Off Topic mafia 5: game thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
InBiscanWeTrust said:
Day 1

IBWT - 1 vote - by Nozzer
No Lynch - 2 vote - by bobbyD, RHC
Gerrez -2 vote- by AFCFTW, Danilo
Danilo -1 vote- Swarbs
Astro - 1 vote - by IBWT
Less hope than neville - 2 vote – by Bodanki, Astro
Goonercymraeg - 2 vote – by mikey, real morgan freeman
magic - 1 vote - billy
Bodanki -1 vote - gerrez

Day 2

Nozzer- 13 vote – by bodanki, bobbyD, real morgan, swarbs, mikey, obi wan, astro, gooner, billy, valley, afcftw, gerrez, ibwt

Mikey -1 vote- by nozzer

Day 3

magic- 1 votes – by astro
RHC – 3 vote – by swarbs, morgan, vally
Gooner – 3 vote – by IBWT, afc, bobbyd,

Valley – 3 vote – by mikey, gerrez, rhc



Any links in voting patterns?

Nozzer - known Russian voted for me (i know im innocent but unknown to rest) and Mikey (known innocent).
Astro known Italian - Voted for Less Hope which put him in danger of lynching, Nozzer & Magic. From this I'd suggest that Less Hope isn't an Italian mafia as would be too risky but could be Russian. Nozzer was opposition and jumping on with everyone else and Magic wasn't in danger so could be a bluff vote.
Danilo - was a recruited mafia so his votes don't matter in day 1.
Click to expand...

On day 1 wasn't astro on No Lynch at first, until reminded by Gerrez of the agreement to follow AFC in the first day's voting?
And on day 2 weren't astro and RHC both on Magic until RHC switched his vote to try and save himself?

Could be imagining things, but that would be two votes in which astro and RHC started out aligned, and then one of them switched their votes later in response to events.
 
InBiscanWeTrust said:
Day 1

IBWT - 1 vote - by Nozzer
No Lynch - 2 vote - by bobbyD, RHC
Gerrez -2 vote- by AFCFTW, Danilo
Danilo -1 vote- Swarbs
Astro - 1 vote - by IBWT
Less hope than neville - 2 vote – by Bodanki, Astro
Goonercymraeg - 2 vote – by mikey, real morgan freeman
magic - 1 vote - billy
Bodanki -1 vote - gerrez

Day 2

Nozzer- 13 vote – by bodanki, bobbyD, real morgan, swarbs, mikey, obi wan, astro, gooner, billy, valley, afcftw, gerrez, ibwt

Mikey -1 vote- by nozzer

Day 3

magic- 1 votes – by astro
RHC – 3 vote – by swarbs, morgan, vally
Gooner – 3 vote – by IBWT, afc, bobbyd,

Valley – 3 vote – by mikey, gerrez, rhc



Any links in voting patterns?

Nozzer - known Russian voted for me (i know im innocent but unknown to rest) and Mikey (known innocent).
Astro known Italian - Voted for Less Hope which put him in danger of lynching, Nozzer & Magic. From this I'd suggest that Less Hope isn't an Italian mafia as would be too risky but could be Russian. Nozzer was opposition and jumping on with everyone else and Magic wasn't in danger so could be a bluff vote.
Danilo - was a recruited mafia so his votes don't matter in day 1.
Click to expand...

Less Hope was killed and a Townie though.
 
Swarbs said:
Ouch, bye bye AFC. Seems like someone didn't like you putting them in the three way tie last night. RHC and Valley looking suspicious now! RHC was also voting a lot with astro earlier in the day IIRC, so could be a link there?

Good news is that astro's death proves the paper yesterday was hacked - I can't be the Italian Mafia goon if astro was the goon! Tho' do we know if the Mafia hacked the whole paper, or just the top part? Could be that the bit about Greez being the serial killer was the journo's original work and the Mafia bit got added on as extra? So maybe Greez was the target of the journo investigation after all?

That might explain why the serial killer took such a big risk going after the cop - trying to get the important kills in early before they can be identified?
Click to expand...

Good shout, hadn't put 2 and 2 together with that yet.
 
Swarbs said:
Ouch, bye bye AFC. Seems like someone didn't like you putting them in the three way tie last night. RHC and Valley looking suspicious now! RHC was also voting a lot with astro earlier in the day IIRC, so could be a link there?

Good news is that astro's death proves the paper yesterday was hacked - I can't be the Italian Mafia goon if astro was the goon! Tho' do we know if the Mafia hacked the whole paper, or just the top part? Could be that the bit about Greez being the serial killer was the journo's original work and the Mafia bit got added on as extra? So maybe Greez was the target of the journo investigation after all?

That might explain why the serial killer took such a big risk going after the cop - trying to get the important kills in early before they can be identified?
Click to expand...

Not entirely true... you could be the Russian goon?

It could have been the Russians that hacked the paper, made it obvious it had been hacked (think a few of us called it right away) but then you put a double bluff in there so when we find out it's hacked you can say "well that means I'm definitely not mafia" etc...
 
Obi Wan said:
Less Hope was killed and a Townie though.
Click to expand...

Good point <laugh>
Forget who's died and alive still....

MITO - any chance you can colour code the dead people in the OP and put their roles next to their names (of the dead ones obviously)?
 
InBiscanWeTrust said:
Could Mikey not be th recruited cop? He was a witness day 1 when no recruited cop was involved but day 2 he wasn't when the recruited cop was brought into the game...?

If he's not... does that mean he's now the witness every night in which case I have a feeling he'll be next on the hitlist for mafia?
Click to expand...

First page:

"4. Major crimes division. The cop can choose if he wishes to set up a major crimes unit (one person joins the cops) This is costly as it will require setting up a tech division but it does add some more powers and a team mate to work with. One person has been selected to be this extra police already. They will be a townsperson day one, after that anything could happen"

In theory it could be Mikey, but that would mean he was selected before the game, and also selected to be the witness on the first night. Also, cop acts before anyone else when arresting people. So Mikey would have been the extra cop before he was a witness, which would in theory rule him out of being an unallocated townie.

Also wouldn't explain why Mikey was so keen for AFC to lock him up every night if it stopped him doing his cop thing!

I think the witness will move between the unallocated townies each night, which means either Mikey or the other townie left with no role.
 
InBiscanWeTrust said:
Not entirely true... you could be the Russian goon?

It could have been the Russians that hacked the paper, made it obvious it had been hacked (think a few of us called it right away) but then you put a double bluff in there so when we find out it's hacked you can say "well that means I'm definitely not mafia" etc...
Click to expand...

Thought someone worked out that after recruiting danilo and losing Nozzer the Russian's didn't have enough money to hack the paper? They recruited danilo which took up all their 50k stash, so no money left to hack the paper. Then the next day they gained 20k but lost half of it when Nozzer was lynched so couldn't afford it then.
 
Swarbs said:
Thought someone worked out that after recruiting danilo and losing Nozzer the Russian's didn't have enough money to hack the paper? They recruited danilo which took up all their 50k stash, so no money left to hack the paper. Then the next day they gained 20k but lost half of it when Nozzer was lynched so couldn't afford it then.
Click to expand...


Possibly.. I've not been keeping up with the money because we don't know how they are earning money etc...

Just I don't think can say for certain that it's not you..
 
I can say for sure gents that unfortunately I was not the extra cop - who I now guess is of now use unless he can proove that he was somehow or has some actual powers beyond just being afc's buddy. I have an inkling who the extra cop but don't think it's of any use.

Also way to bloody spell it out for them IBWT <laugh>

I'm a dead man either way to be fair.

Now that we've established that the paper was most certainly hacked yesterday and cannot be today the journo should put out what he discovered on all three nights. If one of them was a town role who's identity doesn't need revealing, just say they uncovered the role as we desperately need information to be able to find a way to win. At this stage our route to victory is pretty much through the journo's information or getting real lucky with the lynches/vigi.
 
Swarbs said:
Thought someone worked out that after recruiting danilo and losing Nozzer the Russian's didn't have enough money to hack the paper? They recruited danilo which took up all their 50k stash, so no money left to hack the paper. Then the next day they gained 20k but lost half of it when Nozzer was lynched so couldn't afford it then.
Click to expand...

The paper was 100% hacked. Maybe they done some secret **** to earn more money?
 
Seems a case of waiting for the paper and the journo.

RHC looks suspicious to me as has similar voting to Astro .[HASHTAG]#justsaying[/HASHTAG]
 
The artist Billy Can can said:
Apparently I got drunk and rohypnol'd....message said I woke up with knobrash too <grr> no mention of Italian or Russian unfortunately....I've asked but told I don't remember <yikes>
Click to expand...

Ah so you got told you were with him/her.

begs the question.... We're you part of the other Mafia team and your action to kill / recruit was blocked because you were under the prossie...?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom
Back