Whilst I think it is a gamble, and certainly not the decision I would have made, I don't quite understand why everyone is being so completely defeatist about it - it's not like we've re-appointed the Rodent!!
Every manager has to start somewhere, Neeyul is clearly very knowledgable about the game, seems well liked and respected by the players so who is to say he's not got a great managerial career ahead of him?
I can't think of many people I'd like more to be a success in the management game, here's your chance Neeyull - don't let us down!