Cattermole or Henderson ?

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
I'm not daft enough to compare them. Completely different players. I'd go as far to say they play different positions.

Who do you rate best?

****e thread in all honestly
 
In value to the midfield…. both central mids, how do you say they are so different ?

Because I've got eyes and a brain marra. One is a box to box the other is a DM, they aren't just central mids. CM is a very broad term, you got DM's, box to box, holding, deep lying playmakers.

Catts and Hendo are completely different. imo of course. <ok>
 
By the way Funk, we all know they don't have exactly the same DNA but they both play central midfield, no need for the shi*te. Who would people have in our central midfield ? Chill oot man !
 
I'm not daft enough to compare them. Completely different players. I'd go as far to say they play different positions.

Who do you rate best?

s**te thread in all honestly

Because I've got eyes and a brain marra. One is a box to box the other is a DM, they aren't just central mids. CM is a very broad term, you got DM's, box to box, holding, deep lying playmakers.

Catts and Hendo are completely different. imo of course. <ok>

:emoticon-0184-tmi:..

nowt wrong with that question bri
 
WMS yer probs rite, but not by a mile. I would put Catts down for Stoke at home ahead of our Jordan. Sometimes he isn't involved, Catts can be the new Bally, you gonna know his midfield is there.
 
WMS yer probs rite, but not by a mile. I would put Catts down for Stoke at home ahead of our Jordan. Sometimes he isn't involved, Catts can be the new Bally, you gonna know his midfield is there.

catts has simmered so much, but he's still got to watch the officials, he's really class, hendo is superior in that his vision is better, dont get me wrong, i love catts me, he oozes safc, all round hendo is better but i would play him along side him for england, but woy is too thick to even contemplate that they played together let alone his damning stats
 
I echo what WMS has said, overall Jordan has developed into a cracking all round centre mid, Catts is better at his role, and a leader, and I ****ing love the lad.

I wouldn't swap Catts for Jordan, despite me thinking Jordan is better ability wise.
 
I echo what WMS has said, overall Jordan has developed into a cracking all round centre mid, Catts is better at his role, and a leader, and I ****ing love the lad.

I wouldn't swap Catts for Jordan, despite me thinking Jordan is better ability wise.
 
By the way Funk, we all know they don't have exactly the same DNA but they both play central midfield, no need for the shi*te. Who would people have in our central midfield ? Chill oot man !

No offence marra but i'm still waiting for your opinion, you should have included it in your op. I've had to ask and still non the wiser. Hate threads like this. It's lazy and rude. Why do you want to know? what are your views? I'm not here to entertain you. Debate is a two way street. I've given you my opinion, there's no need to pick Catts or Hendo, they're very different. I'd like them both in the same team obviously. You going to have any input at all? Or just quiz the rest of the posters? If you want to do a comparison it think it would be better if it was like for like, just a suggestion.

Sorry fella but it's one of my biggest pet hates on messageboards, If you'd ended it with Discus it would be a step to far if you know what I mean. You post threads like Stu. His are ****e as well.
 
Apologies Funk, for some reason I am getting your posts too late and talking shi*t my end . Sorry me Darlo lovely.

don't apologise fella, I'm being a dick. :p

Just really hate one sentence threads that's just a question. Pet hate, pet hate, pet hate. Sorry fella, Just ignore me when I'm like this. I can be a massive Bellend. <ok>
 
catts has simmered so much, but he's still got to watch the officials, he's really class, hendo is superior in that his vision is better, dont get me wrong, i love catts me, he oozes safc, all round hendo is better but i would play him along side him for england, but woy is too thick to even contemplate that they played together let alone his damning stats

Great post fella. I'd love to see them playing together again. They've both come on so much, Hendo still with so much development to come. Stupid ass Woy.
 
Hey Funk, I was asking who thought what, not telling everyone what I think. Thought it was a forum for collective debate. In answer to you I think Cattermole has been a better player for Sunderland than Henderson, both lack a bit of creativity but Cattermole influences games more.
Its for debate, not what you and I think. Never meant to upset you&#8230;Plastic Non Mackum Darlo Gippo Loving Ho*o ! xxx
 
Hey Funk, I was asking who thought what, not telling everyone what I think. Thought it was a forum for collective debate. In answer to you I think Cattermole has been a better player for Sunderland than Henderson, both lack a bit of creativity but Cattermole influences games more.
Its for debate, not what you and I think. Never meant to upset you&#8230;Plastic Non Mackum Darlo Gippo Loving Ho*o ! xxx

Gippo! <laugh> ****ing rife with them here.

It's your opinion I wanted marra. I'm very changable, I apologise fella.

Love them both me. Wish we never sold Hendo, what with the way the money was flushed down the ****ter. We may as well have given him away for free and told bruce he had no budget and we'd have still saved a fortune. I think Hendo would have been happy to stay on a a good few seasons longer. We should never had sold him. Hindsight eh?