Ok chaps.. They say a team is as strong as its weakest link.
So who do you think our weakest mainstream player is and why?
So who do you think our weakest mainstream player is and why?
The weakest link
- Thread starter Albert's Chip Shop
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
- Status
OK, I'll go first then.
Willo.
I know I'll get stick as he's done a decent job at times, but for me he's not the kind of player who will keep us challenging for euro places. If either Saylor or Colo get injured / suspended, we look vulnerable.
Yes he's OK, but not good enough. For a big lad he's not strong enough and doesn't dominate in the air.
He can often get caught on the wrong side of the striker, isn't quick enough and gives away silly fouls - and he needs to stop grabbing players / shirts in the penalty area.
There - I await my bashing.
Willo.
I know I'll get stick as he's done a decent job at times, but for me he's not the kind of player who will keep us challenging for euro places. If either Saylor or Colo get injured / suspended, we look vulnerable.
Yes he's OK, but not good enough. For a big lad he's not strong enough and doesn't dominate in the air.
He can often get caught on the wrong side of the striker, isn't quick enough and gives away silly fouls - and he needs to stop grabbing players / shirts in the penalty area.
There - I await my bashing.
I'm going for Obertan Cos I just can't see him progressing this year and he runs down so many blind alleys.
Yeah, Obertan was my other pick. I'm hoping he won't get many starts with the squad we have, whereas Willo is 'likely' to if either Colo or Saylor can't play.
Fair enough, I can take it. But you at least need to offer your views on an alternative weakest link and your reasons why! Otherwise you're not entitled to bash.
Without getting Tash excited with formation talk, what would be your strongest 11 santiagomunez?
I was about to agree with you about the shirt pulling and not dominating in the air, (height is wasted on him), but on reading your thread again, I have to agree with all of it.
He is inconsistent, because he does have the odd moment where he's pretty solid, then makes school boy errors, lots of improvement to be made by a little more concentration.
Now what can we do about Simpson constantly backing off.
I was about to agree with you about the shirt pulling and not dominating in the air, (height is wasted on him), but on reading your thread again, I have to agree with all of it.
He is inconsistent, because he does have the odd moment where he's pretty solid, then makes school boy errors, lots of improvement to be made by a little more concentration.
Now what can we do about Simpson constantly backing off.
Get a new right back?
You should be ashamed of yourself. I am very disappointed in you. Now go to the naughty step to think about your actions and the impact they have on others. And don't come back until you're prepared to apologise.
I think we have a good all round squad, if it was to be a weak link in the starting line up it would be Simmo (and i am constantly saying he's awesome). Think this will be the year to see if he will ever cut it at the highest level in the top league in the world. I hope he does but at the moment couldn't see him playing at a higher placed club than ourselves, but then again i cant think of many RB in lower placed Prem team I'd rather have tbh.
If its not for the Starting XI, then yeah Willo or Obertan would be the weakest players in the squad IMO.
If its not for the Starting XI, then yeah Willo or Obertan would be the weakest players in the squad IMO.
Obertan is not an automatic first team choice, I really want him to come good, I would definitely give him until January at least, I still feel it's too soon to write him off.
It was only against Hartlepool but he showed amazing pace and quick thinking to latch onto the ball and smash it into the back of the net.
- Status