Off Topic Mafia VIII - Mafia vs Zombies

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
InBiscanWeTrust said:
Mito you so this every game... You claim to have reads on everyone and then once the truth is already known you come out and say yup I knew that.

If if you knew it all every game just tell us all on day 1 and we can get the whole thing sorted in 1 day <laugh>
Click to expand...

I've told swarbs each day.

Btw... I can't blurt out anything just because as they might be town roles.
 
InBiscanWeTrust said:
Yea but you'd make it harder for town to win. Locking you up is te best as if they kill you, you'll turn into a zombie.
Click to expand...

Assuming I am actually the SK. So assuming the enemy is telling the truth and doesn't want to win for some reason. And assuming if you leave free for 1 night I don't kill a mafia.

A lot of assumptions.

Investigate me. If I am SK it is game over for me. If I am SK I only care about myself.
 
InBiscanWeTrust said:
And investigating you would leave you open to oil again tonight astro
Click to expand...

Kill who? If I were SK and killed a mafia that would be good. I have already got Valley killed.

If I kill a townie and am investigated it is game over for me.

If I were really SK then suggesting you investigate me GUARANTEES I LOSE. Think about it.
 
Hilarious thought.


Ibwt has flipped people over and Gerrez is SK not Astro.

In the end my view is keep it simple and lynch Lucaaas if ibwt had any intent to help town he'd say what Lucaaas is. Let's hunt ibwt and end the infections. Let's lock up Astro and see what occurs as it then tells the mafia theif he can't rob.
 
This all seems crazy. I just don't have time to read 12 pages. Could somebody tell me what's going on? Not being a zombie I didn't really read much into that part of the game. Got time to re read the rules if somebody would kindly put me in the picture since last nights hilarity.
 
moreinjuredthanowen said:
Hilarious thought.


Ibwt has flipped people over and Gerrez is SK not Astro.

In the end my view is keep it simple and lynch Lucaaas if ibwt had any intent to help town he'd say what Lucaaas is. Let's hunt ibwt and end the infections. Let's lock up Astro and see what occurs as it then tells the mafia theif he can't rob.
Click to expand...

And then waste all of tomorrow when the information is inconclusive?

It is impossible for a SK to win the game once they are identified.

Investigate me.
 
astroturfnaut said:
Kill who? If I were SK and killed a mafia that would be good. I have already got Valley killed.

If I kill a townie and am investigated it is game over for me.

If I were really SK then suggesting you investigate me GUARANTEES I LOSE. Think about it.
Click to expand...

But you could kill a town with a role which will be a detriment to them.

locking you up would mean no kill and proof would be given when no kill happens so they can kill you next day with 100% knowledge.
 
moreinjuredthanowen said:
Hilarious thought.


Ibwt has flipped people over and Gerrez is SK not Astro.

In the end my view is keep it simple and lynch Lucaaas if ibwt had any intent to help town he'd say what Lucaaas is. Let's hunt ibwt and end the infections. Let's lock up Astro and see what occurs as it then tells the mafia theif he can't rob.
Click to expand...

Lucas is mafia <ok>
as is gerrez <ok>
Astro is SK
 
InBiscanWeTrust said:
But you could kill a town with a role which will be a detriment to them.

locking you up would mean no kill and proof would be given when no kill happens so they can kill you next day with 100% knowledge.
Click to expand...

Logic [HASHTAG]#fail[/HASHTAG]

The SK is not compelled to kill

And certainly won't kill if they know they are effectively killing me by not killing anyone anyway
 
astroturfnaut said:
And then waste all of tomorrow when the information is inconclusive?

It is impossible for a SK to win the game once they are identified.

Investigate me.
Click to expand...

Why waste an investigation?
lock you up and from the lake of killings it'll be obvious.
 
its up to bobby to weigh the benefits of each way.

locking up, protecting bullets, hunting, etc etc. he should probably actually not tell us.
 
Guys in just trying to help

can anyone (not mito gerrez or Astro) see the logic in this?

lynch one of gerrez/Lucas and you'll kill a mafia that's not been bitten

the hunter kill the other one and then also have 2 mafia dead neither of which are infected

Bobby lock up Astro, means SK ant kill and mafia can't really steal from police for extra bullet as cop has chance of seeing them.

You'll get rid of 3 really bad guys.

You ou can ten kill me the next day as well as Astro
 
InBiscanWeTrust said:
Guys in just trying to help

can anyone (not mito gerrez or Astro) see the logic in this?

lynch one of gerrez/Lucas and you'll kill a mafia that's not been bitten

the hunter kill the other one and then also have 2 mafia dead neither of which are infected

Bobby lock up Astro, means SK ant kill and mafia can't really steal from police for extra bullet as cop has chance of seeing them.

You'll get rid of 3 really bad guys.

You ou can ten kill me the next day as well as Astro
Click to expand...

Can anyone see IBWT is continuing to feed the false story that you will somehow get information about me from locking me up?

The reality is if I am SK I have lost the game once I am investigated

So investigate me
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Super G Ted'inho
InBiscanWeTrust said:
Guys in just trying to help

can anyone (not mito gerrez or Astro) see the logic in this?

lynch one of gerrez/Lucas and you'll kill a mafia that's not been bitten

the hunter kill the other one and then also have 2 mafia dead neither of which are infected

Bobby lock up Astro, means SK ant kill and mafia can't really steal from police for extra bullet as cop has chance of seeing them.

You'll get rid of 3 really bad guys.

You ou can ten kill me the next day as well as Astro
Click to expand...

What's with all the ****ing altruism? <laugh>
 
Alternative plan for @BobbyD

(Though don't respond that you agree with it)

Investigate me. Then you know the truth no matter what and if I am SK I cannot win.

Lock up someone else. I would suggest a quiet player like Sebb or Nolberto or Neville. In fact Neville might be the main priority since he voted for Mikey, a very strong innocent, and then left for the day.
 
astroturfnaut said:
Alternative plan for @BobbyD

(Though don't respond that you agree with it)

Investigate me. Then you know the truth no matter what and if I am SK I cannot win.

Lock up someone else. I would suggest a quiet player like Sebb or Nolberto or Neville. In fact Neville might be the main priority since he voted for Mikey, a very strong innocent, and then left for the day.
Click to expand...

For the town, it's not about stopping you winning... It's about stopping you and the mafia winning and them winning.

If they investigate you, you can still kill which could hurt the town
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom
Back