Off Topic Afcftw Mafia Game

[moreinjuredthanowen]

Do what you want whilst I'm in the ****ter

 

[Brian Storm]

I am well famous for being all over the games. and i did tell you i was far worse than AFC in sign up!

As long as you know you're making it very difficult for people who can't devote the same amount of time as you to actually follow the game.

 

[ValleyGraduate12]

Can you help me out with some points. 2 points confuse me with Valley.

1 Why did he get an extra piece of information? How would that be possible within the rules?
2 On that extra piece of information, he said a player who was changing votes at the end was seen running away with a knife, only to then say he saw mito running away with a knife. @ValleyGraduate12 which was it? A poster who changed last minute, or Mito?

Also somebody said they got three options one of which is right two of which was false. Who was that? Can't find it, can't be arsed to look again and @afcftw can't be arsed to update the op. I'd be able to find this information easier if he bothered put links to the results in op

It was MITO who I saw with the knife.

 

[Super G Ted'inho]

As long as you know you're making it very difficult for people who can't devote the same amount of time as you to actually follow the game.

Question; do you prefer AFC or MITO in the game?

 

[Tobes]

mito is still as guilty as **** like

 

[Swarbs]

Actually, Valley, MITO and Tennis could all be innocent.

Valley is confirmed psychic as far as am concerned now (and I've adjusted my noted accordingly).

MITO could have been forced or he could be the hitman. If forced then he probably is the PI but that doesn't mean Tennis is definitely guilty either, only a 66% that he is guilty (still high odds). If MITO is guilty then tennis is obviously innocent.

We need Valley to investigate one of the others, preferably MITO.

That's pretty much what I said. Either MITO is guilty or Tennisball is 66% guilty. So they could both be innocent, but that's only a 33% shot.

 

[Brian Storm]

It was MITO who I saw with the knife.

Are you willing to disclose how you got an extra piece of information? The town has hidden role, not a hidden action.

 

[Swarbs]

I'm not saying I suspect you, I'm saying you're making yourself look dodgy as ****. And like I said I was pondering ideas. Chill your boots. I don't need your reasoning, I've heard enough from you as I've said. It's other peoples Ideas I'm interested in as well as those who are offering nowt.

You can never hear enough from MITO....

[HASHTAG]#mafiatryingtodighiswayout[/HASHTAG]

 

[ValleyGraduate12]

Still I'm not convinced about this extra piece of info Valley got though. Are there hidden actions we don't know about? Acording to the rules his investigation as Physic only returns a straight town/non town answer. Why hasn't he explained why he's got this extra info? @ValleyGraduate12?

I also find it hard to comprehend that if The Mafia had a hidden action of town person manipulation, why they'd use it first night, a tool much better used later to deflect attentions. Not convinced by Mito's story at all. It's easy for him to say that he's the Drunk PI and must be true because nobody else has claimed the role, but we've just lost a doctor who didn't contribute at all.

The heat is on the right people though and it should unravel it self. I'll stick with Tobes.

I investigated Tobes as he voted early and then disappeared.

I also saw MITO running away with a bloodied knife. This is the info I recieved when I started my investigation.

 

[Super G Ted'inho]

That's pretty much what I said. Either MITO is guilty or Tennisball is 66% guilty. So they could both be innocent, but that's only a 33% shot.

Only way we get a sure answer is by investigating MITO. Investigating Tennis would still leave us with the same question mark on MITO unless he was found to be guilty (MITO wouldn't shoot his own man). It would effectively be taking the 66% gamble.

 

[ValleyGraduate12]

Are you willing to disclose how you got an extra piece of information? The town has hidden role, not a hidden action.

I had it in the email from AFC. Doesn't disclose if its a lie or if I have an hidden power.
I investigated one player and recieved info on two in the reply.

 

[Brian Storm]

Question; do you prefer AFC or MITO in the game?

Put it this way. I think a new format with two Game Masters would be interesting, Guess who i'd want as the Game Masters

 

[Super G Ted'inho]

I had it in the email from AFC. Doesn't disclose if its a lie or if I have an hidden power.
I investigated one player and recieved info on two in the reply.

MITO confirming he killed Biscan would suggest it was true mind

 

[Brian Storm]

I investigated Tobes as he voted early and then disappeared.

I also saw MITO running away with a bloodied knife. This is the info I received when I started my investigation.

Why? When the rules say the only info you get is straight town/non town answer to your investigation. Your answer still doesn't explain why you got extra info. If it was me I'd have ask AFC why you got it. Are you not remotely intrigued as to why you're getting extra info?

 

[Super G Ted'inho]

Why? When the rules say the only info you get is straight town/non town answer to your investigation. Your answer still doesn't explain why you got extra info. If it was me I'd have ask AFC why you got it. Are you not remotely intrigued as to why you're getting extra info?

I think he's made it quite clear that he doesn't know why. However, Tobes as also made it clear that Valley isn't lying about being the psychic

 

[ValleyGraduate12]

Why? When the rules say the only info you get is straight town/non town answer to your investigation. Your answer still doesn't explain why you got extra info. If it was me I'd have ask AFC why you got it. Are you not remotely intrigued as to why you're getting extra info?

I saw MITO. Just lucky I guess. Byt the events since have proven me truthful as I foresaw happening.

 

[Brian Storm]

I had it in the email from AFC. Doesn't disclose if its a lie or if I have an hidden power.
I investigated one player and recieved info on two in the reply.

@afcftw why doesn't the rules state the Physic gets extra info when the town has no hidden actions? Surely this would be a hidden action for the town yet the rules say noting of this.

 

[Brian Storm]

So halfway through day two we know Bisc was the Detective, Billy was Doctor, Valley is Psychic, Mito is PI and Tobes was Pablo. Meaning we don't know the hidden town role and the mafia players with 17 players still left? Valley and Mito have no protection and will obviously die tonight and tomorrow. What a ****ing boring week ahead of randomly pointing the finger and arguing the toss with nowt to go on other than plausible deniability which there will be plenty of. What a load of **** Dreading the rest of this game.

 

[Super G Ted'inho]

I saw MITO. Just lucky I guess. Byt the events since have proven me truthful as I foresaw happening.

Tobes and MITO (truthful or not) confirming your claims make you the known psychic as far as I'm concerned. You have been made green in my notes too

 

[Bodinki]

Why has everyone chosen to lay their cards on the table so early on in this game?
Weird decision.