Archant are running a 'LIVE REACTION' website - well over 80% in favour f the appointment!!!
Alex Neil
- Thread starter zelleryellow
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
I find that honestly astonishing. I doubt there are any "known" managers we could have appointed who would attract that amount of favour... All have too much of a past
Let's hope it doesn't bite us, as I really don't think we should raise expectations too high. Though it suggests that support will be really roaring next home game with fans, players and manager nearly all on the same page for the first time really since Lambert left
Fans tend to follow their managers lead. Under Lambert we all had the never say die attitude. Under Hughton we were all a bit quiet. Under Adams we didn't know what we were doing - do we sing his name, do we boo?
Alex Neil both his name and the instruction he had to follow to get the job.........
.....I honestly know nothing about the bloke, I think if he is a success or not depends on your players buying into him and giving their full commitment which from outside could be what let NA down..
.....I honestly know nothing about the bloke, I think if he is a success or not depends on your players buying into him and giving their full commitment which from outside could be what let NA down..
Good spot Supers. I expect the Cardiff game will now be 'sold out!!!'
that's exactly what I meant Rob, thanks for clearing that up for me!
I do applaud Norwich for finally realising they were getting too big headed, six months ago they were after Celtics manager, now the more realistic target Hamilton Accies manager!
good lesson for everybody that.
A brief interview with AN. He only wants to bring his assistant in - MP et al are staying!!!
http://www.edp24.co.uk/sport/norwic...nfirmed_as_new_norwich_city_manager_1_3910938
http://www.edp24.co.uk/sport/norwic...nfirmed_as_new_norwich_city_manager_1_3910938
Not at all.
Could you please work on providing the evidence requested to back up several of your posts. Not for my benefit, of course, but to pacify the inexplicable doubters that you are honest and credible.
Very much appreciated
Just had a quick look at AN career I think that Warnock has managed more teams than AN has managed Games.
I think Colin has FAILED more managerial posts than AN has managed games!
Have to say that I've spent the past couple of days trying to get my head round all this, and regardless what angle I'm looking at it form I have to admit the one word that keeps coming up in my head is "bonkers".
I'll also admit that other than reading the sound-bites and bits coming out from Hamilton, I know absolutely nothing about this guy at all apart from the fact he's 33, has been a manager for around 18 months and during that incredibly short period of time he has had a bit of success for a small team with very limited expectations, so I accept that I'm no oracle on what he's going to be bringing to the table - but then surely none of us are, and all the positivity I'm reading on here and everywhere is surely based on not much more than wishful thinking and us hoping for the best as I wouldn't say his achievements north of the border are any indication of success down here in a far, far more difficult league - don't forget the SPL is a shocking standard at the moment, with the likes of Hibs, Hearts or Rangers not even in the top flight.
This is a massive step into the unknown and a hell of a risk at a time when most of us had accepted that this year provides our best chance of bouncing back before our best players get poached/decide they want to leave. He might well be a huge success, he might well have a massive future in the game and he might well go all the way to the top as one of his former players has said of him, but we've got hardly anything so far to base this on as his career has been so short and has provided quite a different challenge to the one the Carra Rud gig offers.
One of the big criticisms of Adams when he got the job initially was that he wouldn't be a name that would entice some of our squad to stay with us and he wouldn't be able to attract the type of players that would take us forward, however nobody seems concerned about this at all with this chap. In fact nobody seems to be concerned at all and everyone (even Carrabuh, which I'm absolutely astonished about) seem to have bought into this already and I have to say the level of positivity flowing from every outlet rather taken me aback somewhat, though I'd also say it has left me pleasantly surprised. I say this because regardless of whether I agree with the decision I will always get behind the manager and give him my full support (I even backed the Rodent until he completely lost the plot by releasing Hucks), and I really, really hope that this does turn out to be a masterstroke by the board and Alex Neil goes on to be as big a success (bigger if possible) that Paul Lambert was, a manager that left me equally underwhelmed when he was first appointed so I guess stranger things have happened.
I just didn't expect this at all, I thought the board had learned about taking risks at this stage of the club's history with Adams and gone down the tried and tested route, especially in the short-term. Probably should have accepted that nothing surprises us any more with our club, so Mr.Neil certainly has my full backing now he has the job and I look forward to seeing what he's going to bring.
Just as a final point, I think some of the stuff written about Adams' reign is a bit OTT to me. Stuff is being written as though his time as manager was nothing but disaster after disaster and that everything he did turned to sh1t, which it clearly didn't. Absolute rubbish that is, he leaves us in 7th place, three points off the play-offs, just ten points off the top with a +15 goal difference and in a far better position to have a crack at promotion in the second half of the season than either Cardiff or Fulham who came down with us. We've scored 11 goals in our last two home games and have only been beaten once in the league by more than a single goal (away the the team currently fourth). People seem to re-writing history to make him out to be far worse than he actually was, which provides quite a dis-service to the man and what he did in the first few months of this season - it's very difficult turning a squad of players with a losing mentality into winners, I thought Neeyul was doing ok personally and find some of the stuff I've read quite disrespectful if I'm being honest. That said, I I can understand why the board made the decision to replace Adams, however I'm a little flummoxed why it has been with someone with marginally more experience (albeit at an inferior standard at a club with vastly different expectation levels/operating budget/fan base) with a heck of a lot still to prove.
Hopefully he'll prove it all with us and become a club legend, just a hell of a risk if you ask me, and this was a risk most people weren't interested in pre-season but now appear to be more prepared to swallow for some reason.
It's definitely an interesting appointment at least, let's see what happens
I'll also admit that other than reading the sound-bites and bits coming out from Hamilton, I know absolutely nothing about this guy at all apart from the fact he's 33, has been a manager for around 18 months and during that incredibly short period of time he has had a bit of success for a small team with very limited expectations, so I accept that I'm no oracle on what he's going to be bringing to the table - but then surely none of us are, and all the positivity I'm reading on here and everywhere is surely based on not much more than wishful thinking and us hoping for the best as I wouldn't say his achievements north of the border are any indication of success down here in a far, far more difficult league - don't forget the SPL is a shocking standard at the moment, with the likes of Hibs, Hearts or Rangers not even in the top flight.
This is a massive step into the unknown and a hell of a risk at a time when most of us had accepted that this year provides our best chance of bouncing back before our best players get poached/decide they want to leave. He might well be a huge success, he might well have a massive future in the game and he might well go all the way to the top as one of his former players has said of him, but we've got hardly anything so far to base this on as his career has been so short and has provided quite a different challenge to the one the Carra Rud gig offers.
One of the big criticisms of Adams when he got the job initially was that he wouldn't be a name that would entice some of our squad to stay with us and he wouldn't be able to attract the type of players that would take us forward, however nobody seems concerned about this at all with this chap. In fact nobody seems to be concerned at all and everyone (even Carrabuh, which I'm absolutely astonished about) seem to have bought into this already and I have to say the level of positivity flowing from every outlet rather taken me aback somewhat, though I'd also say it has left me pleasantly surprised. I say this because regardless of whether I agree with the decision I will always get behind the manager and give him my full support (I even backed the Rodent until he completely lost the plot by releasing Hucks), and I really, really hope that this does turn out to be a masterstroke by the board and Alex Neil goes on to be as big a success (bigger if possible) that Paul Lambert was, a manager that left me equally underwhelmed when he was first appointed so I guess stranger things have happened.
I just didn't expect this at all, I thought the board had learned about taking risks at this stage of the club's history with Adams and gone down the tried and tested route, especially in the short-term. Probably should have accepted that nothing surprises us any more with our club, so Mr.Neil certainly has my full backing now he has the job and I look forward to seeing what he's going to bring.
Just as a final point, I think some of the stuff written about Adams' reign is a bit OTT to me. Stuff is being written as though his time as manager was nothing but disaster after disaster and that everything he did turned to sh1t, which it clearly didn't. Absolute rubbish that is, he leaves us in 7th place, three points off the play-offs, just ten points off the top with a +15 goal difference and in a far better position to have a crack at promotion in the second half of the season than either Cardiff or Fulham who came down with us. We've scored 11 goals in our last two home games and have only been beaten once in the league by more than a single goal (away the the team currently fourth). People seem to re-writing history to make him out to be far worse than he actually was, which provides quite a dis-service to the man and what he did in the first few months of this season - it's very difficult turning a squad of players with a losing mentality into winners, I thought Neeyul was doing ok personally and find some of the stuff I've read quite disrespectful if I'm being honest. That said, I I can understand why the board made the decision to replace Adams, however I'm a little flummoxed why it has been with someone with marginally more experience (albeit at an inferior standard at a club with vastly different expectation levels/operating budget/fan base) with a heck of a lot still to prove.
Hopefully he'll prove it all with us and become a club legend, just a hell of a risk if you ask me, and this was a risk most people weren't interested in pre-season but now appear to be more prepared to swallow for some reason.
It's definitely an interesting appointment at least, let's see what happens
Have to say that I've spent the past couple of days trying to get my head round all this, and regardless what angle I'm looking at it form I have to admit the one word that keeps coming up in my head is "bonkers".
I'll also admit that other than reading the sound-bites and bits coming out from Hamilton, I know absolutely nothing about this guy at all apart from the fact he's 33, has been a manager for around 18 months and during that incredibly short period of time he has had a bit of success for a small team with very limited expectations, so I accept that I'm no oracle on what he's going to be bringing to the table - but then surely none of us are, and all the positivity I'm reading on here and everywhere is surely based on not much more than wishful thinking and us hoping for the best as I wouldn't say his achievements north of the border are any indication of success down here in a far, far more difficult league - don't forget the SPL is a shocking standard at the moment, with the likes of Hibs, Hearts or Rangers not even in the top flight.
This is a massive step into the unknown and a hell of a risk at a time when most of us had accepted that this year provides our best chance of bouncing back before our best players get poached/decide they want to leave. He might well be a huge success, he might well have a massive future in the game and he might well go all the way to the top as one of his former players has said of him, but we've got hardly anything so far to base this on as his career has been so short and has provided quite a different challenge to the one the Carra Rud gig offers.
One of the big criticisms of Adams when he got the job initially was that he wouldn't be a name that would entice some of our squad to stay with us and he wouldn't be able to attract the type of players that would take us forward, however nobody seems concerned about this at all with this chap. In fact nobody seems to be concerned at all and everyone (even Carrabuh, which I'm absolutely astonished about) seem to have bought into this already and I have to say the level of positivity flowing from every outlet rather taken me aback somewhat, though I'd also say it has left me pleasantly surprised. I say this because regardless of whether I agree with the decision I will always get behind the manager and give him my full support (I even backed the Rodent until he completely lost the plot by releasing Hucks), and I really, really hope that this does turn out to be a masterstroke by the board and Alex Neil goes on to be as big a success (bigger if possible) that Paul Lambert was, a manager that left me equally underwhelmed when he was first appointed so I guess stranger things have happened.
I just didn't expect this at all, I thought the board had learned about taking risks at this stage of the club's history with Adams and gone down the tried and tested route, especially in the short-term. Probably should have accepted that nothing surprises us any more with our club, so Mr.Neil certainly has my full backing now he has the job and I look forward to seeing what he's going to bring.
Just as a final point, I think some of the stuff written about Adams' reign is a bit OTT to me. Stuff is being written as though his time as manager was nothing but disaster after disaster and that everything he did turned to sh1t, which it clearly didn't. Absolute rubbish that is, he leaves us in 7th place, three points off the play-offs, just ten points off the top with a +15 goal difference and in a far better position to have a crack at promotion in the second half of the season than either Cardiff or Fulham who came down with us. We've scored 11 goals in our last two home games and have only been beaten once in the league by more than a single goal (away the the team currently fourth). People seem to re-writing history to make him out to be far worse than he actually was, which provides quite a dis-service to the man and what he did in the first few months of this season - it's very difficult turning a squad of players with a losing mentality into winners, I thought Neeyul was doing ok personally and find some of the stuff I've read quite disrespectful if I'm being honest. That said, I I can understand why the board made the decision to replace Adams, however I'm a little flummoxed why it has been with someone with marginally more experience (albeit at an inferior standard at a club with vastly different expectation levels/operating budget/fan base) with a heck of a lot still to prove.
Hopefully he'll prove it all with us and become a club legend, just a hell of a risk if you ask me, and this was a risk most people weren't interested in pre-season but now appear to be more prepared to swallow for some reason.
It's definitely an interesting appointment at least, let's see what happens
some sanity at last!
You ought to be a bit worried Munky - Hinge and Bracket agree with you!!some sanity at last!
some sanity at last!
Hmmm, perhaps not quite the endorsement I was looking for, but I guess at least someone agrees with me