Henderson for Neil ...

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Not for me. For a few reasons really. Firstly, Saudi. Secondly, he looks really poor and leggy. Thirdly, we don't need to be blocking pathways anymore, our midfield is in good shape, another body in there will disrupt the balance.

Shame really as a few years ago I held him in unbelievably high regard.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ayrton, clockstander, Montysoptician and 5 others
Already filled that spot with Browne and he would be on top wage with no guarantee of game time. Said in past id love him back here but time isn’t right. I do think he’ll be a quality coach if he goes down that route. Gaffer in 5 years with LON as number 2?
 
  • Like
Reactions: C Montgomery Burns and Smug in Boots
If it was last season when he left Saudi, I would've said yes but as others have said, we've got a good set up at the minute with young rising players such as Rigg and Jobe, Dan Neil behind them (for me anyways) then the new lads still to play in midfield. Plus if he can't get a game for Ajax with the level they are at in the Eredivisie, he'll struggle at Sunderland
 
  • Like
Reactions: Robertson
I can't remember ever being so disappointed with a Sunderland player.

Some players have let us down, such as Bent, but they're not 'one of us' so don't matter.

Henderson is a local lad who knew how people felt about the Saudis but took the money anyway.

There were dozens of clubs he could've gone to but greed, above ambition, was the deciding factor.

That's exactly the kind of influence we should do everything we can to keep away from SAFC.

Henderson's life will now be an empty sharade where he'll be welcome nowhere.

I wouldn't have him back at Sunderland if he wanted to work for nothing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: clockstander, cumbrianmackem, LAMackem and 6 others
Can’t see what the problem is with hendo going to Saudi?

What does that have to do with our club?
 
Worth pointing out most of our fans were saying they wouldn’t take Maja back anarl…

IMO Henderson could be a massive asset both on and off the pitch, one of the best leaders of the modern game at Liverpool and that’s something we clearly lack.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bazza2310
WorkyTicketFTM said:
Worth pointing out most of our fans were saying they wouldn’t take Maja back anarl…

IMO Henderson could be a massive asset both on and off the pitch, one of the best leaders of the modern game at Liverpool and that’s something we clearly lack.
Click to expand...

That may be true but who would you drop to make way for him?
 
WorkyTicketFTM said:
Worth pointing out most of our fans were saying they wouldn’t take Maja back anarl…

IMO Henderson could be a massive asset both on and off the pitch, one of the best leaders of the modern game at Liverpool and that’s something we clearly lack.
Click to expand...
If I'm honest I don't see him as a much better leader than LON who lives and breaths this club and was never a local.
You don't have to be born on Wearside to allow this club to get under your skin. Me included.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LAMackem, Nordic, Jarca and 13 others
cumbrianmackem said:
If I'm honest I don't see him as a much better leader than LON who lives and breaths this club and was never a local.
You don't have to be born on Wearside to allow this club to get under your skin. Me included.
Click to expand...

Sorry, but that is absolute nonsense. Whether you like him or not, he won both the PL and CL whilst playing at a much higher level than we are currently at and captaining much better players for both club and country. To even mention O’nien in the same breathe as him is laughable.. That Liverpool team were one of the best to ever play in the PL. Nothing to do with him being a local lad.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wes and Bazza2310
WorkyTicketFTM said:
Sorry, but that is absolute nonsense. Whether you like him or not, he won both the PL and CL whilst playing at a much higher level than we are currently at and captaining much better players for both club and country. To even mention O’nien in the same breathe as him is laughable.. That Liverpool team were one of the best to ever play in the PL. Nothing to do with him being a local lad.
Click to expand...
All about opinions mate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Makemstine Roger
Essayyeffcee said:
That may be true but who would you drop to make way for him?
Click to expand...

We’d have Henderson/Samed as the options at DM and Neil/Rigg/Bellingham/Browne for the other two midfield positions. I’ve said for a long time I don’t think Neil is as good as some make out and I stand by that, he’s decent at this level but he’s not a stand out performer for me. How often do you come away from games and say “Wow Neil was brilliant today wasn’t he?”

You look at Bellingham, he looks quality and he’s 4 years younger than Neil. He takes games by the scruff of the neck already and tries to make things happen. Rigg shows glimpses of real class albeit he’s still very young and looks to be more of a 60 minute player at the minute. If Neil was as good as people make out he should be head and shoulders above this level by now and I’m not sure he is. Do I think we’d be any worse off having Henderson in the team over Neil as the 6? Absolutely not. He obviously won’t have the legs he used to but plenty of other teams in the division have older lads as their 6 and they manage fine. The experience he’d bring in would be invaluable, it would be like having another manager on the pitch.

All just my own opinion of course I totally understand people arguing it’s a backward move when we have young lads playing well who don’t deserve to be dropped. He could come in and be useless for all we know but I think it’s worth a shot, we all wanted it before he went to Saudi and there was rumours
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bazza2310
Evil Jimmy Krankie said:
As much as I rate Henderson as a player I still can’t get past his move to Saudi. I know it’s been said that any one of us would do the same thing and that may well be correct. But I just struggle with his very blatant hypocrisy. Sad really as I would have loved to have seen him end his career in a Sunderland shirt. As already said, that ship has sailed.
Click to expand...

does your ability to not see past his move to Saudi extend to the abundance of lads from the north east who work for Middle Eastern oil and gas operators?

not entirely sure what this sentiment achieves and where the line is drawn
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bazza2310
As a few have said,
Would have him back but only as part of the coaching set up,
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back