a blatant piss take. Our great working class game is well and truely ****ed.
Infact, it's asthough they are all patting each other on the back for guiding Man United to yet another league title.
Infact, it's asthough they are all patting each other on the back for guiding Man United to yet another league title.
Sunderland betrayed the "working class game" on Saturday by playing a pathetic defensive formation at HOME. You complain about Man U getting penalty decisions - if you don't attack the box then you wan't get a penalty shout.
Sunderland deserved to be relegated for adopting such p*** tactics.
The same 'defensive' formation which resulted in more shots on target for Sunderland and 11 v 4 corners in favour of Sunderland? Did you watch the full game or did you merely believe the media's biased coverage?
I watched the "game".
'Arry was so *****d off afterwards he didn't know what to say it was so embarrasing!
'Arry was so *****d off afterwards he didn't know what to say it was so embarrasing!
Is that it? Is that your pathetic attempt to try and debate?
Working class my backside, thick as **** more like.
Is that it? Is that your pathetic attempt to try and debate?
I take it that you don't like being 3 points below Sunderland, then?
LOL. You are embarrassing yourself. This was a debate about referrees and because you have nothing else to contribute to the debate your answer is to say "we are higher in the league than you!!!!!!"
PMSL
Please remind me that i am on our QPR site and discussing alll things QPR!!!
If you lot want to have a **** fight..please do it on your own boards...we're allready too busy arguing with each other to entertain you..
Thanks..
If you lot want to have a **** fight..please do it on your own boards...we're allready too busy arguing with each other to entertain you..
Thanks..
Wasn't deemed frivolous so only one game, but how they can come to this decision is beyond me. Maybe we should get our whole team to change their names to Balotelli then we can go out to try to break the legs of the opposition and get the same punishment. The FA are of another planet or are anti QPR but either way they are showing that unless you are a big club they don't want to be bothered with you.
Awful decision. Why has common sense left football. Anyone with eyes knows that it was never a penalty due to Young being offside - surely that is the crux of it. Play should have been stopped previously therefore Derry couldn't have commited a foul. the fact that it was also a preety soft dive is neither here nor there. such a pity that noone in the FA is man enough to make the right decision rather than take the easy route and hide behind their rule book.
Compare that decision with Ledley King rugby tackling Holt in the box on Monday - seriously which of the two should be a pen and a sending off? One rule for the big clubs and one for the rest of us methinks
Compare that decision with Ledley King rugby tackling Holt in the box on Monday - seriously which of the two should be a pen and a sending off? One rule for the big clubs and one for the rest of us methinks
The best summary of the situation I've seen:
The FAâs statement confirming their decision to uphold Shaun Derryâs suspension:
âQueens Park Rangers midfielder Shaun Derry will serve a one match suspension with immediate effect after his claim of wrongful dismissal was rejected by a Regulatory Commission today [Tuesday 10 April].
Derry was dismissed for denying a goalscoring opportunity in the Premier League match against Manchester United on Sunday 8 April 2012.â
But a goal-scoring opportunity that only existed because of an officialâs mistake. And a red card that was only shown because of Ashley Youngâs simulation.
The real reason the FA has come to this baffling conclusion, is for the same reason that they make every decision â to protect themselves. Itâs about sequence. If Derry has his red card rescinded, that would have provided a precedent for reviewing the incidents that lead up to the one under review. That opens a can of worms, and probably further complicates the disciplinary procedure.
So as far as the FA are concerned, Ashley Young being clearly offside is an irrelevance. Additionally, clearing Derry puts the spotlight on Young, and why exactly he did go sprawling to the turf â the FA would in essence be saying that the Manchester United player was cheating, and presumably thereâd be some blowback about how to handle that.
This was the way to cut the head off the snake, so to speak â Derryâs red card stands, all those other problems go away.
I understand it, but itâs moronic â you have to show more common sense than that. This kind of adjudication just promotes the long-held belief that the FA is populated by suits who donât really understand the game that theyâre supposed to be governing.
Same old nonsense.
From http://thepremierleagueowl.com/2012...as-failure-to-overturn-shaun-derrys-red-card/
The FAâs statement confirming their decision to uphold Shaun Derryâs suspension:
âQueens Park Rangers midfielder Shaun Derry will serve a one match suspension with immediate effect after his claim of wrongful dismissal was rejected by a Regulatory Commission today [Tuesday 10 April].
Derry was dismissed for denying a goalscoring opportunity in the Premier League match against Manchester United on Sunday 8 April 2012.â
But a goal-scoring opportunity that only existed because of an officialâs mistake. And a red card that was only shown because of Ashley Youngâs simulation.
The real reason the FA has come to this baffling conclusion, is for the same reason that they make every decision â to protect themselves. Itâs about sequence. If Derry has his red card rescinded, that would have provided a precedent for reviewing the incidents that lead up to the one under review. That opens a can of worms, and probably further complicates the disciplinary procedure.
So as far as the FA are concerned, Ashley Young being clearly offside is an irrelevance. Additionally, clearing Derry puts the spotlight on Young, and why exactly he did go sprawling to the turf â the FA would in essence be saying that the Manchester United player was cheating, and presumably thereâd be some blowback about how to handle that.
This was the way to cut the head off the snake, so to speak â Derryâs red card stands, all those other problems go away.
I understand it, but itâs moronic â you have to show more common sense than that. This kind of adjudication just promotes the long-held belief that the FA is populated by suits who donât really understand the game that theyâre supposed to be governing.
Same old nonsense.
From http://thepremierleagueowl.com/2012...as-failure-to-overturn-shaun-derrys-red-card/
Blackburn striker Anthony Modeste has had his 3 match ban for violent conduct in Saturday's match reduced to a 1 match ban. The FA say that it was because of 'extraordinary circumstances' and having missed last night's game against Liverpool he is now available for their remaining crucial games.
Obviously the incident was not as ugly and violent as Derry's savage attack on a player he barely came in contact with. All's well in the FA so.
Obviously the incident was not as ugly and violent as Derry's savage attack on a player he barely came in contact with. All's well in the FA so.
