I know people think my hatred of loans is irrational (everyone's allowed to have their own opinion). But here's the list of loanees who had their first proper experience of first team football with us, I've gone back till just after the Harry Wilson year (about 6 years) as he was the last successful one. I've popped the minutes they played for us in brackets too.
Ebiowei (519)
Vale (76)
Simons (428)
Salah (0)
Bowler (1042)
To me, it's a clear indication that it's a completely pointless strategy as it doesn't work. Thankfully, it's not one we do very often and when we do it feels like desperation. It's why I'm so pessimistic about the young loan pool this year as it's largely players who have never experienced senior football. I'm not saying the above players are bad players either, they really aren't but the Championship is such a tough level to come straight into and do well.