Match Day Thread QPR v Blackburn Rovers

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
So likely one of this lot?

Huddersfield Town’s top five goalkeepers since 1988

http://metro.co.uk/2014/04/28/huddersfield-towns-top-five-goalkeepers-since-1988-4711053/

I note:-

5. Alex Smithies

At the ripe age of 24, Town’s current No.1 has made over 200 appearances for the club.

Handling errors and accurate distribution are deficiencies in his game but that’s compensated with his positional sense and sharp reflexes which regularly stops dead-cert goals.

His recent captaincy of the team shows the influence and experience he has within the dressing room.

Having already saved two penalties, I will always remember the composure he showed to score our last penalty at Wembley in 2012.
Nope.
 
On yesterdays showing...
Handling errors and accurate distribution are deficiencies in his game

The accurate distribution was far better than Greens, he threw to players, he could kick to players.....and he can kick along way too...one got to the oppo goalie, not ideal, but better than Green.

I think none of us are completely sure if he dropped the ball or whether it was a foul, we will have leave that one goal.
I thought he did OK.

He looked "sturdier" somehow, wheras green looks flimsy.
 
No and why would you think that? Don't shoot the messenger mate, I'm just commenting on what I have been told.
Although we have bought a keeper who seems a good shot stopper but cant catch a cold.
You boys had best watch out cos the Goalkeeping Union President Dr WATSon will be down on you like a ton of bricks!
 
It's really not. Some players relish the big occasion and will immediately step up, some take time to settle in. Darius Vassell was a crap club player but raised his game for England, loads of Irish players are ****e but do a good job in the big games for Ireland but then you get players who get their big chance and have a good CV but either can't do it or take a bit of time.Luongo = stepped up immediatelyGladwin = looks ****but they both looked a similar level last season. We are all different.
I'm talking about Goalkeepers which are totally different to outfield players in a number of ways, chief of which is its a specialised position so the only way you'll get in the team is when the other chap seriously fu*ks up. In years past GK's were ready but not anymore. They're full of bloody nerves and not willing to take their rare chance.

If it were up to me Smithies wouldn't be rewarded for choking when his opportunity came. I'd play Joanna Lumley next game. (S)he can't be any worse than the other two.
 
I'm talking about Goalkeepers which are totally different to outfield players in a number of ways, chief of which is its a specialised position so the only way you'll get in the team is when the other chap seriously fu*ks up. In years past GK's were ready but not anymore. They're full of bloody nerves and not willing to take their rare chance.

If it were up to me Smithies wouldn't be rewarded for choking when his opportunity came. I'd play Joanna Lumley next game. (S)he can't be any worse than the other two.

He hardly choked. He made a mistake, if you can call it that, which nine times out of ten the ref would have called a foul for and went on to have a good game including one particularly good save. Being a goalkeeper has little to do with anything.

What good does it do the bloke that he makes one error and is dumped for the third choice goalkeeper? Green is available on Saturday anyway but I'd happily stick with Smithies. He's an experienced goalkeeper at this level and if the plan is to consolidate this season with him as the long term keeper then there's no harm in playing him over Green.
 
Just that he's a 25-year-old keeper with 270 senior appearances, which is quite rare
Where do you get your leeway for understanding his nerves then Sir?
He hardly choked. He made a mistake
You're forgetting his first appearance. His first action was to kick a ball out of his hands straight out of play, then throw one out and then concede a goal he should have parried. Then in his first full game he coughs one up for Blackburn.

Wats you have a very high tolerance level for poor Goalkeeping but each to his own :smile:
 
Where do you get your leeway for understanding his nerves then Sir?

You're forgetting his first appearance. His first action was to kick a ball out of his hands straight out of play, then throw one out and then concede a goal he should have parried. Then in his first full game he coughs one up for Blackburn.

Wats you have a very high tolerance level for poor Goalkeeping but each to his own :smile:

I was a goalkeeper for many years, albeit not at any sort of relevant level of course. He's quite an experienced player but is a young man in any other walk of life, the very same age as me in fact. If I was from a ****hole like Huddersfield, born and bred, never known anything apart from bloody Huddersfield and found myself transferred to a relatively big (or at least higher profile) London club playing against a team that resembled the Harlem Globetrotters, I'd be a tad nervous.

He'll make mistakes but you don't play as consistently as he has at a young age without having something about you.
 
He hardly choked. He made a mistake, if you can call it that, which nine times out of ten the ref would have called a foul for and went on to have a good game including one particularly good save. Being a goalkeeper has little to do with anything.

What good does it do the bloke that he makes one error and is dumped for the third choice goalkeeper? Green is available on Saturday anyway but I'd happily stick with Smithies. He's an experienced goalkeeper at this level and if the plan is to consolidate this season with him as the long term keeper then there's no harm in playing him over Green.
Apart from the 50k a week we throw away on Green. Why the **** didn't we offload when we had the chance?
 
Gabriele Angella on Queens Park Rangers' need to address their defensive issues

Queens Park Rangers have conceded 12 goals in their opening seven Championship matches.



Gabriele Angella has revealed, on the club's official website, that the Queens Park Rangers squad had a frank discussion about their defensive issues following their match against Blackburn Rovers on Wednesday night.
The R's drew 2-2 against Blackburn at Loftus Road, and it was a performance which again highlighted the soft centre which has plagued them all season.

QPR have let in 12 goals in their first seven Championship matches, and Angella admits that the squad will need to improve defensively if they are to achieve their aims this term.

"We've got to stop conceding two goals every game," he admitted. "We spoke about it after the game and we've now got to go back on the training ground and work on the problems we're suffering.

SEE ALSO:
Chris Ramsey on what has shocked him about QPR this season

Despite the volume of goals conceded, Angella has still made a positive impression at Loftus Road since signing on loan from Watford.
The centre-back has been thrust straight into the starting line-up for QPR, and he has largely impressed in his opening two games for the club.
Have you been impressed by Angella's start at QPR?

http://www.hitc.com/en-gb/2015/09/1...queens-park-rangers-need-to-address-their-de/

QPR fans vote Italian defender Gabriele Angella Man of the Match against Blackburn Rovers ...
  • QPR fans have selected Gabriele Angella their Man of the Match against Blackburn Rovers
  • Italian helped the R's to a 2-2 draw on Wednesday evening
GABRIELE ANGELLA was your Man of the Match in Wednesday's 2-2 draw against Blackburn Rovers.
The Italian defender completed 90 minutes at Loftus Road having gone off on his first QPR appearance against Nottingham Forest with a head injury.
The Watford loanee beat off competition from Massimo Luongo and Paul Konchesky to win Wednesday's supporter vote.
And QPR fans can watch his best bits from that match above whilst below are a selection of votes cast by supporters.

Read more at http://www.qpr.co.uk/news/article/q...kburn-rovers-2695612.aspx#eLtjYMs2042z7B8Z.99


 
Gabriele Angella on Queens Park Rangers' need to address their defensive issues

Queens Park Rangers have conceded 12 goals in their opening seven Championship matches.



Gabriele Angella has revealed, on the club's official website, that the Queens Park Rangers squad had a frank discussion about their defensive issues following their match against Blackburn Rovers on Wednesday night.
The R's drew 2-2 against Blackburn at Loftus Road, and it was a performance which again highlighted the soft centre which has plagued them all season.

QPR have let in 12 goals in their first seven Championship matches, and Angella admits that the squad will need to improve defensively if they are to achieve their aims this term.

"We've got to stop conceding two goals every game," he admitted. "We spoke about it after the game and we've now got to go back on the training ground and work on the problems we're suffering.

SEE ALSO:
Chris Ramsey on what has shocked him about QPR this season

Despite the volume of goals conceded, Angella has still made a positive impression at Loftus Road since signing on loan from Watford.
The centre-back has been thrust straight into the starting line-up for QPR, and he has largely impressed in his opening two games for the club.
Have you been impressed by Angella's start at QPR?

http://www.hitc.com/en-gb/2015/09/1...queens-park-rangers-need-to-address-their-de/

QPR fans vote Italian defender Gabriele Angella Man of the Match against Blackburn Rovers ...



    • QPR fans have selected Gabriele Angella their Man of the Match against Blackburn Rovers
    • Italian helped the R's to a 2-2 draw on Wednesday evening
GABRIELE ANGELLA was your Man of the Match in Wednesday's 2-2 draw against Blackburn Rovers.
The Italian defender completed 90 minutes at Loftus Road having gone off on his first QPR appearance against Nottingham Forest with a head injury.
The Watford loanee beat off competition from Massimo Luongo and Paul Konchesky to win Wednesday's supporter vote.
And QPR fans can watch his best bits from that match above whilst below are a selection of votes cast by supporters.

Read more at http://www.qpr.co.uk/news/article/q...kburn-rovers-2695612.aspx#eLtjYMs2042z7B8Z.99


Man of the ****ing match??????!!!!!!!!!!!!

What a joke.
 
He hardly choked. He made a mistake, if you can call it that, which nine times out of ten the ref would have called a foul for and went on to have a good game including one particularly good save. Being a goalkeeper has little to do with anything.

What good does it do the bloke that he makes one error and is dumped for the third choice goalkeeper? Green is available on Saturday anyway but I'd happily stick with Smithies. He's an experienced goalkeeper at this level and if the plan is to consolidate this season with him as the long term keeper then there's no harm in playing him over Green.

It wasn't just the one mistake, there were another 3 or 4 times that rather than catching it he flapped at it with a weak punch.

Hopefully that won't be normal and it was down to his ricket for the goal knocking his confidence as the weather was no excuse as their own goalie managed it
 
Last edited: