Off Topic Afcftw Mafia Game

[Swarbs]

I don't see the point in putting them in a 50/50, mafia aren't stupid enough to try save their mate in such a situation.

If the info is correct mito is mafia and tobes is either mafia or Pablo (or maybe even SK). We HAVE to lynch Tobes in that case, if he is Pablo he could survive the cointoss and recruit, then we could spend days trying to find the recruit. We can always go for Mito the next day, and after lynching tobes we'll know if the info was correct.

Vote Tobes. Yes we can.

But remember that if the info is true then MITO is the Mafia killer, the Mafia still have a kill left, and Valley has just revealed that he is our most powerful asset. Tobes could just be a random Mafia goon.

So if we lynch Tobes tonight we guarantee that Valley is killed and we lose our last remaining good investigator.

 

[ValleyGraduate12]

Tobes

 

[Tobes]

**** sake lads, read post [HASHTAG]#536[/HASHTAG].

I investigated Tobes. He's is a non town member.

On my way home, I spotted mito running from the scene of the crime with a bloodied knife in his hand. I just happened to see MITO running away. There wasn't a second investigation.

But the detective is dead.

You must be the pissed version who's only got a 2/3 success rate, and you've some how supposedly uncovered 2 non town in one evening. Yeah right oh.

 

[Super G Ted'inho]

I don't see the point in putting them in a 50/50, mafia aren't stupid enough to try save their mate in such a situation.

If the info is correct mito is mafia and tobes is either mafia or Pablo (or maybe even SK). We HAVE to lynch Tobes in that case, if he is Pablo he could survive the cointoss and recruit, then we could spend days trying to find the recruit. We can always go for Mito the next day, and after lynching tobes we'll know if the info was correct.

Vote Tobes. Yes we can.

In the OP they are listed as town roles. Kind of like the vigilante, they could do damage to town but are town aligned i would think

The SK is also listed as town ATM which means Tobes is Mafia or Cartel of Valleys claim is true.

I vote Tobes

 

[ValleyGraduate12]

But remember that if the info is true then MITO is the Mafia killer, the Mafia still have a kill left, and Valley has just revealed that he is our most powerful asset. Tobes could just be a random Mafia goon.

So if we lynch Tobes tonight we guarantee that Valley is killed and we lose our last remaining good investigator.

Kill their hitman Tobes.

 

[BobbyD]

No brainer. Valley has come out as the psychic. Bit too early for my liking. Doubt mafia would put themselves up for it unless its their secret power to make valley do things.

Tobes

Hopefully tobes isnt a townie and we finally pick off a bad guy.

Not sure why valley would come out so early though.... only thing suspcious for me. And the double statement

 

[Lucaaas]

I think its pretty telling that MITO has gone awfully quiet though? From one of the most active to saying nothing in like 20 mins.

 

[Swarbs]

**** sake lads, read post [HASHTAG]#536[/HASHTAG].

I investigated Tobes. He's is a non town member.

On my way home, I spotted mito running from the scene of the crime with a bloodied knife in his hand. I just happened to see MITO running away. There wasn't a second investigation.

Ok, I can believe that, but WTF have you just told the Mafia you are the psychic when they have a kill left and there's no doctor to protect you?

It basically means you are guaranteed to die tonight, and the town has just lost their best source of info, when the serial killer, cartel and two other Mafia are still out there and Tobes can only be one of them.

 

[Lord Jonjomort]

But the detective is dead.

You must be the pissed version who's only got a 2/3 success rate, and you've some how supposedly uncovered 2 non town in one evening. Yeah right oh.

No, he's not - he's a psychic, he's merely finger pointing at MITO, which he can do, as we all can.

 

[Lord Jonjomort]

Following the visions of Derek Acorah, I'll also vote Tobes

 

[Super G Ted'inho]

What if the Mafia's secret power is a heavy? They could have forced Valley to make one or both of the claims

Interesting that Valley hasn't said anything else and he's liking all comments where Tobes or Mito have been voted for.

@Valley... Are you able to say anything else?

 

[Swarbs]

Kill their hitman MITO.

I suppose that makes sense.

- If MITO is the hitman then we take away the Mafia's ability to kill you
- Worst case scenario, Tobes is Pablo. So he recruits someone tomorrow but we kill him then the cartel is left with one powerless member and you will still be alive so we can find him

Sounds good to me, I vote MITO

 

[Joelinton's Right Foot]

I think its pretty telling that MITO has gone awfully quiet though? From one of the most active to saying nothing in like 20 mins.

This is what struck me.

I think we know Tobes is non-town but we know MITO is the killer - unless Valley is Mafia. I can't see Mafia blowing their good start though by coming out of the woodwork like that unless they were very silly or very greedy. For that reason I think the ONLY person we can really trust right now is Valley.

And for that reason I will go with Valley's reasonings and vote MITO

 

[moreinjuredthanowen]

Ok guys I just read something interesting.

An investigation last night and Tobes was identified as not being a member of the Town.

The poster who kept changing votes in the last few moments was seen running away with a bloodied knife in his hand near IBWTs sliced and diced body. This person is a Liverpool MOD.

ok guys this is where it gets interesting

please settle in for a tale of woe

.......................................................

1. Please all re-read these rules:

Detective - the detective can investigate one person each night by sending a PM to me. The detective will learn whether the target is mafia, cartel, has a role or is a normal town person. The detective is always on the lookout and may receive further information beyond his investigations.

Doctor - the doctor can protect one person each night, but cannot protect the same person on two nights running.

Psychic - the psychic spends his time studying the mystic and is able to read the aura of other town members. The psychic can choose to investigate one person each night but will only receive a town, or non-town read.

Town Drunk (Alcoholic PI) - once upon a time a great detective with a bright future but after falling to the bottom of a bottle and losing his job he started his own private investigation service. The only problem is, he hasn't put down the bottle. He can investigate one person each night but with blurry vision will only get a correct investigation 2/3 times. Bumbling drunk, or town saviour?

2. Valley here is accusing someone of killing IBWT.

Well here it is. Valley has unfortunately claimed two things here

2.a Tobes is non town. If true this is important. he could be cartel perhaps.

2.b Valley is claiming by coming out as the psychic that in effect he ALSO say an LFC mod kill IBWT. this unfortunately doesn't add up at all as tobes is not an lfc mod so is he following two people?

so valley somehow investigated tobes but saw a lfc mod also kill IBWT.


are we all following so far?

Right lets get down to it.

3. I know half of what is going on.

There are hidden rules so this could all be forced upon valley but her eis the thing.

I KNOW which mod killed IBWT..

I had the great pleasure in sticking it to IBWT. SHOCK... the truth is i was forced to do it by mafia. they held my family and forced me to do it.

Here is the other thing

4. I AM THE TOWN DRUNK

yes sob it is true. my name is mito and i am an alcoholic.

I have to come out now unfortunately on night one. My tactic today was to look so ridiculous nobody uold risk recruiting me or killing me

But good news. my imprending doom will be not for naught.

I did get a piece of info which i will now reveal.

I chose Sir tennisball as a potential lurker and investigated. Please bear in mind info is only 2/3 right at best.

I got the result that sir tennisball is MAFIA

..............................................

so now you all must decide.

Has some hidden mafia power chosen valley and sneakily revealed that i was picked to kill IBWT?

Has he come back with REAL or FAKE info to us.

Are all the towns investigators right now out in the open?

you all have to decide.

as of now:

1. Tobes is under direct suspicison. He could be the cartel boss and chose one of billy and IBWT to recruit and failed. he could be mafia.

2. Valley has to be under suspicision. As the psychic he would get the non town read but how did he get the extra info.. ONLY ibwt should have got that and he died. the only explaination is he was fed it too. I did call him out along with others so mafia might have used it

3. Sir tennis ball MIGHT be mafia. he is 2/3 maifa from my investigate

4. I am the town drunk. I did investigate and i did kill IBWT. I am giving myself up as I think a one for one exchange of investigator for mafia is a good exchange.

You can all judge for yourselves who is dodgiest and who to kill but I am being totally straight with you and say IMO the other 3 are very dodgy so Id welcome you killing me now i have got the info out. MAKE SURE YOU KILL THE OTHERS.

I am now changing my investigate to valley for tomorrow night

 

[moreinjuredthanowen]

This is what struck me.

I think we know Tobes is non-town but we know MITO is the killer - unless Valley is Mafia. I can't see Mafia blowing their good start though by coming out of the woodwork like that unless they were very silly or very greedy. For that reason I think the ONLY person we can really trust right now is Valley.

And for that reason I will go with Valley's reasonings and vote MITO

It took me 20 mins to type what i just did. read and see. thats why i was quiet.

big info

 

[Sir Tennisball]

But remember that if the info is true then MITO is the Mafia killer, the Mafia still have a kill left, and Valley has just revealed that he is our most powerful asset. Tobes could just be a random Mafia goon.

So if we lynch Tobes tonight we guarantee that Valley is killed and we lose our last remaining good investigator.

You could be right, but i understood the OP to imply there aren't specific mafia roles like assassin etc. i thought they are general mafia and get a collective 2 kills. In that case they could kill Valley regardless of whether Mito gets lynched. Although they may only be able to kill in a few days time as the OP keeps it vague... I just think Pablo is the main target atm.

 

[moreinjuredthanowen]

again for the record I am happy that Valley has at least named tobes as well.

I saw sir tennisball.

that means the town have 2 clear targets even if you have to kill me by lynch tomorrow to prove it.

please town killing roles target the two.

 

[Tobes]

So the supposed mystic says I'm not town, but also comes out with some tale of seeing the mafia killer and you're lapping this **** up?

FFS you're all so ****ing gullible. Why come out at this point and then embellish the story with a double 'vision'

Lynch away lads - again ffs

 

[Lucaaas]

Maybe Valley got extra info because the Mafia have the secret ability to feed false information to him?

 

[Mikey]

My head hurts.