Off Topic The Politics Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

Should the UK remain a part of the EU or leave?

  • Stay in

    Votes: 56 47.9%
  • Get out

    Votes: 61 52.1%

  • Total voters
    117
  • Poll closed .
Worth noting that is a link to the US BLM movement

BLM UK doesn't have exactly the same goals and demands

Ta. I actually couldn't find an 'official' UK site, but also figured the US site was likely to take the more extreme line anyway, so safer sharing that one. Happy to edit the other post to include the UK link too if anyone knows the official site?
 
And that's the point - we don't use 'white' as short-hand for young men of Caucasian origin when we talk about crime in Glasgow in the 90s. We talk about youth gangs and poverty. Talking about the specific issues facing young black men in a particular part of London, and how we can learn from other parts of the country like Glasgow is not bad thing. Just using 'black' as shorthand as the key identifier really is.

So it's fence sitting to not support the non-existent position of the BLM which you fabricated? Cool, happy to fence sit in that case. I take it you're happy to endorse every position Boris takes because you both support Brexit and you voted Tory in 2019? Or are you also a fence sitter i.e. capable of independent thought?

But isn’t it a fact that there is a clear link between young black males and youth gang violence....especially in London ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Goldhawk-Road
And that's the point - we don't use 'white' as short-hand for young men of Caucasian origin when we talk about crime in Glasgow in the 90s. We talk about youth gangs and poverty. Talking about the specific issues facing young black men in a particular part of London, and how we can learn from other parts of the country like Glasgow is not bad thing. Just using 'black' as shorthand as the key identifier really is.

So it's fence sitting to not support the non-existent position of the BLM which you fabricated? Cool, happy to fence sit in that case. I take it you're happy to endorse every position Boris takes because you both support Brexit and you voted Tory in 2019? Or are you also a fence sitter i.e. capable of independent thought?

Of course we don't use "Caucasian" when describing Scotsmen in Scotland in the 1990's! Because they were virtually all Caucasian at that time. Jeez, this is straight out of the Jo Swinson book of woke speech.

Now you are seriously suggesting that I have fabricated BLM's position that the police should be defunded. How do you explain this or are you suggesting I fabricated it too:

https://www.standard.co.uk/news/pol...ice-black-lives-matter-backlash-a4483981.html

You continually hedge. You say something isn't so, and then imply that even if it is so, you don't necessarily endorse it. You want it all ways, and you're going to get a nasty splinter from that fence
 
Ta. I actually couldn't find an 'official' UK site, but also figured the US site was likely to take the more extreme line anyway, so safer sharing that one. Happy to edit the other post to include the UK link too if anyone knows the official site?

I'm not sure they have a website, but very active on Facebook and Twitter if you Google BLM UK

Lots of detail about local actions e.g. efforts to close down Yarl's Wood (in over 5 languages) and support for the Ryanair cabin crew strike
 
I'm not sure they have a website, but very active on Facebook and Twitter if you Google BLM UK

Lots of detail about local actions e.g. efforts to close down Yarl's Wood (in over 5 languages) and support for the Ryanair cabin crew strike


“We’re guided by a commitment to dismantle imperialism, capitalism, white-supremacy, patriarchy and the state structures that disproportionately harm black people in Britain and around the world. We build deep relationships across the diaspora and strategise to challenge the rise of the authoritarian right-wing across the world, from Brazil to Britain”

That’s the statement from the BLMUK gofundme page that raised over a million pounds......I presume it’s official as if it wasn’t then I’m sure the ‘official BLM’ would be claiming the money raised.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kiwiqpr
Have a look at the figures on who is killing and who is dying in London. It's young black men (apologies to Jo Swinson for not qualifying further)

Doesn’t sound like a lot of fun.

Old white men do a disproportionate share of noncing but I wouldn’t wish to consider it an issue the old white men community need to look at themselves for.
 
Of course we don't use "Caucasian" when describing Scotsmen in Scotland in the 1990's! Because they were virtually all Caucasian at that time. Jeez, this is straight out of the Jo Swinson book of woke speech.

Now you are seriously suggesting that I have fabricated BLM's position that the police should be defunded. How do you explain this or are you suggesting I fabricated it too:

https://www.standard.co.uk/news/pol...ice-black-lives-matter-backlash-a4483981.html

You continually hedge. You say something isn't so, and then imply that even if it is so, you don't necessarily endorse it. You want it all ways, and you're going to get a nasty splinter from that fence

It's really not that hard to understand - I can only assume you are trying to willfully misunderstand it. Let's take it out of the current context to see if you can wrap your head around it. If I were to say "I support the civil rights movement in the USA of the 1960s, but disagree with the actions [and many views] of the Black Panthers", would that be fence sitting, or just a broadly sensible thing to say? I ask again - do you endorse everything Johnson says because he led the Leave vote and the Party you voted for in 2019? Or are you capable of independent thought, or 'fence sitting' as you put it?

As for the defund the police statement - I've still not seen that on any of their official sites, but I have no issue with the tweet in that article. "When we say 'Defund the police' we mean 'Invest in programmes that actually keep us safe like youth services, mental health and social care, education, jobs and housing. Key services to support the most vulnerable before they come into contact with the criminal justice system'. That's precisely the sort of holistic multi-disciplinary approach that worked with white on white violence in Glasgow.
 
It's really not that hard to understand - I can only assume you are trying to willfully misunderstand it. Let's take it out of the current context to see if you can wrap your head around it. If I were to say "I support the civil rights movement in the USA of the 1960s, but disagree with the actions [and many views] of the Black Panthers", would that be fence sitting, or just a broadly sensible thing to say? I ask again - do you endorse everything Johnson says because he led the Leave vote and the Party you voted for in 2019? Or are you capable of independent thought, or 'fence sitting' as you put it?

As for the defund the police statement - I've still not seen that on any of their official sites, but I have no issue with the tweet in that article. "When we say 'Defund the police' we mean 'Invest in programmes that actually keep us safe like youth services, mental health and social care, education, jobs and housing. Key services to support the most vulnerable before they come into contact with the criminal justice system'. That's precisely the sort of holistic multi-disciplinary approach that worked with white on white violence in Glasgow.

You're hedging because you say something doesn't exist and that it has been fabricated - a policy of defunding the police - and then qualify your statement by saying, anyway, I don't subscribe to everything the BLM stands for. If you can't see it, I haven't the energy to explain it further.

It sounds like you now accept I didn't make up the BLM policy of defunding the police. That's progress of sorts.
 
You're hedging because you say something doesn't exist and that it has been fabricated - a policy of defunding the police - and then qualify your statement by saying, anyway, I don't subscribe to everything the BLM stands for. If you can't see it, I haven't the energy to explain it further.

It sounds like you now accept I didn't make up the BLM policy of defunding the police. That's progress of sorts.

So, let's just be completely clear - you subscribe to every view of every organisation you support?
 
So, let's just be completely clear - you subscribe to every view of every organisation you support?

I support QPR, but I'm damned if I'd be too happy to see Luke Amos in a hooped shirt again.

With regards to the VRUs in Glasgow, and the surrounding areas. I moved up here just over 20 years ago and there were stabbings every week, and plenty of murders every year. The figures have dropped, although locally we still have one of the highest murder rates per head of population...

https://www.greenocktelegraph.co.uk...inverclyde-has-highest-murder-rate-in-the-uk/

The approach that the VRUs conduct in Glasgow is definately an approach that should be considered, not just in London but nationwide as it's had a dramatic effect in the reduction of offences.

This is an excellent article that I've posted before about the VRU

www.bbc.co.uk/news/amp/uk-scotland-45572691
 
I support QPR, but I'm damned if I'd be too happy to see Luke Amos in a hooped shirt again.

With regards to the VRUs in Glasgow, and the surrounding areas. I moved up here just over 20 years ago and there were stabbings every week, and plenty of murders every year. The figures have dropped, although locally we still have one of the highest murder rates per head of population...

https://www.greenocktelegraph.co.uk...inverclyde-has-highest-murder-rate-in-the-uk/

The approach that the VRUs conduct in Glasgow is definately an approach that should be considered, not just in London but nationwide as it's had a dramatic effect in the reduction of offences.

This is an excellent article that I've posted before about the VRU

www.bbc.co.uk/news/amp/uk-scotland-45572691

What about if I throw in Paul Hart as manager? The VRU stuff is really interesting, and is precisely the sort of investment that's needed to make any real difference, reconsigning the 'upstream' challenges that need to be fixed rather than just throwing money at the police hoping that will fix anything.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Willhoops