Off Topic mafia 5: game thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
The Real Morgan Freeman said:
Agree it seems more sense to, at least initially, vote for non speakers. So combining that with afc's first half of list suggestion

I VOTE BOBBY

as Astro and Bodanki have spoken and he's next on the list.
Click to expand...

I voted BobbyD. Next is danilo, goonercym, gerrez
 
The Real Morgan Freeman said:
Gerrez and Danilo (I think, can't be bothered to re-read everything. Anyone who can tell me if I'm wrong) have been on and so not inclined at this stage to vote for them. Am happy to change vote to Goonercym if others wish.
Click to expand...

I've read every word and commented a fair bit too
 
Can everyone please stop being ****s and get their **** together

Thanks <ok>
 
Bodanki said:
Yup, need a rule that if you dont comment at least 3 times in each day cycle, you contract Ebola, and Small pox, and AIDS.
And you become a United fan.
Click to expand...

i suggested this but was shot down... though even i was no going so far as making them utd fans
 
As the app doesn't work with a table here is a new format:


IBWT - 1 vote - by Nozzer
No Lynch - 4 vote - by bobbyD mikey Danilo RHC
Bodanki -1 vote- by AFCFTW
Danilo -1 vote- Swarbs
BobbyD - 2 vote- by Astro, Real Morgan
Astro - 1 vote - by IBWT
Billy - 1 vote - by Gerrez
Less hope than neville - 1 vote - by Bodanki

no votes:
RHC
AFCFTW
mikey
magic
Gerrez
Nozzer
Valley
Obi wan
real morgan freeman
Swarbs
goonercymraeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Super G Ted'inho and astro
In line with the prematch strategy, afcftw proposed we vote for: Astro, Bodanki, bobby, billy, danilo, goonercym, gerrez, less hope than Neville

Votes so far (I think)

No Lynch ---4--- (BobbyD, Mikey, danilo, Red Hadron Collider)
Red Hadron Collider
afcftw
Bodanki ---1--- (afcftw)
astroturfnaut ---1--- (InBiscanWeTrust)
InBiscanWeTrust ---1--- (Nozzer)
Mikey
Magic
The artist Billy Can can ---1--- (Gerrez)
Gerrez
Nozzer
danilo. ---1--- (Swarbs)
Swarbs
ValleyGraduate12
Less Hope Than Neville ---1--- (Bodanki)
Obi Wan
The Real Morgan Freeman
BobbyD ---2--- (astroturfnaut, The Real Morgan Freeman)
goonercymraeg

edit: see MITO above
 
Morgan freeman change to goonercym and someone vote gerrez

And then someone post the table so we know wtf is going on :p

Edit: table already posted
 
I think having eight players in the vote defeats the point. It's only a 12.5% risk so they would probably sit it out and take the risk.

Only way it works is if it includes two members of one team presenting a 25% risk.

Better off only having three or four in the vote IMO.

And no, that's not me trying to change things, I said exactly the same on the pregame thread and I don't mind if I'm one of the players at risk.
 
Gerrez said:
I think having eight players in the vote defeats the point. It's only a 12.5% risk so they would probably sit it out and take the risk.

Only way it works is if it includes two members of one team presenting a 25% risk.

Better off only having three or four in the vote IMO.

And no, that's not me trying to change things, I said exactly the same on the pregame thread and I don't mind if I'm one of the players at risk.
Click to expand...

Makes sense to me. Still think it should be those being quiet, can see what afc had done in picking random people but why not pick those not saying anything.

Are whoing to learn much from having you Astro up for example when neither are going to change your posting patterns? Better voting for those not doing much, see if it kicks them into life all of a sudden.

But as said, it's afc's choice.
 
Personally I'd target people who have been online but not posted (Assuming this isn't classed as out of game information, apologies if it is) over just alphabetical, but also don't mind just following the method of the proven town. So crossreferencing this list of people who haven't spoken Astro posted, and the alphabetical 8, goonercymraeg has been online and posting elswhere but silent here, so I'll go for him.

Changing lynch to goonercymraeg for now.
 
IBWT - 1 vote - by Nozzer

No Lynch - 3 vote - by bobbyD, Danilo, RHC

Bodanki -1 vote- by AFCFTW

Danilo -1 vote- Swarbs

BobbyD - 2 vote- by Astro, Real Morgan

Astro - 1 vote - by IBWT

Billy - 1 vote - by Gerrez

Less hope than neville - 1 vote – by Bodanki

Goonercymraeg - 1 vote – by mikey



no votes:

RHC

AFCFTW

mikey

magic

Gerrez

Nozzer

Valley

Obi wan

real morgan freeman

Swarbs
 
Swarbs said:
Sounds good. My vote will stay on danilo unless my Mafia boss tells me to change it.

Bodanki, who do you want me to vote for?
Click to expand...

Well I think you should vo........waaaaaaaait a minute!!

You must log in or register to see images
 
Mikey said:
Personally I'd target people who have been online but not posted (Assuming this isn't classed as out of game information, apologies if it is) over just alphabetical, but also don't mind just following the method of the proven town. So crossreferencing this list of people who haven't spoken Astro posted, and the alphabetical 8, goonercymraeg has been online and posting elswhere but silent here, so I'll go for him.

Changing lynch to goonercymraeg for now.
Click to expand...

Again makes perfect sense to me... <ok>
 
Mikey said:
Personally I'd target people who have been online but not posted (Assuming this isn't classed as out of game information, apologies if it is) over just alphabetical, but also don't mind just following the method of the proven town. So crossreferencing this list of people who haven't spoken Astro posted, and the alphabetical 8, goonercymraeg has been online and posting elswhere but silent here, so I'll go for him.

Changing lynch to goonercymraeg for now.
Click to expand...

No rule for out of game comments etc. We usually use that sort of info.
 
Evening lads, anybody care to fill me in on what's happened so far as ive been at therosslyn 7s in Wimbledon today.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom
Back