Mafia XI - An Unknown Evil -GAMEOVER Town/Anarchist Victory!

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
Less Hope Than Neville said:
I disagree. I think a 3 way may spread votes too thin looking at how many people have voted so far, though I appreciate some people may just be holding back at the minute. However, if Gerrez is innocent then we can be 99% sure that AFC is guilty which will give us a relatively safe lynch for tomorrow. If Gerrez is guilty then, in my eyes, we have a relatively safe lynch target in Obi. If Gerrez is guilty then it leaves us less sure about AFC. I find it strange that he joined in the dude conversation on his first post and have openly said I found this suspicious - so maybe he would be a good one to add to the list of possible investigation targets (making the list bigger means less chance of investigations being flipped - if they even have that ability).
Click to expand...

So make it a two way between Gerrez and AFC? If the innocent one dies, we lynch the other tomorrow?

I'll start the ball rolling AFC.
 
moreinjuredthanowen said:
I think everyone with a role needs to think about what they want to do... please remember last games where people all went for the same targets... Kills if we have them need to be evidence based. investigators go with your gut. think hard guys. Theres several lines out now that if you have to kill you can or you can hold off.

I invite the investigation cos i've been called on by JPF here just like nev and lucaaas. however its entirely up to the investigator role or roles.
Click to expand...

I agree with all of this!!

I would also add that if we have a protection role then that person(s) need to think hard about who is most likely to be targeted and use their powers wisely.
 
Thinking about it, while it makes sense Gerrez was on some sort of mission, he can't know someone else is evil, he could just blab that right away and we have an evil player.

I still think obi is the most obviously guilty, him starting the weird word posts without reason this far.
 
I reacted to obi putting "Mondo" as I thought the medium would know the words we have to say. This is not the case, the medium just knows we've been told to say certain things regularly. Got to be pretty stupid not to know what those words are now.

Also, since I've put everything on the table,why would I be voting for Obi if we were linked.

Simply put, kill me and we lose a potential reward

DUDE


PS...2%
 
  • Like
Reactions: ValleyGraduate12
TheJudeanPeoplesFront said:
Thinking about it, while it makes sense Gerrez was on some sort of mission, he can't know someone else is evil, he could just blab that right away and we have an evil player.

I still think obi is the most obviously guilty, him starting the weird word posts without reason this far.
Click to expand...

Of course I can, we are against each other. It is also the reason Milk gave the warning about talking in private; he sent the surfer pm to me and afc together taster than individually

BODACIOUS
 
Gerrez said:
I reacted to obi putting "Mondo" as I thought the medium would know the words we have to say. This is not the case, the medium just knows we've been told to say certain things regularly. Got to be pretty stupid not to know what those words are now.

Also, since I've put everything on the table,why would I be voting for Obi if we were linked.

Simply put, kill me and we lose a potential reward

DUDE


PS...2%
Click to expand...

Your explanation makes no sense. You say the PM was sent to you & AFC together, rather than individually. So why was Obi Wan aware of the word "mondo" and mentioned it before either of you? Where does he come into this?

Or are all 3 of you on the same team and trying to distance yourselves from each other?
 
Lucaaas said:
Your explanation makes no sense. You say the PM was sent to you & AFC together, rather than individually. So why was Obi Wan aware of the word "mondo" and mentioned it before either of you? Where does he come into this?

Or are all 3 of you on the same team and trying to distance yourselves from each other?
Click to expand...

The targeting continues

GNARLY
 
I agree, i think Gerrez' defense is nowhere close to watertight, and he's digging a bigger hole for himself.

If he was told about afc being evil in a PM then such a blatant reveal of a player's role would be jumped upon immediately. If you're a townsperson and you know who an evil person is you reveal immediately, classic case for an investigator role since town always outnumber evil guys at the start.
 
Catching up on reading the thread, got about half an hour before I'm heading out and then won't be back on until some time later tonight after nightfall!
 
ValleyGraduate12 said:
Let's put AFC in the coin toss with Gerrez. Only one way to find out.
Click to expand...

How would that find out? It gives a 50:50 chance on killing a innocent or evil, if you kill the evil then town lose the benefit of the role so you may as well have killed me anyway.

I obviously don't want to die but nor do I want afc to die.

Best option is vote no lynch and investigate me. My vote is on Obi purely because it offers the best chance of survival for me.

MONDO
 
Sir Tennisball said:
I agree, i think Gerrez' defense is nowhere close to watertight, and he's digging a bigger hole for himself.

If he was told about afc being evil in a PM then such a blatant reveal of a player's role would be jumped upon immediately. If you're a townsperson and you know who an evil person is you reveal immediately, classic case for an investigator role since town always outnumber evil guys at the start.
Click to expand...

Check one of my earlier posts to Lucaaas. Defense always digs a bigger hole bit silence is seen as guilty too. A dude can't win
 
Some observations:

Gerrez obviously has to use some odd words or has some kind of task to complete. Why he is trying to drag me into it I have no idea! Maybe because I voted for him earlier?

If gerrez is telling the truth about having to say certain things then I think we can assume Obi is either on a team with him or is the medium. Obi used mondo before gerrez and gerrez claims that is one of the words, so either they are in it together or Obi knows the words because he is the medium and got told everything. Why would he then say the word though and link himself to gerrez? Unless maybe he was trying to highlight it so others would notice. Not sure. I'd investigate Obi, kill gerrez (since we have nothing better to go on and he is trying to take me down as usual lol)

Valley has been really pushing to throw me under the bus too, I'm watching you sir!
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheJudeanPeoplesFront
afcftw said:
Some observations:

Gerrez obviously has to use some odd words or has some kind of task to complete. Why he is trying to drag me into it I have no idea! Maybe because I voted for him earlier?

If gerrez is telling the truth about having to say certain things then I think we can assume Obi is either on a team with him or is the medium. Obi used mondo before gerrez and gerrez claims that is one of the words, so either they are in it together or Obi knows the words because he is the medium and got told everything. Why would he then say the word though and link himself to gerrez? Unless maybe he was trying to highlight it so others would notice. Not sure. I'd investigate Obi, kill gerrez (since we have nothing better to go on and he is trying to take me down as usual lol)

Valley has been really pushing to throw me under the bus too, I'm watching you sir!
Click to expand...

This!

Although I think your post on this thread had "dude" in it...
 
Gerrez said:
How would that find out? It gives a 50:50 chance on killing a innocent or evil, if you kill the evil then town lose the benefit of the role so you may as well have killed me anyway.

I obviously don't want to die but nor do I want afc to die.

Best option is vote no lynch and investigate me. My vote is on Obi purely because it offers the best chance of survival for me.

MONDO
Click to expand...

No point investigating you as surely the results would be flipped (assuming they can do it this game).

You and AFC should be in the coin toss. If you die and are innocent we lynch AFC tomorrow and vice versa.
 
afcftw said:
Some observations:

Gerrez obviously has to use some odd words or has some kind of task to complete. Why he is trying to drag me into it I have no idea! Maybe because I voted for him earlier?

If gerrez is telling the truth about having to say certain things then I think we can assume Obi is either on a team with him or is the medium. Obi used mondo before gerrez and gerrez claims that is one of the words, so either they are in it together or Obi knows the words because he is the medium and got told everything. Why would he then say the word though and link himself to gerrez? Unless maybe he was trying to highlight it so others would notice. Not sure. I'd investigate Obi, kill gerrez (since we have nothing better to go on and he is trying to take me down as usual lol)

Valley has been really pushing to throw me under the bus too, I'm watching you sir!
Click to expand...

Lucaaas as done a good nudge there dude <laugh>

Sacrificing the challenge so that I don't get the reward tonight (if I somehow survive)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom
Back