This is our strongest line up. Although (and I recognise that this might cause a right flap on), I'd have Rodwell or Pienaar ahead of Cattermole.
If he headed three off the line and scored the last minute winner some will still find a reason to criticise him for summat in the game. People just will see that he is our continuity player who gets a majority right but is left adrift by others. Khazri and others want shooting for their contribution to Everton's first goal.
Sounds like a CB to me. That is where he (Rodwell) belongs.
I agree. With every word. Think you're making my argument for me but probably wording it better. I never argue whether people are realistic or not whether positive or negative. Just that negative people who say they are "realistic" are normally insinuating that positive people aren't realistic.
Can't start Khazri on what I've seen of him so far. Just doesn't look bothered enough to me, Gooch for him and I'd take it
Cattermole is a good leader and his contribution when our backs against the wall is extremely valuable. Looking at the Squawka stats from last season though, Rodwell's are better (but only slightly) than Cattermole's, especially in defensive terms. Which just shows that, like you've said, the criticism of Rodwell is not really justified. I think perhaps Cattermole is a more visible defensive presence but Rodwell goes about his defensive work in a quieter manner. Maybe against Spurs we need that blood and thunder approach; I just prefer a more elegant footballer.
In all seriousness, mate. I hope he doesn't. For his sake, he needs a rest and games back in the youth team. We don't want him burning out and he needs time to evaluate his game, because he's very raw and not quite ready to be playing consistently. However, at the moment we haven't got many alternatives.
