Transfer Rumours January '23 Transfer Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
there’s so much more to it then that, understand the view point but it’s come at complete sacrifice to any sort of attacking play or flow. Our entire game is based off playing from the back to open up the opposition, if you think Coyle and Jones are up to it in possession of the football then I’m at a loss. we are reasonably solid, we get lucky and have had some mega displays from both keepers but the reality is we play well within our limits and build very slowly from the back. We need better ball playing defenders who can help us control the game and get on the front foot. As pure defenders Coyle and Jones aren’t terrible squad players, Coyle goes missing for me way more then jones but the improvements lie with the ability on the football, for me it isn’t good enough.
Coyle 100% isn’t good enough for a possession style, but that’s why he’ll be a deputy to someone who is. You can’t expect 2 similar quality players to play for one spot at our level.
 
Coyle 100% isn’t good enough for a possession style, but that’s why he’ll be a deputy to someone who is. You can’t expect 2 similar quality players to play for one spot at our level.

You can if you have prem/parachute income but not realistically on a budget made up from just club turnover plus 13m annual owner investment like most clubs in the champ.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NewcastleTiger
Really interesting what we do top end of the pitch. Oscar and Adama the only ones nailed on really.

Not sure Oscar is that nailed on.

If we were going to free up some kitty then he'd probably the one to command a decent fee - yet only scores in spells with not a lot else in normal play.

Not saying he should go, but suspect he might.
 
Not sure Oscar is that nailed on.

If we were going to free up some kitty then he'd probably the one to command a decent fee - yet only scores in spells with not a lot else in normal play.

Not saying he should go, but suspect he might.

You’re maybe right. Won’t fit in Rosie’s style of closing down etc, however we need to score goals and we can’t replace him, so……
 
You’re maybe right. Won’t fit in Rosie’s style of closing down etc, however we need to score goals and we can’t replace him, so……

It would help if we actually had another fit striker.

Notable though that Tetteh was starting ahead of Oscar when he was fit.
 
Last edited:
Not sure Oscar is that nailed on.

If we were going to free up some kitty then he'd probably the one to command a decent fee - yet only scores in spells with not a lot else in normal play.

Not saying he should go, but suspect he might.
You’ve changed your tune, how far is he off the 15 goals
 
You’ve changed your tune, how far is he off the 15 goals

I'm not saying we should or shouldn't cash in either way, he's probably our most instinctive finisher but the line from Acun about maybe having to sell to buy then maybe its a case of who will command a worthwhile fee?

He's only 1 off his 15. Hopefully hell get it before the season is out.

* edit - 2 off his 15.
 
I know. 14 goals in the championship should get us a good fee, but given the majority of the time he's having a drought without offering much with his back to goal I just wonder if we might cash in.
he has 13
but yes, he's useless outside of the box
offers nothing
 
i aren’t desperate to slag him, he tries hard for the shirt and I respect that. If you think he’s fine then you’re lost imo. So let me get it right, we can’t criticise a single player, we need to give them all new deals and stick by them yet we are still… 16th. If we want to go up we simply need better, there’s no emotion in this for me I don’t have it out for anyone, I just see someone who isn’t good enough to take us where we need to be.

friends from work that I’ve taken to games who support leeds of all people (actual wessies so marginally better) even said to me after Blackburn unprompted “no idea how Coyle still plays for you, need a new back line if you want to challenge” there’s something missing, playing within limitations to appear solid and having the ability to turn us into challengers is all I’m alluding to.

new CB/LB x 2/RB for me

I respect your opinion but I have to disagree with your and your mates’ assessment against Blackburn, mate. He played very well on Saturday night. I get what you’re saying and if we didn’t have Christie, I’d want us to sign a new right-back but Coyle is fine as back-up in this league.
 
Great, get Chris Waddle and ‘Bill’y Clarke coaching him and you’ll have an eggsellent striker for us next season.

Heard any names we’re interested in, ST? A new defensive mid? I like Bielik but that Onyeka from Brentford would be decent as well if they sign another midfielder in the summer.
 
I can’t believe the low opinion of Brandon Fleming to be honest. I thought he showed a lot of promise and I think I only saw him have one bad game (Derby, I think?)

I was gutted when he went out on loan and thought he was very comfortable on the ball and consistently linked up well with players around him going forward.

I guess time will tell but if we do let him go, I will be watching closely to see how he gets on/whether he makes us regret it!
 
I can’t believe the low opinion of Brandon Fleming to be honest. I thought he showed a lot of promise and I think I only saw him have one bad game (Derby, I think?)

I was gutted when he went out on loan and thought he was very comfortable on the ball and consistently linked up well with players around him going forward.

I guess time will tell but if we do let him go, I will be watching closely to see how he gets on/whether he makes us regret it!

He was excellent last season, one of the highest performing full backs in the league on the whoscored and whatever charts that go out every weekend. Had no pre season and was predictably a yard off the pace when thrown straight back into the side as soon as he was back in training. Never really got another chance since. Now obviously he’s a **** league one player.
 
He was excellent last season, one of the highest performing full backs in the league on the whoscored and whatever charts that go out every weekend. Had no pre season and was predictably a yard off the pace when thrown straight back into the side as soon as he was back in training. Never really got another chance since. Now obviously he’s a **** league one player.
No one thinks he’s ****, but he’s warming the bench for a terrible Oxford side and wasn’t fancied by Rosenior. Fortunately because of how good that end of last season was I think a team would pay a decent fee for him if he has no future with us. 23 now with 60 career appearances
 
He was excellent last season, one of the highest performing full backs in the league on the whoscored and whatever charts that go out every weekend. Had no pre season and was predictably a yard off the pace when thrown straight back into the side as soon as he was back in training. Never really got another chance since. Now obviously he’s a **** league one player.

Not really. He's a decent attacking wingback. Questions over his injury record and doesn't look remotely like a championship fullback in a 4 when the defensive job is a tough one

Playing with Keano in front looking to track back and Greaves next door on the left spur of a back 3 then you have something that has been years in the making but he still has a lot to prove at this level as a left back in his own right.

For me anyway.

I'd have said similar about Elder last season now im saying sign him, so who knows? He's on a decent contract so he'll be hard to shift to a lower level permenantly I'd have thought.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: NewcastleTiger