Off Topic Coyote Canyon Game Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
Graham Carr's Binoculars said:
Can I just say that voting ACS does nothing to prove if someone is town or bandit. It's basically impossible to nominate anyone else based on the fact that we know ACS is a bandit.

Musty is high on my list unless he's just misunderstood the rules given that he's targeting me and gerrez.

On that note though, given ACS is leading the vote by so much and is going to swing whether me and gerrez vote anyway I'd quite like me and gerrez to revisit the priest to prove amongst me, him and the good man of the cloth that neither me or him have been turned.
Click to expand...

I'm in no way refusing since I have nothing to hide. However, that would mean we can't vote again tomorrow. I posted the possible numbers before. There could be six bandits out there right now, that would mean there are eleven townies. ACS is going to die but his bandit team could recruit to replace him (10-6). If we lose two or three townies (8-6 or 7-6), votes may be very important.

I'm happy to do what people wish. I could do with some input from the priest on this one!


Edit: just seen Tennis' post. We can't visit the priest again anyway, its a once per game action.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Graham Carr's Binoculars
mustyfrog said:
if everyong is so certain re Fish & Chips, why not lynch someone else eg your second choice?
Click to expand...
And do what with ACS? If you mean instruct to shoot him instead, then why put the sheriff/vigilante into an unnecessary gunfight with other potential bandits? Plus in the order of events, bandits can kill before the vigilante if that is their chosen action. So putting people at risk if we don't lynch a known bandit. <ok>
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sir Tennisball
Obi Wanaldum said:
Agree re the plan. We lynch ACS (voted already, but just to avoid any doubt)

Also agree it seems crazy for Donaldsons to save ACS. My point is why would the whole team sacrifice actions, if they coild recruit instead? Especially when brb was next in line. If they wanted to sacrifice brb over ACS, thn all they had to do was pile votes on tk brb and Albert not go all stupid and tey'd have the same outcome. Why waste the team save in that situation. If that happened, it is the biggest fck up ever. Waste an action, lynch a player and leave another out to dry the next night?
NOT EVEN ALBERT, BRB AND TASH ARE THAT CRAZY. Are they?

I think Acs was a lone McGraw and saving himself as a last act of desepration.

If so, that means the Donaldsons may have recruited. Hence the lack of other news. In which case, they are still strong numerically.

That's my theory.
Click to expand...

If they recruited, why didn't they act as well? Rules say recruitment is a team leader action. It also says actions are passed to the next highest ranked member if someone dies.

They had three members yesterday. In your scenario... BRB hung, their leader recruited and the third guy did...?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Sir Tennisball said:
The way I understand it the Deputy can't try to kill anyone, only the Sheriff and Vigilante can.

From tonight the Sheriff and Deputy are Tradesmen so only the Vigilante will be able to target someone. The rest will defend if someone shoots at them (or someone in the same building as them). <ok>
Click to expand...

Bollox, forgot about Sheriff and Deputy becoming tradesmen <doh>
 
  • Like
Reactions: Obi Wan and Sir Tennisball
Obi Wanaldum said:
Agree re the plan. We lynch ACS (voted already, but just to avoid any doubt)

Also agree it seems crazy for Donaldsons to save ACS. My point is why would the whole team sacrifice actions, if they coild recruit instead? Especially when brb was next in line. If they wanted to sacrifice brb over ACS, thn all they had to do was pile votes on tk brb and Albert not go all stupid and tey'd have the same outcome. Why waste the team save in that situation. If that happened, it is the biggest fck up ever. Waste an action, lynch a player and leave another out to dry the next night?
NOT EVEN ALBERT, BRB AND TASH ARE THAT CRAZY. Are they?

I think Acs was a lone McGraw and saving himself as a last act of desepration.

If so, that means the Donaldsons may have recruited. Hence the lack of other news. In which case, they are still strong numerically.

That's my theory.
Click to expand...
I think you're giving the bandits too much credit, you may be right but they may not have realised that the #2 gets lynched if they rescue ACS.
Perhaps ACS was the gang leader and he just made the call to save himself regardless...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nolberto's Salsa Inferno
Didn't realise you could only visit once, but I do think it would have helped provide clarity on me and Gerrez as IMO one of us was most likely to be turned and I know it's not me because I still have my original role.

Again, doesn't mean I'm now pointing fingers at Gerrez, it just would have given me, him and the priest 100% trust again.
 
Kloppezinho said:
If they recruited, why didn't they act as well? Rules say recruitment is a team leader action. It also says actions are passed to the next highest ranked member if someone dies.
Click to expand...
Brb and Tash were both killed, so maybe their selected actions didn't take place. What were their exact roles again? Twatface Nev hasn't updated p1 and I don't which page the nightfall summary was on.
But their actions may have been limited with 2 down. Arsonist has 50% chance of accuracy so mah have failed.
 
Graham Carr's Binoculars said:
Didn't realise you could only visit once, but I do think it would have helped provide clarity on me and Gerrez as IMO one of us was most likely to be turned and I know it's not me because I still have my original role.

Again, doesn't mean I'm now pointing fingers at Gerrez, it just would have given me, him and the priest 100% trust again.
Click to expand...

Apart from there being at least one recruit still to be used <laugh>
 
  • Like
Reactions: Graham Carr's Binoculars
Obi Wanaldum said:
Brb and Tash were both killed, so maybe their selected actions didn't take place. What were their exact roles again? Twatface Nev hasn't updated p1 and I don't which page the nightfall summary was on.
But their actions may have been limited with 2 down. Arsonist has 50% chance of accuracy so mah have failed.
Click to expand...

I edit my last comment but you may have just answered that. Hash was the Hitman and BRB the investigator (I think). Just off to check the night orders...
 
I think our strongest play could be to ask at least one person we have doubts about to visit the priest. If they're town there is no need to refuse, we know the priest can't be turned so it would then give me, Gerrez and the priest a definite answer on if said visitor is a town member or a bandit.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Obi Wan
Obi Wanaldum said:
And do what with ACS? If you mean instruct to shoot him instead, then why put the sheriff/vigilante into an unnecessary gunfight with other potential bandits? Plus in the order of events, bandits can kill before the vigilante if that is their chosen action. So putting people at risk if we don't lynch a known bandit. <ok>
Click to expand...
ok ACS
 
  • Like
Reactions: Obi Wan
Obi Wanaldum said:
Agree re the plan. We lynch ACS (voted already, but just to avoid any doubt)

Also agree it seems crazy for Donaldsons to save ACS. My point is why would the whole team sacrifice actions, if they coild recruit instead? Especially when brb was next in line. If they wanted to sacrifice brb over ACS, thn all they had to do was pile votes on tk brb and Albert not go all stupid and tey'd have the same outcome. Why waste the team save in that situation. If that happened, it is the biggest fck up ever. Waste an action, lynch a player and leave another out to dry the next night?
NOT EVEN ALBERT, BRB AND TASH ARE THAT CRAZY. Are they?

I think Acs was a lone McGraw and saving himself as a last act of desepration.

If so, that means the Donaldsons may have recruited. Hence the lack of other news. In which case, they are still strong numerically.

That's my theory.
Click to expand...

Now you have put me in two minds....
 
Obi Wanaldum said:
Brb and Tash were both killed, so maybe their selected actions didn't take place. What were their exact roles again? Twatface Nev hasn't updated p1 and I don't which page the nightfall summary was on.
But their actions may have been limited with 2 down. Arsonist has 50% chance of accuracy so mah have failed.
Click to expand...
Kloppezinho said:
I edit my last comment but you may have just answered that. Hash was the Hitman and BRB the investigator (I think). Just off to check the night orders...
Click to expand...


Hitman strikes before the vigilante but after the sheriff....

Less Hope Than Neville said:
Order of Events
  1. Lynching
  2. Tavern Whore actions
  3. Serial Killer's actions
  4. Sanctuary taken
  5. Bank Manager actions
  6. Bullets purchased
  7. Invincibility potion taken
  8. Sherrif's actions
  9. Bandit kills (including Lone Gunmen kills) - carried out in order received
  10. Vigilante kills
  11. Coachmen actions
  12. Other bandit actions (if the action is to rob the coachmen then this happens before the coachmen return to the bank) - In order:
    1. Gang Leader actions,
    2. Gang Investigator actions
    3. Gang Thief actions
    4. Gang Arsonist actions
    5. Hired Gun Actions
  13. Deputy actions
  14. Lone Gunmen other actions (carried out in order received)
  15. Cat Burglar actions
Click to expand...

If it was a vigilante kill the question remains, If Leader who recruited, BRB and Tash were the remaining three Donaldson's, why didn't Tash act? Lack of money maybe...?


I'm certain ACS is a Donaldson
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sir Tennisball
Graham Carr's Binoculars said:
I think our strongest play could be to ask at least one person we have doubts about to visit the priest. If they're town there is no need to refuse, we know the priest can't be turned so it would then give me, Gerrez and the priest a definite answer on if said visitor is a town member or a bandit.
Click to expand...

This would also help provide clarity over me and Gerrez, as if the priest discovers a bandit we'd follow the priest's lead when it comes to voting, the only we this wouldn't happen is if we'd been turned.

If Gerrez hasn't already been turned, it would also prevent me and him being turned tonight as we'd be able to flush either me or him out (if one of us gets turned tonight) very quickly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom
Back