But it was an error. Clear and obvious because it wasn’t four play but a scoring opportunity and it wasn’t.Looking at the foul again you can't overturn the on-field decision. It's not a howler because the challenge is reckless. And once you give foul you have to red card him. At the end of the day getting the ball doesn't mean you can't commit a foul. If he hadn't given a foul Vesty would have got away with it. Either way it wouldn't have been a clear and obvious error.