It's bit like being patted on the head then told to run along, and don't upset the big boys
The Premier League Thread
- Thread starter TheSecondStain
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
We should be training refs to be more confident in their on-field instincts and their understanding of the rules and using VAR as a support tool to improve those skills - but currently it's going the other way.
At the moment they can make a poor decision and VAR will compensate for it or worse VAR is removing the responsibility for making a decision at all.
Look at rugby where the ref's decision is final unless the video ref can see something clear and obvious that the ref didn't see that should impact the decision OR the ref specifically asks "is there anything that stops me keeping my decision" and in a lot of cases the games doesn't stop for the wait. It carries on and the video ref goes "hang on a minute - we've seen this that would change that last one"
At the moment they can make a poor decision and VAR will compensate for it or worse VAR is removing the responsibility for making a decision at all.
Look at rugby where the ref's decision is final unless the video ref can see something clear and obvious that the ref didn't see that should impact the decision OR the ref specifically asks "is there anything that stops me keeping my decision" and in a lot of cases the games doesn't stop for the wait. It carries on and the video ref goes "hang on a minute - we've seen this that would change that last one"
Looked very quiet in the first 10 but then I turned over to the F1
Just looking at Kumb and they’re saying he’s their best midfielder by a country mile, even going just by that half.
A bigger win in his first game with West Ham than he had in his entire time with us. Albeit when he was subbed off it was still 0-0
The mindset of rugby union players and fans is instilled into them at a young age, in a good way.
I’ve mentioned before that I have spent some time in the past watching lower level RFU and the comparison with football is like comparing chalk with cheese.
Clubhouses have code of conduct posters on the wall that are policed by the fans themselves and when you see a 50+ year old man say to a young referee “I think you got that decision wrong”, followed by the inclusion of the word “Sir”, not in a sarcastic way, it’s a breathe of fresh air.
I love how different it is, tbh.
The one single rule from rugby I would love to see in football is the 10 yard (metre) rule for dissent. Any backchat and the penalty is moved up the pitch.
Absolutely. But there’s an underlying theme when rugby fans slight football and its fans. As I say, two different sports. They’d be better off moaning about NFL, but then they wouldn’t be able to have the undercurrent of social superiority.
I think they did try that. But like a number of new initiatives it was enforced to start, and then less and less before it was decided it didn't work and we reverted back to what didn't work before that.
Good results earlier today. Forest have gone BIG (overly BIG?) in the market again. +£100m on the bench, so it was nice to see a 0-3 home defeat dished out. I noticed as soon as Matty left the field late on, the goals flew in!
I don't think Watford had any yesterday. While we had 1 non British Isles and a secretly Belgian manager.
Last edited:
This has been as bad as the old firm game just without the atmosphere.