Match Day Thread Hull City v Reading

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

City win?

  • City win

  • Draw

  • Royally done?


Results are only viewable after voting.
Allahyar didn’t arrive injured for months. Weird we’ve signed some no-mark reserve player from Arsenal on loan, gave him the #10 shirt and haven’t seen him once since we signed him.

We’ve made a few pointless signings. The kid from Arsenal, the two from Chelsea and Ryan Woods. Signing players we didn’t need when we’re crying out for a strong defensive midfielder to compliment Seri.

They should only compliment Seri when he has done something to deserve it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WSTiger
Allahyar didn’t arrive injured for months. Weird we’ve signed some no-mark reserve player from Arsenal on loan, gave him the #10 shirt and haven’t seen him once since we signed him.

We’ve made a few pointless signings. The kid from Arsenal, the two from Chelsea and Ryan Woods. Signing players we didn’t need when we’re crying out for a strong defensive midfielder to compliment Seri.

They clearly rate the arsenal kid and as he's here with a view to a perm they obviously feel he might be one for the future. Maybe his injury was the reason he wasn't signed on a perm in the first place?

Agree on the Chelsea lads - I assume they were signed as cover when injuries hit, but given we play a midfield 3 then having 5 first team CM's (Seri, Woods, Tufan, Slater and Doc - the latter 3 having added versatility in other positions) isn't exactly a massive overstock.

Cannon hasn't got a squad number so is clearly surplus, but as far as Woods is concerned, given the fact he's starting despite the others being fit then I can't see how he can be deemed a 'pointless' signing.

For number 10 role we have Pelkas and Traore when he comes back from injury. I'd suspect M'hand would have been signed as a youngster to try and break through and provide cover if needed.
 
Last edited:
They clearly rate the arsenal kid and as he's here with a view to a perm they obviously feel he might be one for the future. Maybe his injury was the reason he wasn't signed on a perm in the first place?

Agree on the Chelsea lads - I assume they were signed as cover when injuries hit, but given we play a midfield 3 then having 5 first team CM's (Seri, Woods, Tufan, Slater and Doc - the latter 3 having added versatility in other positions) isn't exactly a massive overstock.

Cannon hasn't got a squad number so is clearly surplus.

For number 10 role we have Pelkas and Traore when he comes back from injury. I'd suspect M'hand would have been signed as a youngster to try and break through and provide cover if needed.

I get the impression Pelkas will only be here for this year, don’t think he has an option and imagine getting rid of his no doubt big wages in an area we should be well stocked in when Salah and Traore are fit. Should give more financial wiggle room to sign a quality defender or two.
 
I get the impression Pelkas will only be here for this year, don’t think he has an option and imagine getting rid of his no doubt big wages in an area we should be well stocked in when Salah and Traore are fit. Should give more financial wiggle room to sign a quality defender or two.

Isn't he out of contract and therefore available for free at the end of the season?

Obvs we'll potentially have to fend off interest elsewhere to agree terms so there's no guarantees but he doesn't need an option as his loan here takes him to the end of his Fenerbache contract.
 
Isn't he out of contract and therefore available for free at the end of the season?

Obvs we'll potentially have to fend off interest elsewhere to agree terms so there's no guarantees but he doesn't need an option as his loan here takes him to the end of his Fenerbache contract.

That rings a bell tbh so you could be right. Even so - and this is assuming Traore and Salah are up to the level and can stay fit, which we should find out in the second half of this season - the wages on him would be better spent on a top defender or defensive midfielder.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Brucebones
I absolutely agree with this. Was very conscious in the L1 promotion season how much nous we showed. Slowed the game down on throw ins but also Magennis and Honeyman were constantly niggling at refs and drawing loads of fouls. I don't see anyone in the current team who seems to do that. It shouldn't be needed of course, but I really feel we've had some awful refereeing decisions this season and begin to wonder if it's a factor. Normally when people complain about the ref I think it's just our natural bias but this season I really feel we've had a raw deal almost every game I've seen.
You. Can’t say the H word
 
  • Like
Reactions: SydneyTiger14
That rings a bell tbh so you could be right. Even so - and this is assuming Traore and Salah are up to the level and can stay fit, which we should find out in the second half of this season - the wages on him would be better spent on a top defender or defensive midfielder.

Guess it depends whether we can free up space and budget elsewhere - or what offers Pelkas receives from other clubs as a free agent. We won't be the only ones interested if we want to sign him permanently. For me, if he continues as he has started then we'd be mad not to try and keep him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Benjo
Allahyar didn’t arrive injured for months. Weird we’ve signed some no-mark reserve player from Arsenal on loan, gave him the #10 shirt and haven’t seen him once since we signed him.

We’ve made a few pointless signings. The kid from Arsenal, the two from Chelsea and Ryan Woods. Signing players we didn’t need when we’re crying out for a strong defensive midfielder to compliment Seri.


That's utter tosh. We signed Salah for the long term and not just for the here and now. That's also why we took him injured. It's not everyday that a club of our size can sign a top young talent.

You can say the Chelsea lads were pointless signings as they were squad fillers mind.

If there was a quality defensive midfielder that we could've signed, we would have. We didn't just sign a Chelsea kid instead, it would've been a last resort
 
Odd. I thought Seri had a decent game. Worked hard, constantly trying to make things happen, some Huddlesque passes. Things just didn't come off today all round. It was a terrible dive though, expecting a bit more contact that never came I guess.
Well he definitely was not at his best but as I said earlier he did make the midfield strum at times even though he never got to actually pulling the strings as he sometimes does.
 
That's utter tosh. We signed Salah for the long term and not just for the here and now. That's also why we took him injured. It's not everyday that a club of our size can sign a top young talent.

You can say the Chelsea lads were pointless signings as they were squad fillers mind.

If there was a quality defensive midfielder that we could've signed, we would have. We didn't just sign a Chelsea kid instead, it would've been a last resort
So talented Arsenal let him go but kept their ****ter ones? interesting
 
I doubted him about 5/6 games in, he seemed to disappear and not want to be here. But not now. We are beyond lucky to have him in our shirt and with the right people beside him (might not be until next season) he will go to a different level. If I was Acun/ LR I'd be building around him.
Gotta to agree with that. I would be hard pressed to name a player of his calibre that has had the shirt on in the past. Huddlestone maybe in his prime. Tom had a great pass on him but not sure his control in tight situations was as good Seris and that in my opinion is what make him such a great player his ability to receive the ball in tight situations control it and then magically get himself into a positon to play a killer pass. He demonstrated that in spades during the first half of the Cardiff game. A joy to watch.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DuaneDarby18
If arsenal wanted to keep him they’d have kept him

let’s hope he goes on to have a great career for us

It's not always that simple for youngsters. There's only so many games, it's pretty limited really and they have a lot of players in his position. Not every club is as twattish as Chelsea where when Solanke refused to sign a new deal so they wouldn't let him play for the 23s.

He's not their top level of talent either so when he said he wanted to leave, they've let him.

He's obviously not ****e though as he did get on their pre season tour