For me - unless we go and sign Ederson - we are going to have to accept these types of mistakes all season.
The difference between McCarthy and a new keeper is how many times we have to suffer these mistakes - not completely eliminate them.
I agree these mistakes are going to happen, even with Baz we were making them and he is very good with his feet for a keeper.
The “pass it to the midfielder just outside the area with someone right up his arse” tactic is usually how the opposition steal the ball when any team plays out from the back.
As you say it’s how often we make those mistakes and whether we want another Bazunu type who isn’t the best shot stopper but better with his feet or the more traditional keeper who won’t be as good (but hopefully better than McCarthy) with his feet.
We lost the ball lots of times last year as well when teams pressed us later on in games, but we weren’t punished any where near as often as we will be in the Prem