Who do you want out

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.

Wise James

Member
Jan 28, 2011
457
24
18
NULL
With the transfer market looming on us and all us geordies praying for a miracle or ashley to drop his wallet, There will be departures, Who do you want to see go

Perch
jose - no smoke without fire (so jog on)
Loven - improving but not good enough and a tad to late
 
Ranger- On loan
Perch- Forever
Shola- He's a Geordie but **** all else, not good enough. He'll stay though, he seems to be indispensable
Lover- Only if we replace him, he's looked good with Best
Soderberg- Loan
Kuqi- Give him a coaching role
Campbell- Forever, never darken our dressing room again
Derek Llambias- Shot and buried at sea
 
Kuqi and Campbell, offer coaching roles.
Ranger and loads of youngsters, loan moves to the Championship or L1.
Perch.

Dont see the point in selling 6 or 7 players then buying 5 or 6 and still having a small squad.
 
Smith - UNLESS he takes a pay cut. I think he's a decent player who can have impact when needed and can do a decent job, but he's not worth more than 15k a week.
Shola - Bone idle, lazy and doesn;t deserve to play in our strip. He should go and Lover should stay. Lover man could have scored alot more if Shola could ****ing pass and Lover showed that he can play well with a good partner. Shola has chances to play Lover in for a goal but he can't pass. Lover and Best together are a good partnership, where as Shola helps no one.
Perch
Raylor - Free kick specialist, gets himself ridiculous bookings, and no i'm not just talking about the Bolton game. He could have been sent off vs Chelsea in the cup also. He's an awful RB and he'll never get a game over any of our better players. I'd even take Routledge over Raylor.

Loans -

Ranger - Class young lad but he needs to go out on loan. All he needs to do is score a couple of goals and then he'll be knocking loads in.
Lua Lua - For his own development
Vuckic - I don't see the class in him that everyone is talking about but he should be going out on loan if he's that promosing.
Forster - loan to a PL club.
Airey
 
Perch + Sol, Smithy unless he takes a paycut.

I don't WANT anyone to go otherwise. The only player on pointlessly high wages in relation to his playing ability/pitch time is Smith, and if he can take a pay cut then we may as well take him. Squad depth and such really!
Unless we get decent replacements for not too much. I can't see many players that aren't important fetching decent transfer fees...
 
So long as we have replacements lined up, buy before we sell to avoid the Carroll fiasco happening again.

OUT

Campbell
Lovenkrands
Perch
Raylor
Smith
Kuqi (offer a coaching role)

LOAN OUT
Vuckic
Ranger
Lua Lua (depending on how many wide men we bring in)
Tavernier (if we bring in another defender)
 
In an ideal world if replacements were made I would want:

Campbell- Released
Routledge- Sold
Smith- Sold/Released
Ranger- Loan
Ameobi- Sold
Lovenkrands- Sold/Released
Perch- Sold
Kuqi- Released (kept on in some capacity though)

This is all well and good but then we need to buy 8 players just to have a squad the same size as this one, which is too small as it is.
 
jose - no smoke without fire

I want Jose out.

you'll be singing a different tune if he signs a new contract.

you can't blame the lad for dragging his feet on the matter, especially going with past experiences of Ashley. The lad's a good player and he wants to play at a competitive club, which we'll only be with some good investments in the summer, which is far from guaranteed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.