Town Of Salem

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
moreinjuredthanowen said:
1. I think the role claimed and results confused things. I don't understand the result compared to the rule book for the role.

2. ACS claimed this prior to the paper. This as in case he died. I thought nah you are never dying if you are in a tie lynch vote. however another person did die.. and i expected more. therefore I think this helps him cos barring mafia having investigated beardlsey using Consigliere role and knowing then why take the risk???

3. Mafia have 3 people v 5 town. unless theres vampires or werewolves rising in my view there's an easy mafia win on the cards so the risk only makes sense if he thought he'd be lynched for sure tonight again.... agai nif someone is lyning about a role then the real investigator knows it and despite the sheriff being topped as well they need ot thnk hard cos holding on prob plays into mafia hands.

4. down to ACS to say what you are next penfold. you survived again.. as i said I if were mafia I'd be concerned about you so the fact is <whistle> here you are... I'm easily led astray but you... you're too good at this but thats my thing.. here you are still... why have you not got killed...
Click to expand...
Possibly because they are reading this thread and thinking Penfold could be next on the lynching list and why bother.

And last night I was one of the ones tied and why risk a killing on someone who could be lynched.

Simples.

Does this mean I have to die on night 1 or 2 just to prove I'm Town/Good Guy?
 
Roles:

Mafia 1: godfather?
Mafia 2:
Mafia 3

ARSONIST: (i got doused)

Neutral: ? don't know what

Sheriff: Dead
Doctor: dead
bodygaurd: dead
Investigator: claimed by ACS

Vigilante - one kill per night; but if he kills an innocent will immediately take his own life. Isn't able to shoot on the first night phase.
Veteran - a man/woman of many battles, can be on alert three times and will kill anyone who visits.
Lookout - will peer through the curtains and see who visits their chosen viewee.
Escort - can block someone from their role each night. Only exception is Serial Killer, who will automatically kill the Escort.
Medium - can talk to the dead via the QT Dead Board.

What has town got left?
an a vigilante who has not killed? worrie dif he gets it wrong he dies. well its 50/50 choice now.
A veteran who is a passive kill who waits for someone to happen by
a look out who sees who visits if any.
Escort who blocks roles.
Medium who talks to dead

Its not rocket science for mafia to know what these are either. the three mafia just need to kill eveyone else and thier choice for attack is simply who don't kill them.
 
Penfold's Adviser said:
Possibly because they are reading this thread and thinking Penfold could be next on the lynching list and why bother.

And last night I was one of the ones tied and why risk a killing on someone who could be lynched.

Simples.

Does this mean I have to die on night 1 or 2 just to prove I'm Town/Good Guy?
Click to expand...

hmmm valley and Beardsley better targets than you? you know thats my point and they've passed you up twice... can't deny that. your point on tie is valid though..

thats all i have to go on. Acs needs to speak up when he gets back form the pool or the massage or whatever filth he's up to.
 
moreinjuredthanowen said:
hmmm valley and Beardsley better targets than you? you know thats my point and they've passed you up twice... can't deny that. your point on tie is valid though..

thats all i have to go on. Acs needs to speak up when he gets back form the pool or the massage or whatever filth he's up to.
Click to expand...

Mind you, they also seem to have passed you uo and No Chance and G and Bisc.

In regards to Valley who do you go for when you have no info and may want to direct attention to Toon fans as opposed to, just say, Liverpool fans.

In regards to Beardsley I have no idea unless he was the one investigated on the first night or said something in his posts. He possibly upset the Paper Boy.
 
Penfold's Adviser said:
Mind you, they also seem to have passed you uo and No Chance and G and Bisc.

In regards to Valley who do you go for when you have no info and may want to direct attention to Toon fans as opposed to, just say, Liverpool fans.

In regards to Beardsley I have no idea unless he was the one investigated on the first night or said something in his posts. He possibly upset the Paper Boy.
Click to expand...

all perfectly reasonable of course.... but the fact is you are deflecting off why did you go for ACS twice in thread?

your firs tpoint on valley is perfectly resonable

your second on beards is pretty poor and you should read it there... the mafia killed him! your point is complete poo poo so... hmmmmm
 
moreinjuredthanowen said:
all perfectly reasonable of course.... but the fact is you are deflecting off why did you go for ACS twice in thread?

your firs tpoint on valley is perfectly resonable

your second on beards is pretty poor and you should read it there... the mafia killed him! your point is complete poo poo so... hmmmmm
Click to expand...
Deflecting?

<laugh>

And your posts can't be construed as you deflecting away from you. You never asked me why I went for Chippy. But I have previously stated why I went for Chippy. Post 60 and 65

First post was just to stir a response from a hunch and second post was just giving details as to why I had that hunch. (The bells, the bells...)

So I haven't hidden anything for anyone who reads the thread. Also No Chance picks up a voting issue and then Chippy goes full steam for him. Then we have the "result" of the investigation which doesn't add up.
 
moreinjuredthanowen said:
And the beardsley pile of poo you dropped?
Click to expand...
Can't work out your point here as I have simply said I have no idea as to why the Mafia would go for him. Can't explain it and won't try at this point until I get a read as to why. I wouldn't but then again someone obviously has.

The Paper Boy reference was a "joke" reference Beardsley questioning Rolo being late with the paper. Post 223 if that's what you're getting at?

Anyway enough about me, want to convince me you're not the Mafia with al your deflecting!!
 
Penfold's Adviser said:
Can't work out your point here as I have simply said I have no idea as to why the Mafia would go for him. Can't explain it and won't try at this point until I get a read as to why. I wouldn't but then again someone obviously has.

The Paper Boy reference was a "joke" reference Beardsley questioning Rolo being late with the paper. Post 223 if that's what you're getting at?

Anyway enough about me, want to convince me you're not the Mafia with al your deflecting!!
Click to expand...

Ok so it was just a joke then........
 
Apologies I couldn't get on last night. It would have made no difference as I had pretty much decided there was little point in lynching without information.

I'll have a read back through and see how things played out - then log my vote on what I know and what I think I know.
 
moreinjuredthanowen said:
You must be really worried here...
... trying yer best n all mind.

You are trying quite hard to tie things up and confuse but youve been deliberately obtuse.
Click to expand...
Honestly, is that the best you've now got.

You ask and I have answered. Nothing obtuse at all.

I ask and you don't answer.

If I don't answer then I'm damned but if I do answer then I'm damned. Sounds like an argument with my wife!!!

If you claim I've been obtuse then back it up with examples. In the meantime I'm waiting for Chippy.
 
Penfold's Adviser said:
Honestly, is that the best you've now got.

You ask and I have answered. Nothing obtuse at all.

I ask and you don't answer.

If I don't answer then I'm damned but if I do answer then I'm damned. Sounds like an argument with my wife!!!

If you claim I've been obtuse then back it up with examples. In the meantime I'm waiting for Chippy.
Click to expand...

I specifically asked about your line about beardsley and you ignored it first then made out it was a joke, then I called you on it.

"In regards to Beardsley I have no idea unless he was the one investigated on the first night or said something in his posts. He possibly upset the Paper Boy."

As I pointed out... he was killed by mafia? are you telling me the mafia have the investigator role? <ok>
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back