Weekend Debate

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Emu said:
****ing hell, I said this last week and got told I was too pessimistic.

If the signings are worse than Koch, Bates or Klich in midfield then we better hope Phillips doesn't leave or get injured.
Click to expand...
What do you mean worse than Koch??!!!!
If a player plays for his national side at CB and we buy him, where are you going to play him? Oh let’s play him in MF and let him loose confidence actual play time etc. ffs
Who do you rate better, Cooper or Koch? I for one was fed up of square pegs in round holes last season, the new recruits are better than Bate and Klich, not be hard to beat them but Bate is still young don’t forget.
 
  • Like
Reactions: wakeybreakyheart
Think emu was referring Koch purely because he was used as a Phillips replacement last year… as we didn’t have any other dm’s at the club.

For the record koch has actually played for Germany as a dm.

whenever we played him as a centre back in his first season for me he was a bit of a defensive liability. Couldn’t get up to pace with the PL. Hopefully after 2 years now he’s adapted and becomes an asset.

Given both bielsa and marsch seem to like a left and right footer centre back pairing, Koch was really competing with lorrente rather than coops and It seems both bielsa and marsch preferred lorrente.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Whitejock
Doc said:
Romano has stated yesterday that Leeds are in discussions with PSG and they believe Kalimuendo is the answer to their striker problems. 12 goals from 32 games is a great result in the top French league.


Reports are suggesting Leeds have already lodged a bid for the 20-year-old which is believed to be worth in the region of €20m (£17m).

He has been highly rated by the talent scout Jacek Kulig who called him ‘absolutely deadly’ on Twitter having hailed the striker following his hat-trick against the Netherlands at U17 level.

However, with just 19 goals to his name in the French top flight, could this be the man to improve Leeds in front of goal following their struggles last season?
Click to expand...
No
 
  • Like
Reactions: southernwhite and Doc
milkyboy said:
I see super pundit paul Robinson is at it again… desperately trying to have an earnest, forthright and considered opinion but always coming across as an irrelevant buffoon. I get the whole controversy = clicks thing, but when you just come across as a bellend every time you open your mouth… is it worth the price?

https://www.leeds-live.co.uk/sport/leeds-united/ex-leeds-united-star-paul-24236953
Click to expand...
I don’t actually mind what he said this time. They don’t fill you with excitement and they wouldn’t soften the blow of losing Phillips and Raphinha.
 
Doc said:
Romano has stated yesterday that Leeds are in discussions with PSG and they believe Kalimuendo is the answer to their striker problems. 12 goals from 32 games is a great result in the top French league.


Reports are suggesting Leeds have already lodged a bid for the 20-year-old which is believed to be worth in the region of €20m (£17m).

He has been highly rated by the talent scout Jacek Kulig who called him ‘absolutely deadly’ on Twitter having hailed the striker following his hat-trick against the Netherlands at U17 level.

However, with just 19 goals to his name in the French top flight, could this be the man to improve Leeds in front of goal following their struggles last season?
Click to expand...
Deadly.... at least a goal every two games in my view and just Stella in junior football
 
  • Like
Reactions: Irishshako and wakeybreakyheart
ristac said:
I don’t actually mind what he said this time. They don’t fill you with excitement and they wouldn’t soften the blow of losing Phillips and Raphinha.
Click to expand...
I do not get the whole phillips thing. Bielsa made him look good and we can do better than him. He creates very little and is not that quick. If anyone offers over 30 million for him take it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FORZA LEEDS and Irishshako
ristac said:
I don’t actually mind what he said this time. They don’t fill you with excitement and they wouldn’t soften the blow of losing Phillips and Raphinha.
Click to expand...

Entitled to your opinion bud… but of course they wouldn’t soften the blow, who has ever suggested they would - they don’t even play in the same positions. They’re strengthening the squad (we hope) in areas it needed strengthening and most fans are reasonably happy with them.

Both are young internationals with champions league experience. But apparently they’re not ‘proper players’.

Just another Needless cretinous comment from an annoying pr*ck.

over-rated showpony as a goalkeeper too.

other than that he’s great. <laugh>
 
  • Like
Reactions: southernwhite, Jammy 07, FORZA LEEDS and 1 other person
milkyboy said:
Entitled to your opinion bud… but of course they wouldn’t soften the blow, who has ever suggested they would - they don’t even play in the same positions. They’re strengthening the squad (we hope) in areas it needed strengthening and most fans are reasonably happy with them.

Both are young internationals with champions league experience. But apparently they’re not ‘proper players’.

Just another Needless cretinous comment from an annoying pr*ck.

over-rated showpony as a goalkeeper too.

other than that he’s great. <laugh>
Click to expand...
What I don’t get is how fans can be either happy or unhappy with the new signings without having seen them perform yet. It’s understandable that we all want to get excited but as has been pointed out in many an occasion, a five minute you tube collection can make a player look very good or bad. With Rapha and Kp we know how good they are. It’s damn frustrating if they go
 
  • Like
Reactions: LeedsRover1, SIDDAS, bucks_is_leeds and 1 other person
Infidel said:
What do you mean worse than Koch??!!!!
If a player plays for his national side at CB and we buy him, where are you going to play him? Oh let’s play him in MF and let him loose confidence actual play time etc. ffs
Who do you rate better, Cooper or Koch? I for one was fed up of square pegs in round holes last season, the new recruits are better than Bate and Klich, not be hard to beat them but Bate is still young don’t forget.
Click to expand...

Referring to Koch in midfield. It didn't work. He was a square peg in a round hole. Roca is at least recognised as a defensive midfielder.
 
Emu said:
Referring to Koch in midfield. It didn't work. He was a square peg in a round hole. Roca is at least recognised as a defensive midfielder.
Click to expand...
The whole squad was unbalanced because one man said everything would be fine. But he was a genius so what could go wrong.
We are signing players to play in their proper positions. We are not newcastle or a top six side so cannot compete with their money. So we have to go down the cheaper route and hope jesse puts the T in teamwork. Leicester won the league by being a tight knit squad and rode their luck. We are due a season that is not full of injuries. 17th place is not for us this season i am going for top ten and anything less i will class as failure. I am putting all my faith on jesse and his jeans.
 
  • Like
Reactions: southernwhite and NostradEmus
wakeybreakyheart said:
The whole squad was unbalanced because one man said everything would be fine. But he was a genius so what could go wrong.
We are signing players to play in their proper positions. We are not newcastle or a top six side so cannot compete with their money. So we have to go down the cheaper route and hope jesse puts the T in teamwork. Leicester won the league by being a tight knit squad and rode their luck. We are due a season that is not full of injuries. 17th place is not for us this season i am going for top ten and anything less i will class as failure. I am putting all my faith on jesse and his jeans.
Click to expand...
You must log in or register to see images
 
  • Like
Reactions: wakeybreakyheart and Leedsoflondon
So the superstar that was Big Kev has now been released by Nantes after only playing 77 mins all season, hes now gone to Switzerland, maybe to play for a health spa. Damaged goods….
 
  • Like
Reactions: southernwhite and Irishshako
Surely area of mist concern now must be striker or lack thereof. Bamford May bag 15 this season but he may also continue to be a crock. Wonder is jimmy floyd keeping himself fit these days
 
Seems Notts Forest are in for Summerville, Sheff Utd also trying as well as 3 German and 2 Dutch clubs. Leeds need to do something as he is now in the last year of his contract and he needs football. He has hardly played this season due to the bollox of the first team but even he played twice as many minutes as Big Kev <laugh>
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back