Off Topic mafia 5: game thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
You all realise also the paper hack revealed both swarbs and gerrez and nobody realised. Today the paper was largely made up on guesses that day you all dismissed the hack immediately due to content

I was not involved in original jouneo role so I decided billy did a great job and I should use it

I over complicated the paper but felt the last games people got to personal and heated and this was a way to vent for people
 
For the record, I didn't kill on the second night because the Italian prostitute raped me!

Also, I avoided another lynch on day one. Then despite being fingered in the paper, I got no attention and not one single vote after that first day lol
 
Was never going to recruit you after it was confirmed you were the witness.... meant

1. You had no role so were of no important to me (harsh but true <laugh>)
2. You were prime target for recruitment by one of the mafia members.

Get the mafia thing definitely, surely I was either getting recruited or killed, was just frustrating as we were starting to build a decent town circle. Could have really narrowed it down as I had you down as town from very early which would've been confirmed, AFC as cop and Magic as deputy and Billy as journo, don't know what your reads were would have given us a great picture to go from - even if I died/was recruited we could've had it sewn up. Guess it goes back again to our discussions about AFC's protection - role vs proven innocent, having proven innocents with good town reads being able to communicate and work together is so so powerful even if it would've been short lived. Going into the deciding night we had the Journo and Vigi and the GM alive but still lost. You got the journo and got a lot of info together so did well, was just frustrating from a personal point of view I was hoping we could buddy up and lead to a glorious victory haha.
 
That would have been awesome... inside job, taking them out one by one without them even knowing <laugh>

I don't know about others who have been freemasons... but other than knowing 1 person is innocent for about 1 night (was actually more this game because an unknown recruitment didn't happen until about night 3) then it seems a pointless power to me?

Freemason was weaker this game because of the large number of players. Otherwise having another known innocent and the abililty to coordinate is strong. If you work out and recruit a powerful townie you're half way to winning.
 
For the record, I didn't kill on the second night because the Italian prostitute raped me!

Also, I avoided another lynch on day one. Then despite being fingered in the paper, I got no attention and not one single vote after that first day lol

Freeman said he raped me on the 2nd night...?

And it was only on the 3rd night I realised that the hacked paper was true.. it was hacke dby the other mafia team and were actually telling the truth to get rid of players they didn't want!

I saw the hack right away (they claimed Bod was grandmaster) but I didn't click that it might be hacked by the Italians and that the info was actually correct <grr>
 
Freemason was weaker this game because of the large number of players. Otherwise having another known innocent and the abililty to coordinate is strong. If you work out and recruit a powerful townie you're half way to winning.

True about number of players.

Yup, but the chance of recruiting a powerful townie at the start was so small that wasn't worth the risk... and by the time you've worked out who people might be, someone has generally been recruited and then you lose the trust anyway..
 
Poor fella had me beg him to try and when he did you all chose to disbelieve when the majority knew full well he was never going to bother lying on this

It suited half of you to accuse him and the town forgets this. The town and sorry ibwt you let swarbs fit him up

He made it a heck of a lot easier for us Italians <ok>
 
Freeman said he raped me on the 2nd night...?

And it was only on the 3rd night I realised that the hacked paper was true.. it was hacke dby the other mafia team and were actually telling the truth to get rid of players they didn't want!

I saw the hack right away (they claimed Bod was grandmaster) but I didn't click that it might be hacked by the Italians and that the info was actually correct <grr>

Two prossies in the game <doh>

I couldn't tell everyone is been entertained as it would have been obvious I was the serial killer with there being no kill.

When that hacked paper was released I thought I was ****ed. Couldn't believe that I didn't have to do anything and I got no attention, not one vote after day one!
 
Two prossies in the game <doh>

I couldn't tell everyone is been entertained as it would have been obvious I was the serial killer with there being no kill.

When that hacked paper was released I thought I was ****ed. Couldn't believe that I didn't have to do anything and I got no attention, not one vote after day one!

[HASHTAG]#notimportantsoyouwereignored[/HASHTAG]
 
Freemason was weaker this game because of the large number of players. Otherwise having another known innocent and the abililty to coordinate is strong. If you work out and recruit a powerful townie you're half way to winning.

Yes but I felt the known person led to everyone fearing to contradict afc and everyone who had an agenda ensured anyone even asking was made feel they were in danger

Perhaps an equal number of masons would have been better but there were 2 masons, 2 cops, journo and vigilante so mafia v role town was equal
 
Status
Not open for further replies.