It's not out. He's dropped it as part of the whole "catching and movement of body" law that got Starc. I don't think it was a celebration, just the natural movement of the arms back to starting position. That is the series right there sadly
Well that's what they have said on telly, but they would ever go against whatvumpures say really . But mo doubt he was going to throw the ball up. It is highly subjective, sometimes a slip especially will throw the ball behind himself when still on the move, and it's out. Maybe that will change.
But series done anyway. Far too many dropped catches at Edgbaston and Lords. Since then England have been the better side, but you can't let a good side off the hook so often and not pay the price.

