Off Topic Politics Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
I am going to take one thing as a small light of hope. They have polled 38 people per constituency. 23000 in 650 seats.

Am I being dumb to think that that is a pretty ****ty little poll?
 
I feel ashamed to be British. We fell for nationalism and xenophobia.” As long as I’m ok, who care about the rest “ seems are new motto. I feel my generation has failed the youth. Might as well reach for the scotch.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ChilcoSaint
“Oh, Jeremy Corbyn?”

Looking like the cultists were wrong after all.

And as I've mentioned previous, the crying shame (beyond, y'know, the immediate effect) is that people will take away that Corbyn's democratic socialism was the problem. The next leader will be a New Labour type, and probably several leaders thereafter.

The problem wasn't Corbyn's place on the political spectrum, it was Corbyn. He was absolutely the wrong leader for this moment in time, and sadly it has cost Labour (and the UK, IMO) dearly.

Edit:

You must log in or register to see media
 
I am going to take one thing as a small light of hope. They have polled 38 people per constituency. 23000 in 650 seats.

Am I being dumb to think that that is a pretty ****ty little poll?

23000 is a huge poll, generally speaking. Most polls run in the ~2000 person range, because that's when the margin of error gets into the +/- 3% range. Not representative constituency-by-constituency, but it would take absolute malpractice for it to be inaccurate overall.
 
And as I've mentioned previous, the crying shame (beyond, y'know, the immediate effect) is that people will take away that Corbyn's democratic socialism was the problem. The next leader will be a New Labour type, and probably several leaders thereafter.

The problem wasn't Corbyn's place on the political spectrum, it was Corbyn. He was absolutely the wrong leader for this moment in time, and sadly it has cost Labour (and the UK, IMO) dearly.

Have you ever seen the media turn on one of the party leaders like they have done with JC? I'm not a fan of he, but I found the constant stories and slights very strange. Never seen such a coordinated effort. Makes you wonder how far up the orders came?
 
23000 is a huge poll, generally speaking. Most polls run in the ~2000 person range, because that's when the margin of error gets into the +/- 3% range. Not representative constituency-by-constituency, but it would take absolute malpractice for it to be inaccurate overall.

I don't really do numbers, but how can polling 38 people per consituency give a reliable result?
 
I don't really do numbers, but how can polling 38 people per consituency give a reliable result?

38 people wouldn't be reliable for that riding; the margin of error would be insane. But when you aggregate the whole result, the MOE is going to be quite low, unless there are systemic problems with the way you're conducting it...only interviewing old white men with shouty voices, say.
 
  • Like
Reactions: VocalMinority
38 people wouldn't be reliable for that riding; the margin of error would be insane. But when you aggregate the whole result, the MOE is going to be quite low, unless there are systemic problems with the way you're conducting it...only interviewing old white men with shouty voices, say.
Right, I get that, but how does it make regional predictions? Southampton is going totally blue according to this, but where is the Southampton exit poll?

Is this number magic?
 
Right, I get that, but how does it make regional predictions? Southampton is going totally blue according to this, but where is the Southampton exit poll?

Is this number magic?

You'd model based on past results...so, if Hampshire normally runs Con + 5 or something, you'd run it through a model where you used the sample from all Hampshire-area exit polls + the nationwide sample to make assumptions about how that would move individual ridings. It's well short of exact, and harder by far than modeling in a two-party system like the US: there will be wrong calls there, but it's almost definitely going to be a Conservative majority at the end of the night.
 
Right, I get that, but how does it make regional predictions? Southampton is going totally blue according to this, but where is the Southampton exit poll?

Is this number magic?
I'm afraid you are clutching at a very frail straw. The very worst outcome for Pffefel would be a majority of 50. At the other margin of error 120. Brexit hasn't gone away though, that's the real challenge.
 
You'd model based on past results...so, if Hampshire normally runs Con + 5 or something, you'd run it through a model where you used the sample from all Hampshire-area exit polls + the nationwide sample to make assumptions about how that would move individual ridings. It's well short of exact, and harder by far than modeling in a two-party system like the US: there will be wrong calls there, but it's almost definitely going to be a Conservative majority at the end of the night.
Oh I am resigned to a Tory majority. I am not happy to be losing my Labour MP.
 
I take it the poll will be 95% accurate, but ITV/BBC are doing themselves favours as according to them, Boris will have a 10+ year legacy and Labour are done for my lifetime, so why stay up for the boring predictable count.

I'll go to bed soon

Let's get sleep done.