Off Topic Mafia game: The island

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Tobes said:
Stuff that didn't make sense like No.6 you mean? I.e. You.

The mafia posters ignored all of the stuff I posted about the obvious narrative in this game that is based on the The Prisoner.

They chose instead to focus the discussion on the chosen direction.
Click to expand...

Tbh I have skim read to catch up so don't have specifics like I normally would for why I was suspicious of you, haven't been able to add anything to my notes today, just got that general feeling as I was reading through. As I say I may yet change who I vote for but wanted to get something on the table.

Tonight I think I'll need to re-read all of today's action.
 
What is the reasoning for south? People are just jummping on it nev you wanted a unaminous decision but more people have voted east why the switch

East
 
  • Like
Reactions: J. J. McClure
astroturfnaut said:
Yes the pro-North guys have either refused to justify, or given the worst reason imaginable

My logic is maybe a bit of stretch, but the best I can do, and certaintly better than "go North for a better view of the East"

I am voting BobbyD for his terrible reasoning, and will change to South if people are willing to to try to get a unanimous decision on the direction (based on the "work together" clue in the OP)
Click to expand...
North makes zero sense to me.

I've been with South all along, as it seems the obvious choice given the option of the sea or the mountain terrain.

I'm leaving my choice of escapee until others show their tactics. I have a strong idea who I'm voting for but will give it a while yet....
 
  • Like
Reactions: J. J. McClure
table:

Escape table:
Chaos: 1 Vote by: Bodanki
ACS: 1 vote by: tennis
Astro: 1 vote by: G'inho
style: 1 vote by: RHC
Valley: 3 vote by: nev, Penfold, style
Neville, 1 vote by: ACS
tobes: 4 vote by: bobbyd, afcftw, valley, chaos
bobbyd: 1 vote by: astro
yet to vote: Mikey, Nolberto, tobes

Action table:
Head East: 4 by penfold, tennis, ACS, valley
Head North: 2 by BobbyD, style
Head south: 7 by G'inho, tobes, RHC, Chaos, afcftw, astro, south
yet to vote: AFCFTW, Bodanki, Mikey, Nolberto

note i got one sad server in the middle of this count so be aware.

actions please all....
 
BobbyD said:
What is the reasoning for south? People are just jummping on it nev you wanted a unaminous decision but more people have voted east why the switch

East
Click to expand...

East seems to make the most sense, but people were already changing to South. I am happy to go with whatever we decide will be the one we go for to get a unanimous vote
 
  • Like
Reactions: J. J. McClure and Sir Tennisball
Tobes said:
North makes zero sense to me.

I've been with South all along, as it seems the obvious choice given the option of the sea or the mountain terrain.

I'm leaving my choice of escapee until others show their tactics. I have a strong idea who I'm voting for but will give it a while yet....
Click to expand...

But why would you choose south to the JUNGLE full of traps hiding places and danger when you can go EAST and head towards the sea to head OFF the island. South is definitely the most fishy out of all these options. Nothing ever good has come from going into the jungle EVER.
 
  • Like
Reactions: J. J. McClure
moreinjuredthanowen said:
table:

Escape table:
Chaos: 1 Vote by: Bodanki
ACS: 1 vote by: tennis
Astro: 1 vote by: G'inho
style: 1 vote by: RHC
Valley: 3 vote by: nev, Penfold, style
Neville, 1 vote by: ACS
tobes: 4 vote by: bobbyd, afcftw, valley, chaos
bobbyd: 1 vote by: astro
yet to vote: Mikey, Nolberto, tobes

Action table:
Head East: 4 by penfold, tennis, ACS, valley
Head North: 2 by BobbyD, style
Head south: 7 by G'inho, tobes, RHC, Chaos, afcftw, astro, south
yet to vote: AFCFTW, Bodanki, Mikey, Nolberto

note i got one sad server in the middle of this count so be aware.

actions please all....
Click to expand...

MITO you are late, i'm heading EAST
 
  • Like
Reactions: J. J. McClure
MITO kind of hypothetical question, but if there happened to be some kind of bonus for a unanimous decision, would having all voters be enough i.e. "not voted" are just ignored?

You probably can't answer, I'm just saying IMO the "not voted" people should be ignored <ok>
 
  • Like
Reactions: J. J. McClure and Nolberto's Salsa Inferno
If the link is between valley and style is there a particular reason we are going for valley over style to be in danger?

I get why Tobes is in the running as my gut said he was suspicious when I read through but not sure I want to be part of outright lynching him as I haven't had the time today to be sure of my actions...
 
  • Like
Reactions: J. J. McClure
afcftw said:
If the link is between valley and style is there a particular reason we are going for valley over style to be in danger?

I get why Tobes is in the running as my gut said he was suspicious when I read through but not sure I want to be part of outright lynching him as I haven't had the time today to be sure of my actions...
Click to expand...

My reasoning was that Valley was the one doing the following, plus when I asked him about it, rather than coming back with a reason he just voted to lynch me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: J. J. McClure and afcftw
BobbyD said:
But why would you choose south to the JUNGLE full of traps hiding places and danger when you can go EAST and head towards the sea to head OFF the island. South is definitely the most fishy out of all these options. Nothing ever good has come from going into the jungle EVER.
Click to expand...

South is the lake that leads to the jungle, so not technically the jungle yet
 
  • Like
Reactions: J. J. McClure
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back