Yeah, it just doesn't add up. And it would just make the game too easy if you saw who was killing who on the first night.
Off Topic Afcftw Mafia Game
- Thread starter afcftw
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
- Status
Yeah, it just doesn't add up. And it would just make the game too easy if you saw who was killing who on the first night.
Oh do **** off with more of this secret info which may or may not be true!
So if I interpret this right:
If 1. is true then Valley is Mafia and not psychic
If 2. is true then Nobby is town drunk and not MITO
If 3. is true then Mikey is Mafia? Or some weird secret role
Can't believe 1. as if Valley is Mafia why would he out himself? If we kill MITO or Tobes and they aren't Mafia then we go straight for Valley
Could possibly believe 2, as MITO claiming town drunk is quite convenient - if Sir Tennisball isn't Mafia then he can just say it was his 1/3 chance of being wrong
No idea about 2!!
S
Super G Ted'inho
Guest
Having read that again i think mito is scrambling and trying to bluff us.
Read his points 3 & 4:
3. Sir tennis ball MIGHT be mafia. he is 2/3 maifa from my investigate
4. I am the town drunk. I did investigate and i did kill IBWT
How can you investigate both myself and IBWT in one night? BOOM, busted!
What do you guys think?
EDIT: After reading it all yet again I misunderstood mito I think. He's saying he investigated me and killed IBWT, he's not saying he investigated both of us and then killed IBWT...
Read his points 3 & 4:
3. Sir tennis ball MIGHT be mafia. he is 2/3 maifa from my investigate
4. I am the town drunk. I did investigate and i did kill IBWT
How can you investigate both myself and IBWT in one night? BOOM, busted!
What do you guys think?
EDIT: After reading it all yet again I misunderstood mito I think. He's saying he investigated me and killed IBWT, he's not saying he investigated both of us and then killed IBWT...
Last edited:
S
Super G Ted'inho
Guest
Have you not seen Most Haunted? Derek Ackora used to have visions scratching his arse.
Like I've said, I was walking home, and I saw MITO running away.
So you didn't actually see him kill anyone? Which makes me think he could be being framed here.
Lads, can I say that I have not said that MITO is Mafia, that I do not know. All I saw was him running away with a bloodied knife.
don't forget obi wan is not aligned to anyone and can help or hinder the town.
I am 100% the town drunk
there are 3 things that can be done
1. valley can investigate me.
2. the killers can kill me
3. the town can lynch me.
At this point I'll say this again
A 1 for 1 exchange of town investigator for non investigator is a GOOD exchange. I have zero to lose by coming out.
the reverse is not true a mafia for one town is not a good exchange at all lads. you know this. YOu have to suspect my motivation was to simply defend myself by coming out after valley.
He is putting out a lot of info and making a lot of claims. I've never seen him make a table that detailed before, so possibly something to hide behind all that info?
Also Obi Wan's info implies that Nobby may be the town drunk, which would contradict what MITO claims.
IMO the choice is still:
1. Lynch Tobes, best case kill Pablo, worst case kill random Mafia whilst Mafia kills Valley
2. Lynch MITO, best case kill Mafia hitman, worst case kill random Mafia whilst Tobes recruits
I'd still lean towards MITO, as we can always kill Tobes tomorrow.
exactly.
you have said
1. tobes is non town
2. you saw me with bloody knife.
I am the one confirming point 2. I am not going to say what was in my pm. what i will say is it did say knife but not bloody. It was more descriptive of why i was forced to kill IBWT so im not bothered baout the lack of similarity.
I am the one saying hey the rules show you cannot be detective I suppose you could be the random nutjob role but your description makes you sound like the psychic
obi wan is having fun. he is not town aligned. have fun with that.
in the end we got info you have to decide yourselves who you trust with info.
let me be clear.
I killed IBWT. the mafia took my family and left a picutre of them with a gun to their heads.. they forced this poor drunk to go knife ibwt.
On the way back i saw sir tennis and my result was MAFIA... again it can't be 100% due to rules.
again you'd be fools to at least not test that one out.
Even if he isn't, you let everyone think that and made him come out which means 2 of our detectives are out in the open now (if you're both telling the truth).
- Status