Why? I think it's a bit offensive to existing players tbh. Every other team forum on this website has current fave players, but we have to resort to old players who haven't been here for decades?
To me it just adds to the impression people have that Newcastle fans are stuck in the past after the CL matches we had. If I come on this forum I wanna see the players who are gonna take us forward here and now. Ben Arfa, Tiote and so on. It gets me much more excited than a load of retired players from past generations.