New Head Coach

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
I think you can mind, they've got worse and a big part of that is Simms failing to deliver for long parts of the season. Wright is quality though
Fair enough about Simms. Really rate Wright, reckon they’ll be receiving bids for him this summer. It was always gonna be tough losing Gyokeres and Hamer - two quality players.
 
How come? If anything it isn't talked about enough how good a job he's done.
Reims arent a Luton for example. They have a good budget relative to league position. He has followed on from coaches he has been number 2 to. Didnt he want to bail out of Reims but couldnt? League 1 isnt elite in my opinion, once you get below 2 or 3 teams it is much of a muchness imo. I think some of his early career experience is really low level stuff.

I love his journey, commitment and passion. I hope he is the next Pep. But right now we need someone with more gravitas and know how. In my opinion anyway.
 
It just felt to me that when people called out the current results they were being dismissed as fans who dont look at the context. If I misunderstood apologies. But folk have a right to point to what look like the sort of results that are worse than some of our coaches appear to get under pressure for. We have a horrible record with supporting coaches generally.

Feel free to ignore me. I think he is entirely the wrong profile for us. Like you though I will support him 100%. Probably more knowing me, I am something of an arch defender of coaches on here. I dont dislike Still at all, but I do think the Reims story is a bit overblown. If they get him, I just hope he is given a fair crack at it. Mowbray wasnt and Beale never was.
Some might have looked at the context but others will just look at the results and thats it. Some would have watched some of Reims matches, some wont have.

My point is there is more to a coaches performance than just what the results are. Yes their primary job is to get points but i look for how they set their teams up, how do they tweak things throughout the game to try n get a positive result, how did their team perform and are the players working hard still

From the games I've seen reims tick those boxes without getting the results

Some will write him off and dont want him because he is young and hasnt managed in the championship before - for me i see a talented coach who has got the absolute most out of the squad hes got

Id rather him than a simon grayson type (an experienced manager in english football when he came to us - granted at an awful time)

Now does that mean Still would be a success with us if we appointed him, no it wouldnt but id be pleased to see us go for someone who has performed well in the job hes in
 
Reims arent a Luton for example. They have a good budget relative to league position. He has followed on from coaches he has been number 2 to. Didnt he want to bail out of Reims but couldnt? League 1 isnt elite in my opinion, once you get below 2 or 3 teams it is much of a muchness imo. I think some of his early career experience is really low level stuff.

I love his journey, commitment and passion. I hope he is the next Pep. But right now we need someone with more gravitas and know how. In my opinion anyway.
Wanted to show loyalty to Garcia whos daughter was dying but Reims promoted him against his will and said to get out of the contract he'd have to pay 600,000. Crazy story and I think he's been itching to leave for a while.

https://www.getfootballnewsfrance.c...ds-oscar-garcia-hes-never-spoken-to-me-again/
 
Fair enough about Simms. Really rate Wright, reckon they’ll be receiving bids for him this summer. It was always gonna be tough losing Gyokeres and Hamer - two quality players.
Yeah Wright and Sheaf will probably be the players they sell this summer and they'll reinvest heavily again. We need to get to that level.
 
Exactly mate, its just because they got to a semi final

Most clubs have issues but according to some of our 'supporters' every club is in a better position than us

They badly needed a right winger so agreed a deal with the lad at Peterborough, £5m iirc, then allowed him to stay there this season. As soon as the Japanese lad was injured that was season over, he's very good tbf. We're accused of showing no ambition, or judgement, but it's not easy this football lark.

(This could all be wrong btw, it's from memory and I don't take much notice of them.)
 
Some might have looked at the context but others will just look at the results and thats it. Some would have watched some of Reims matches, some wont have.

My point is there is more to a coaches performance than just what the results are. Yes their primary job is to get points but i look for how they set their teams up, how do they tweak things throughout the game to try n get a positive result, how did their team perform and are the players working hard still

From the games I've seen reims tick those boxes without getting the results

Some will write him off and dont want him because he is young and hasnt managed in the championship before - for me i see a talented coach who has got the absolute most out of the squad hes got

Id rather him than a simon grayson type (an experienced manager in english football when he came to us - granted at an awful time)

Now does that mean Still would be a success with us if we appointed him, no it wouldnt but id be pleased to see us go for someone who has performed well in the job hes in
My biggest fear about Still or anyone remains the recruitment. Every coach including the experienced Mowbray suffered from our gaps and limited options. Not getting this right and we have a new coach with the same issues, which I don’t think can be fixed with current personnel. Two early crucial additions and they haven’t lost the fans by the windows end.
 
My point is we knew Evans was missing at least half the season back in the summer. We didnt get someone in to replace his quality or influence or experience. Same with Stewart, which is the bigger issue. Seems a real deliberate approach to have very little experience or older players to me. I dont think many will make the approach work.
I think sometimes it is a bigger picture thing band the club rightly or wrongly have identified young talent over more established players, is that because of the re sale value or is it because we had no quality or very little quality in our 18 to 20 year old bracket as back up to the first team when KLD and KS took over. Even last year with the signing of Dack as an older pro he got injured pretty much straight away. Even looking at Corry Evans injuries we have had very little back up (although I do think DN has been very good this year).
Basically we have had to build up the youth teams before adding the 'EXPERIENCE' as if the experienced player or players were to be injured we had nothing behind them.
It has been a bad season and I do think we have overplayed our hand a little bit with development signings but I do also think that this transfer window is the first real opportunity to get them more established players in and if they get injured then we know we have a lad in the reserves or on the bench with minutes under their belt who can step in.
 
this just an opinion mind but if speakman does go.
i've got a little tiny feeling poyet might take his place just thought it was abit strange him coming out saying the owners having been talking to him about next coach and how he's really good friends with them
 
  • Like
Reactions: SAFC2403
Personally I can’t stand the man, no logic to back up the reason why, but just don’t like the way he comes across. Having said that, nobody can argue that he isn’t good at what he does. He consistently produces the goods for them.
And importantly has been given time. Clubs are far too trigger happy. Sacking Mowbray achieved absolutely nothing and just destabilised the club. If they didn't think he was right for the job they should have got rid last summer and appointed someone they had absolute confidence in. Instead they've acted like headless chickens and performances have got worse.
I'm absolutely convinced the club have got someone lined up and are pretty much seeing this season out and sucking up the criticism.
I've said it before and repeating myself but we need better players if we are going to realistically challenge at top of table. That and a proper manager. Big few months ahead
 
this just an opinion mind but if speakman does go.
i've got a little tiny feeling poyet might take his place just thought it was abit strange him coming out saying the owners having been talking to him about next coach and how he's really good friends with them

I really did not like Poyet. I would be gutted if he came back to the club. The football we played under him was absolutely horrendous.

Just passing it amongst the back six over and over until we lost the ball and conceded.

That villa game is the worst game I ever went to at the SoL.

Can't femember him signing well either, those lads from Brighton were really poor, never got the hype around Borini other than that goal. Wouldn't want him as a DoF either but then I'm not doing the hiring.
 
And importantly has been given time. Clubs are far too trigger happy. Sacking Mowbray achieved absolutely nothing and just destabilised the club. If they didn't think he was right for the job they should have got rid last summer and appointed someone they had absolute confidence in. Instead they've acted like headless chickens and performances have got worse.
I'm absolutely convinced the club have got someone lined up and are pretty much seeing this season out and sucking up the criticism.
I've said it before and repeating myself but we need better players if we are going to realistically challenge at top of table. That and a proper manager. Big few months ahead
You’re bang on there. We’re nowhere near good enough atm and the model must change for us to challenge. I reckon we’ll be in this league for years and years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blond Bombshell