Off Topic mafia 5: game thread

[InBiscanWeTrust]

Gerrez's insistence in kissing up to AFC tonight is a bit odd... First night makes perfect sense but tonight after Nozzer having like 10 votes on him already still asking who to vote for seems odd... seems like just trying to stay on someones good side.

 

[Super G Ted'inho]

Yeah this is the kind of time when we have no info to go on (unless we get another lucky witness report or the journo saw something) where people need to just start slinging **** at the wallls and see what sticks.

Personally I'm struggling to get many reads since I don't know any of you bastards or how your games usually go. Initially I had an inkling on goonercymraeg since he was active and posting elsewhere for much of yesterday but never showed up here, and then Gerrez immediately tried to redirect me from that back to afcftw's alphabet plan, that made me suspicious but surely there's no way they're in cahoots as they allowed a coin flip to decide a lynch they were both up for. I also found Gerrez a bit suspicious in general seemed to be overcompensating a bit trying to look like a town, and then looking to afcftw to guide his vote when we pretty much had a 100% lynch... But by all accounts Gerrez is a shifty bugger anyway so maybe he's actually innocent.

I said I'd follow the known innocent in the pregame discussion. I have the reason to change that as I have next to nothing to go on so far.

The only thing i think i know is who the journo is, obviously that's not something we want to be revealing to the Mafia though.

 

[Obi Wan]

Where do we stand for tomorrow?

Are we going to vote for an inactive? If not, who and why?

I can't think of any specific action anyone has taken ( now Mikey seems to be kosher) to put them in front of the lynch mob. Or I could just be missing all the key points again.

Agree the inactives 'might' be suspect, but we might get some clues from the witness and/or reporter before diving into tactics?

 

[Super G Ted'inho]

Gerrez's insistence in kissing up to AFC tonight is a bit odd... First night makes perfect sense but tonight after Nozzer having like 10 votes on him already still asking who to vote for seems odd... seems like just trying to stay on someones good side.

See last comment, pregame discussion and the last Mafia game

The last person I want to follow usually is AFC

 

[astro]

Agree the inactives 'might' be suspect, but we might get some clues from the witness and/or reporter before diving into tactics?

Magic, goonercymraeg and Red Hadron Collider are on my list of suspicious/useless but I agree we should wait until the newspaper is out

 

[Mikey]

I said I'd follow the known innocent in the pregame discussion. I have the reason to change that as I have next to nothing to go on so far.

The only thing i think i know is who the journo is, obviously that's not something we want to be revealing to the Mafia though.

Indeed, though I think yesterday there was plenty to go on by usual Day 2 standards haha. Not trying to nail you to the mast just like I said this is the kind of time where people should be voicing any old opinion as even if it's crap it's still information which at the moment we have none of.

Interesting on the journo, not sure how we can use that as an advantage as of yet, hope you've something up your sleeve.

Magic, goonercymraeg and Red Hadron Collider are on my list of suspicious/useless but I agree we should wait until the newspaper is out

Yeah as things stand I'd probably be working from those three for the lynch tomorrow.

 

[ValleyGraduate12]

Masons are townspeople

It didn't say grandmaster so he can still recruit and be useful

Are they? Didn't know that

 

[goonercymraeg]

Indeed, though I think yesterday there was plenty to go on by usual Day 2 standards haha. Not trying to nail you to the mast just like I said this is the kind of time where people should be voicing any old opinion as even if it's crap it's still information which at the moment we have none of.

Interesting on the journo, not sure how we can use that as an advantage as of yet, hope you've something up your sleeve.



Yeah as things stand I'd probably be working from those three for the lynch tomorrow.

I think Astro may just be trying to hide his own misdeeds

 

[Super G Ted'inho]

Indeed, though I think yesterday there was plenty to go on by usual Day 2 standards haha. Not trying to nail you to the mast just like I said this is the kind of time where people should be voicing any old opinion as even if it's crap it's still information which at the moment we have none of.

Interesting on the journo, not sure how we can use that as an advantage as of yet, hope you've something up your sleeve.

Not sure if suspecting who the journo is is an advantage at all bar believing what that poster says. Especially if said poster doesn't know of my innocence.

The problem I have in this game is experience of some of the players. I know that should be an advantage but it means I know how deceiving they can be so I've no idea whether to trust them or not. Doesn't help that ice been suckered into believing the wrong twice too though

 

[InBiscanWeTrust]

1 RHC - Not much activity... consistent with other games. Lac of activity may correlate with Italian Mafia's inactivity.

2 AFCFTW - Cop, known innocent, no reason to suspect anything else.

3 Bodanki - Known innocent but dead now.

4 Astro - Not much to go on... same levels of activity, stuck with consistent approach round one of no lynch

5 Biscan - known innocent to myself, but obviously not to anyone else.

6 mikey - near enough 100% innocent given his witness report on Nozzer being true and the witness definitely being a townie.

7 magic - See RHC

8 Billy - Same as Astro

9 Gerrez - Slightly suspicious behaviour tonight by still asking for AFC to confirm who to vote for... states being consistent with pre-game talk however after night 1, should have more of an independent mind. One to watch.

10 Nozzer - Russian Mafia done and dead.

11 Danilo - Russian Mafia recent recruit and dead/

12 Swarbs - Not much to go on so far... similar to Astro & Billy.

13 Valley - Similar to RHC & Magic, not very active however more active so would suggest if the don then would have chosen an action by now.

14 Less hope than Neville - Innocent dead.

15 The sinful dwarf - Who?

16 trevornufc - Obi Wan I think? Small activity, hard to judge being a newbie to our game... not much to go on.

17 BobbyD - Similar to the other blues.

18 goonercymraeg - Similar to Magic & RHC


That's a real quick overview of what I've taken from the game so far.... Those in Blue aren't really showing much. The ones in Orange are really inactive which could account for Mafia inactivity. Gerrez is only other one that stands out for me from tonight's actions however I'm no where near saying that he is mafia.

Depending on what comes back from the paper tomorrow morning, wouldn't be against putting a couple like Mafic, RHC & Gooner up together and see if it gets any of them talking and anyone trying to save them

 

[InBiscanWeTrust]

Just relised Sinful Dwarf is probably Morgan Freeman....

I'd put him Blue, a bit of activity, nothing to suspect as yet.

 

[Obi Wan]

1 RHC - Not much activity... consistent with other games. Lac of activity may correlate with Italian Mafia's inactivity.

2 AFCFTW - Cop, known innocent, no reason to suspect anything else.

3 Bodanki - Known innocent but dead now.

4 Astro - Not much to go on... same levels of activity, stuck with consistent approach round one of no lynch

5 Biscan - known innocent to myself, but obviously not to anyone else.

6 mikey - near enough 100% innocent given his witness report on Nozzer being true and the witness definitely being a townie.

7 magic - See RHC

8 Billy - Same as Astro

9 Gerrez - Slightly suspicious behaviour tonight by still asking for AFC to confirm who to vote for... states being consistent with pre-game talk however after night 1, should have more of an independent mind. One to watch.

10 Nozzer - Russian Mafia done and dead.

11 Danilo - Russian Mafia recent recruit and dead/

12 Swarbs - Not much to go on so far... similar to Astro & Billy.

13 Valley - Similar to RHC & Magic, not very active however more active so would suggest if the don then would have chosen an action by now.

14 Less hope than Neville - Innocent dead.

15 The sinful dwarf - Who?

16 trevornufc - Obi Wan I think? Small activity, hard to judge being a newbie to our game... not much to go on.

17 BobbyD - Similar to the other blues.

18 goonercymraeg - Similar to Magic & RHC


That's a real quick overview of what I've taken from the game so far.... Those in Blue aren't really showing much. The ones in Orange are really inactive which could account for Mafia inactivity. Gerrez is only other one that stands out for me from tonight's actions however I'm no where near saying that he is mafia.

Depending on what comes back from the paper tomorrow morning, wouldn't be against putting a couple like Mafic, RHC & Gooner up together and see if it gets any of them talking and anyone trying to save them

The Sinful Dwarf was/is me. Trev is now the Real Morgan Freeman .

 

[Super G Ted'inho]

1 RHC - Not much activity... consistent with other games. Lac of activity may correlate with Italian Mafia's inactivity.

2 AFCFTW - Cop, known innocent, no reason to suspect anything else.

3 Bodanki - Known innocent but dead now.

4 Astro - Not much to go on... same levels of activity, stuck with consistent approach round one of no lynch

5 Biscan - known innocent to myself, but obviously not to anyone else.

6 mikey - near enough 100% innocent given his witness report on Nozzer being true and the witness definitely being a townie.

7 magic - See RHC

8 Billy - Same as Astro

9 Gerrez - Slightly suspicious behaviour tonight by still asking for AFC to confirm who to vote for... states being consistent with pre-game talk however after night 1, should have more of an independent mind. One to watch.

10 Nozzer - Russian Mafia done and dead.

11 Danilo - Russian Mafia recent recruit and dead/

12 Swarbs - Not much to go on so far... similar to Astro & Billy.

13 Valley - Similar to RHC & Magic, not very active however more active so would suggest if the don then would have chosen an action by now.

14 Less hope than Neville - Innocent dead.

15 The sinful dwarf - Who?

16 trevornufc - Obi Wan I think? Small activity, hard to judge being a newbie to our game... not much to go on.

17 BobbyD - Similar to the other blues.

18 goonercymraeg - Similar to Magic & RHC


That's a real quick overview of what I've taken from the game so far.... Those in Blue aren't really showing much. The ones in Orange are really inactive which could account for Mafia inactivity. Gerrez is only other one that stands out for me from tonight's actions however I'm no where near saying that he is mafia.

Depending on what comes back from the paper tomorrow morning, wouldn't be against putting a couple like Mafic, RHC & Gooner up together and see if it gets any of them talking and anyone trying to save them

Fair assessment. The reason you put for me is why I tried to commit suicide in the last game though

Edit... Also annoying that yet again I'm rated as a bigger suspect than the ones that haven't posted [HASHTAG]#silencekeepsyousafe[/HASHTAG]

 

[InBiscanWeTrust]

The Sinful Dwarf was/is me. Trev is now the Real Morgan Freeman .

Ok, you're both rated the same in my opinion lol.

 

[InBiscanWeTrust]

Fair assessment. The reason you put for me is why I tried to commit suicide in the last game though

Edit... Also annoying that yet again I'm rated as a bigger suspect than the ones that haven't posted [HASHTAG]#silencekeepsyousafe[/HASHTAG]

No at all... Don't let the red fool you more than the orange.

At the bottom of my post I sad I'd much rather see the 3 who aren't talking up for lynching more than you... if you hadn't have asked AFC who to vote for tonight then you would be blue along with the rest... in my opinion, just looked a bit suspicious.

 

[Magnet]

So, it's goodnight everyone and see what the paper says.

 

[Super G Ted'inho]

No at all... Don't let the red fool you more than the orange.

At the bottom of my post I sad I'd much rather see the 3 who aren't talking up for lynching more than you... if you hadn't have asked AFC who to vote for tonight then you would be blue along with the rest... in my opinion, just looked a bit suspicious.

Fair enough, no complaints and I can see why. I'm still planning on being guided by him as he's the only poster I trust!

 

[Mikey]

So let's lay this out, there's 14 players left. 3 Italian mafia, 2 Russian Mafia, 1 Serial Killer. So there's 8 towns.

afcftw is proven and has a deputy who as of now is also 100% town.
I'm effectively proven at this point.
The mason grandmaster can still and should recruit, but is at risk of recruiting a mafia unless he recruits someone proven who he can then reveal himself to.

Here's how personally I think we should be going about things (unless the paper has any revelations):
The Vigilante should start shooting, we could possibly get a nice town circle going soon at which point we can just overpower the mafia, we have near 50/50 odds of hitting a bad guy at this stage. I'd suggest the Vigi selects someone from a list provided by @afcftw
The grandmaster should recruit
The journo should follow someone from the same list as the Vigi is kiling from.
The town should lynch an inactive, with goonercymraeg and ValleyGraduate posting a bit more the main two I guess are RHC or magic.

 

[Super G Ted'inho]

So let's lay this out, there's 14 players left. 3 Italian mafia, 2 Russian Mafia, 1 Serial Killer. So there's 8 towns.

afcftw is proven and has a deputy who as of now is also 100% town.
I'm effectively proven at this point.
The mason grandmaster can still and should recruit, but is at risk of recruiting a mafia unless he recruits someone proven who he can then reveal himself to.

Here's how personally I think we should be going about things (unless the paper has any revelations):
The Vigilante should start shooting, we could possibly get a nice town circle going soon at which point we can just overpower the mafia, we have near 50/50 odds of hitting a bad guy at this stage. I'd suggest the Vigi selects someone from a list provided by @afcftw
The grandmaster should recruit
The journo should follow someone from the same list as the Vigi is kiling from.
The town should lynch an inactive, with goonercymraeg and ValleyGraduate posting a bit more the main two I guess are RHC or magic.

You could say the same for the Serial Killer couldn't you? To stand any chance of winning he needs to kill the Mafia too, no way he can win whilst they're (the Italian Mafia) working together. That would effectively mean he is working alongside the townies atm. Why not use his killing skills to our advantage for now?

 

[Mikey]

You could say the same for the Serial Killer couldn't you? To stand any chance of winning he needs to kill the Mafia too, no way he can win whilst they're (the Italian Mafia) working together. That would effectively mean he is working alongside the townies atm. Why not use his killing skills to our advantage for now?

Indeed if he felt like co-operating that'd be dandy too!