Any idea why we've signed an under 21 goalkeeper from Newcastle on loan ?
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/footbal...west_wales&link_location=live-reporting-story
Because your 2 keepers are crap?
Any idea why we've signed an under 21 goalkeeper from Newcastle on loan ?
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/footbal...west_wales&link_location=live-reporting-story
Because your 2 keepers are crap?
Its a big risk putting your faith in youngsters in key positions.Cooper must rate this kid from Newcastle!
Its a big risk putting your faith in youngsters in key positions.
I'm all for youth (colin doesn't use youngsters enough for me), but you need experience in the spine of the team. It can be pretty lonely as a keeper if things start to go wrong and it can finish careers before they start.
I assume he's considering him for the first team as its unlikely you'd loan a player for the 23s. Why develop a youngster for someone else?

Or could Mulder or Nordsfeldt be on their way out. I am just worrying a little that the only players we are looking to sign are players he has coached as 17 year olds. who knows how they have progressed or if good enough.I would tend to agree with you. That said
Martyn Margetson has coached the lad so they must believe that he can do the job.
His father is/was Gareth Southgate’s best friend - they wrote a ‘joint’ book about their friendship - Woody and Nord. Worth a read![]()
I did wonder that myself - given they want to save cash, having 3 ‘first team squad’ keepers seems an extravagance - especially with Benda in the U21s as potential back up should an injury be picked up by Woody (if he’s ‘The Man’) - can’t see Newcastle wanting to loan him unless he was guaranteed a shot at being Number 1Or could Mulder or Nordsfeldt be on their way out. I am just worrying a little that the only players we are looking to sign are players he has coached as 17 year olds. who knows how they have progressed or if good enough.

So it's 'jobs for the boys' basically ?I would tend to agree with you. That said
Martyn Margetson has coached the lad so they must believe that he can do the job.
His father is/was Gareth Southgate’s best friend - they wrote a ‘joint’ book about their friendship - Woody and Nord. Worth a read![]()
that's what I said is worrying me. we just cant sign players because he has worked with them before all the time.So it's 'jobs for the boys' basically ?
that's what I said is worrying me. we just cant sign players because he has worked with them before all the time.

they were senior players though, I don't mind that. most of these are kids. that's why I am not sure about it.I wouldn’t disagree with that, although a certain Brian Clough did ok with that approach!![]()
Good pointthey were senior players though, I don't mind that. most of these are kids. that's why I am not sure about it.


I agree Phil, but if they clicked, Baston, Pederson & Ayew would be a pretty formidable attack in the Championship.Looks like we could be using A Ayew this season, we have not been able to offload him, maybe he will pull his finger out and recover his career, and yes pigs can fly!!.............![]()

That said, we can but hope .....I agree Phil, but if they clicked, Baston, Pederson & Ayew would be a pretty formidable attack in the Championship.![]()
I suspect that keeping and integrating Baston would tend to suggest that they were expecting Oli’s departure.We need Ayew atm as an option. The club should have forecast on a Striker than a Keeper we dont need. There has been plenty of time since it was just a rumour that Oli was wanted.....No preparation nothing incase he was sold and now it has happened and we are left with no recognized goal scorer.....What was Birch and Cooper thinking ffs......Shows his inexperience there.....

I agree Dai - but the focus of the owners is to prioritise Cash.But Taff there is no benefit in raking in £17m rising to £20m if he does well and not spending some of it on investment on players we need....Our defence is not good as it is and now we have to take a chance on two players that were rubbish before upfront.....It is a hell of a risk imo..