IS it the death of a dream? That is the question facing every Sunderland fan this morning and the man who is posing it is one of the most popular ever to pull on the famous red-and-white shirt, chairman Niall Quinn.
His dream ââ¬â letââ¬â¢s call it ââ¬Åvisionââ¬Â because thatââ¬â¢s Quinnââ¬â¢s own word ââ¬â is that Sunderland, one of Englandââ¬â¢s oldest and most famous clubs, could be rallied and remodelled from their post-war slumbers to take on the biggest and best in the Premier League.
Quinn arrived at Sunderland as a player late in his career and proceeded to play his best football there. He arrived in Roker Parkââ¬â¢s dying days and moved to the new Stadium of Light in 1997, fired by the passion of the crowd that filled their new 48,000-seater home to the rafters time and again.
When Bob Murray, the chairman behind the modernisation, quit to make way for new investment, it was Quinn who returned with fellow-Irish businessmen backing the club. That initial bubble burst with the Irish economy in 2008 so Quinn, pursuing his vision, found and delivered Texan billionaire Ellis Short.
ââ¬ÅThe vision is that with our passion, we have a chance of competing with the best,ââ¬Â he said. ââ¬ÅIn the first season after our last promotion we averaged a fantastic 44,000 and spent most of the season in the bottom three but managed to scrape out of the relegation places in the last few games ââ¬â that struggle did not seem to bother us at the gate.
ââ¬ÅI told Ellis that with a base of 44,000 we could build on that and take on the bigger boys ââ¬â not with similar investment to the very biggest clubs but with raw passion and emotion. It adds a different component and makes us a big club. Itââ¬â¢s what makes Sunderland special and difficult to beat.
ââ¬ÅThat was my vision, thatââ¬â¢s what I put to Ellis and he bought into that. Our rise on the pitch has been steady and until our recent wobble weââ¬â¢ve spent much of the winter in the top six or seven but the gates, instead of improving with the team, have gone the other way, down to about 38,000 this season.
ââ¬ÅThat canââ¬â¢t continue. If it does, it may be the end of my vision. Iââ¬â¢m not sure I could continue to ask the owner to underwrite that.ââ¬Â
What follows next for Quinn is a battle to win back those lost fans ââ¬â not, he believes, lost as Sunderland followers but lost at the gate. Many have defected to illegal broadcasts of Sunderland home matches, shown in pubs, clubs and bars in the clubââ¬â¢s heartland every Saturday afternoon ââ¬â live ââ¬â when they were populating the Stadium of Lightââ¬â¢s stands in past years. How many? Quinn believes it could be a staggering 10,000 screen defectors for every home game.
ââ¬ÅThis is not anecdotal,ââ¬Â he assured me. ââ¬ÅWeââ¬â¢ve done our research. Weââ¬â¢ve had Premier League observers investigate whatââ¬â¢s going on. There is one typical town in our heartland which has around 50 pubs, clubs, cricket clubs, social clubs and other bars. They found 37 of those 50 were showing our games live, illegally. Thatââ¬â¢s just one town and I could name another 12 in our area where the same thing is happening.
ââ¬ÅIf just 30 people are watching in each bar ââ¬â and thatââ¬â¢s a conservative number ââ¬â you see the scale of the problem.
ââ¬ÅThose fans may be saving on a match ticket but theyââ¬â¢re still turning up to have their fish and chips, beer or sandwiches. I donââ¬â¢t think all of them canââ¬â¢t afford to watch us.ââ¬Â Quinn is now going on the campaign trail again over the next four to six weeks. He will meet the stayaways and urge them to return to keep the ââ¬Åvisionââ¬Â alive.
ââ¬ÅEllis Short has kept his side of the bargain,ââ¬Â says Quinn. ââ¬ÅIââ¬â¢m announcing that Ellis put in another ã28million of his own money last season. And yet the crowds will have gone down a further 10 per cent.
ââ¬ÅIn these next four to six weeks I am going out into the heartland again. I am going to speak to our fans and Iââ¬â¢ll get the message out there. There will be no holds barred. The future shape of the club depends on that. The fans in front of those illegal screens or at home watching illegal sites on their home computers perhaps do not understand how critical it is. If I donââ¬â¢t win them back, the club may have to downsize and cut its cloth differently. Itââ¬â¢ll be difficult to follow up on the current investment and players may have to be sold.
ââ¬ÅManchester United have just announced turnover of ã289m; ours is ã64m. We canââ¬â¢t compete financially with that. Our missing 10,000 fans cost us ã1.8m over the season so a figure like that wonââ¬â¢t make the difference in allowing us to compete ââ¬â it is those fans being inside the ground and making it a hostile place for visiting sides that makes the difference.
ââ¬ÅWhen United came earlier in the season the ground was full and rocking and in the closing moments Sir Alex Ferguson was screaming for the referee to end it. He doesnââ¬â¢t normally do that...thatââ¬â¢s the difference Iââ¬â¢m talking about.
ââ¬ÅWhat I want from our fans is their atmospheric input. Thatââ¬â¢s what makes the place special. If they donââ¬â¢t come back, we may not be the club I thought we were and could be. Me, finish as chairman? I donââ¬â¢t want to ask myself that question but it will mean events have not gone the way we want.ââ¬Â
Critics say Quinn underestimates the economic factors. Sunderland is feeling the recession more than most cities and is still coming to terms with the loss of massive industries.
ââ¬ÅPeople have accused me of just wanting fansââ¬â¢ money in an area where it is just not affordable,ââ¬Â he admits. ââ¬ÅThatââ¬â¢s not my complaint. If any one of our fans tells me: ââ¬ËLook, I just canââ¬â¢t afford to watch youââ¬â¢, I can have no problem with that.
ââ¬ÅBut we do our level best to make Sunderland good value to watch. Weââ¬â¢re right up there in the top places in the table but we are 18th in the league of season-ticket prices. Only two Premier clubs are cheaper to watch than us.
ââ¬ÅAmong the first reactions to what I said in the programme, a stayaway said we hadnââ¬â¢t repainted some parts of the stadium and the concourses were dreary ââ¬â stuff like that.
ââ¬ÅThatââ¬â¢s not the Sunderland fans I know and love...the miners who stood up to Thatcher; the fans who follow us through thick and thin...staying away because the concourses may need a lick of paint? Thatââ¬â¢s a worry.
ââ¬ÅLook, if we get 45,000 season-ticket holders for next season, I will get down on my knees and apologise to them all ââ¬â but it will have been worth it to get them back in the fold.
ââ¬ÅIf we fail then Iââ¬â¢ll do my best for our existing 30,000 season-ticket holders and our other 7-8,000 regulars ââ¬â other than that, the clubââ¬â¢s progress will have been stunted.ââ¬Â