What should HCAFC do with Nick Proschwitz?

[Spanner82]

Just reading the other thread regarding Nick P, thought we could get an idea of what us HCAFC fans think of him

 

[McGregor HU5]

It depends on if we get a better replacement in.. In which case, everyone would vote to have a better striker in.

 

[BigotAlertAnalRimMan]

We need to loan him to hope that he can recoup some of his value that has now dropped massively.

 

[originallambrettaman]

I voted sell him, the problem is finding anyone who would buy him.

 

[BigotAlertAnalRimMan]

don't see the point in loaning him in the UK because clearly he is not settling.

SO the real answer is "sell him" but we should do this after a loan spell.

 

[Dr.Stanley O'Google, HCFC]

Loan him to an English club. See if he shapes up (at their possible expense?) and then decide whether he comes back or we sell him.

 

[BigotAlertAnalRimMan]

Loan him to an English club. See if he shapes up (at their possible expense?) and then decide whether he comes back or we sell him.

yeh let's loan him to Palace

 

[Quill]

Sell him (and Mclean and Cairney) in a deal for Rhodes.

 

[originallambrettaman]

Shouldn't there be an 'I don't give a ****' option?

 

[Fez]

You'll get next to nowt for him if you can find a buyer, so loan him to low Champs or L1 to get some rousting; abroad might be useful as a shop-window.

 

[Murdoc]

I really wanted him to come good, but I remember losing all faith in him at North Ferriby (even though he scored a sitter). He was getting out-muscled, out played, made stupid passes, the players seemed to be against him and rather run with the ball than pass it to him.

We'll have to take a loss to sell him (which I think we're trying to do) but if some Club came in and wanted to loan him and play him every week it would be great to possibly see him capture some form and regain some sell-on value.

 

[Pat E O'Dors]

Sell him (and Mclean and Cairney) in a deal for Rhodes.

You cannot sell something or somebody, in this case, that nobody wants to buy.

 

[Quill]

You cannot sell something or somebody, in this case, that nobody wants to buy.

I assume you are eluding to Mclean.

If you include him in a deal involving other players and money, they might suddenly want him...

 

[Craigo]

Swap him for Knockaert at Leicester. We know how much they love him.

 

[Quill]

Swap him for Knockaert at Leicester. We know how much they love him.

Give them Cam as well

 

[GLP]

Loan him to an English club. See if he shapes up (at their possible expense?) and then decide whether he comes back or we sell him.

Perfect answer.

 

[hongkongfooi]

send him to orchard park and bransholme schools to do footy lessons in PE

 

[Kudos]

I voted sell because he offers nothing to the team. Some people on here are so fickle.

 

[SydneyTiger14]

Loan him because otherwise we're unlikely to get much value from him. Loan him to a League 1 club to get consistent game time and see if he can get some sort of confidence about his abiliy. If not then he'll go for nothing anyway, but at least we'll have got his wages off our books, and if he comes good then bring him back in January.

 

[ellewoods]

Cant we sell him back to a German club? Dude is proven in their 2nd tier and wouldnt be a gamble to any team in that league.