Scotch Independence - the countdown

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

Should Scotland be an Independent Country?

  • Yes

  • No


Results are only viewable after voting.
They must be showing different stuff on the tv up there and printing different stuff in the papers.

There was some tree hugging hippy woman talking on behalf of the yea campaign talking about creating a special type of inclusive, free and just government.. Without actually saying what that is. What does it mean?

They had some other well spoken Scottish bloke just saying that businesses won't leave and panic.. Then when asked why he believes that he couldn't answer it. That's just what he believed. He believed it would be fine.. Based on nothing other than hyperbole.

I just find the whole situation very strange. For people to say I don't know anything about it. Unfortunately I'm a drone that watched the bbc news every morning over breakfast then at night over dinner and it's been every day Scottish independence. It's in the papers every day down here.

I watched the live debate where salmond made a twat of himself. I didn't see the second one where apparently he was better prepared.

There is so much disinformation and conjecture being disseminated that it should be difficult to make an informed choice but when i'm being sold (Or force fed) a vision of a bleak Scottish wasteland - should I have the temerity to vote Yes - then i'm afraid my default setting of "I'll show these bastards" kicks in and I suspect many Scots feel the same way.

The propaganda from the No camp has been absolutely staggering, that's why I changed my mind. I won't be bullied or lectured to, least of all by people who are too scared to make a coherent argument for the Union because they have a vested interest in maintaining the status quo.
 
There is so much disinformation and conjecture being disseminated that it should be difficult to make an informed choice but when i'm being sold (Or force fed) a vision of a bleak Scottish wasteland - should I have the temerity to vote Yes - then i'm afraid my default setting of "I'll show these bastards" kicks in and I suspect many Scots feel the same way.

The propaganda from the No camp has been absolutely staggering, that's why I changed my mind. I won't be bullied or lectured to, least of all by people who are too scared to make a coherent argument for the Union because they have a vested interest in maintaining the status quo.

I think you've hit the nail on the head with that statement. It defines exactly where the better together campaign have made a pigs arse out it. Regardless of whether what they are saying is true, it's enabled salmond and his team to twist it into an us vs them. Make it easy to to turn into look at them trying to scare us. It's played into his hands. It's enabled him to avoid the focus on how it's actually going to work and give everyone a kind of we'll show them standpoint.
 
I think you've hit the nail on the head with that statement. It defines exactly where the better together campaign have made a pigs arse out it. Regardless of whether what they are saying is true, it's enabled salmond and his team to twist it into an us vs them. Make it easy to to turn into look at them trying to scare us. It's played into his hands. It's enabled him to avoid the focus on how it's actually going to work and give everyone a kind of we'll show them standpoint.

Simplistic bollocks sweats.
 
I think you've hit the nail on the head with that statement. It defines exactly where the better together campaign have made a pigs arse out it. Regardless of whether what they are saying is true, it's enabled salmond and his team to twist it into an us vs them. Make it easy to to turn into look at them trying to scare us. It's played into his hands. It's enabled him to avoid the focus on how it's actually going to work and give everyone a kind of we'll show them standpoint.

I seldom listen to Salmond and I have not watched any debates in which he's been involved because there's no need as you say, the No camp have done all the work for him. Some of their scare tactics have backfired spectaculary, such as no EU membership, no currency of our own and border guards at Berwick. It's laughable.