Leeds Utd Weekend Debate - 26th July

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
good morning to matt and co from a wet Bardsey
It would appear that Phillips whose contract has until 2021 to expire wants to move to Villa so that money should free up so we can get a striker who can score goals Gayle for me ,Gibson for CB and if we need one a keeper so it should be busy on the transfer front next week perhaps Doc can give us an update

TBH I'd be worried if I were a Villa fan. We might complain about Radz being tight but if it goes wrong for them and the owner decides they've had enough they'll go bankrupt. Not sure how they're getting round FFP (again) at the moment.
 
Mike the only update available is not much help. Nothing concrete anywhere just the usual paper talk, but even quieter than last week. One fact is that Oliver Sarkic has just about left the club as he played for Burton Albion yesterday. 3 overseas clubs are chasing and now Nigel Clough wants him so another one out of the door.

2 players we were supposed to be chasing have signed for WBA and Birmingham Sunjic and Sawyers.

Keeper situation still a mystery
Thanks Doc get to know BTW on Friday how they are going to tackle my problem fingers crossed how about you
Why I said to the Doc that I hadn't got cancer was the fact that I have had 5 x rays on my chest in 4 weeks and no one spotted it!
 
Been doing some light reading on yesterdays Leeds V Girona match, as not many match reports around. But seemingly the best Leeds players on view were:
Douglas
Harrison
Stevens
Alioski

Toss up for MOM between Stevens and Harrison

Seems Douglas is now doing what he did at Wolves and sending in great crosses?
 
  • Like
Reactions: davy
We went out to get Sam Dalby and it was a tough job as plenty of clubs were chasing him. He was key for the U23s earlier in the season then sent out on loan to Morecambe. i think he was either homesick or felt his face didn't fit. But gutted to see him go, but to a Prem team. Hugo Diaz U23 captain, won the lot this year and played in most positions at the back, released and goes to a La Liga outfit? why hasn't Edmondson got a squad number? Love to know whats happening at TA right now
 
It is strange though WJ, two we've released in Dalby & Diaz go to teams in leagues above us, don't you think that's odd?
Good question, but I have no idea.

Could it be that they're going to go nowhere in those clubs too? Let's be clear here - they've not all of a sudden become world beaters at these clubs - they've only signed for them. Might never even play for the 1st XI.

From our side, perhaps we considered that we had better coming through that were about to - or already had - surpassed their abilities/potential?

I honestly have no idea.
 
We went out to get Sam Dalby and it was a tough job as plenty of clubs were chasing him. He was key for the U23s earlier in the season then sent out on loan to Morecambe. i think he was either homesick or felt his face didn't fit. But gutted to see him go, but to a Prem team. Hugo Diaz U23 captain, won the lot this year and played in most positions at the back, released and goes to a La Liga outfit? why hasn't Edmondson got a squad number? Love to know whats happening at TA right now
I never really seen enough of Dalby to comment. I've always thought he was a sacrificial lamb - loaned out because we couldn't fully develop both him & Edmondson at the same time. If both were defenders or midfielders, it might have been different. When you only have one up-front spot to develop someone, I believe the club made the right decision to choose only one. Only time will tell if they chose the right one.

Diaz, however, I watched a lot. The best I can offer for him was that he was solid and dependable. And versatile. Perhaps too versatile? A future 6-7/10 journeyman, imho. For his sake, I hope I'm wrong.
 
Good question, but I have no idea.

Could it be that they're going to go nowhere in those clubs too? Let's be clear here - they've not all of a sudden become world beaters at these clubs - they've only signed for them. Might never even play for the 1st XI.

From our side, perhaps we considered that we had better coming through that were about to - or already had - surpassed their abilities/potential?

I honestly have no idea.

No worries, just I know you watch the U23s a lot and you've always spoken highly of and rated Diaz in particular. When I meant odd, we didn't even try to get a fee for him and then a LaLiga side are prepared to see what he can offer. I understand they might not make the grade at their new clubs but usually when a player is released, their trajectory is downwards not up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Whitejock
No worries, just I know you watch the U23s a lot and you've always spoken highly of and rated Diaz in particular. When I meant odd, we didn't even try to get a fee for him and then a LaLiga side are prepared to see what he can offer. I understand they might not make the grade at their new clubs but usually when a player is released, their trajectory is downwards not up.
Until he makes it into their 1st XI, it'll always be a sideways move for me. :D

He's a solid kinda player, but never really flourished with us, imo. If he was a 6.5/10 u23 player, Halme was an 8 & Struijk a 9. I've only had a couple of looks at Casey, who's just come through from the u18s, & was stunned by him. At least a 7.5 (but very little game time to judge, tbf). I think it was a simple case that we had better than him.

Even though he was out of contract, are we still not entitled to development costs for him. He's only 22, so certainly qualifies by age.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leedsoflondon
I never really seen enough of Dalby to comment. I've always thought he was a sacrificial lamb - loaned out because we couldn't fully develop both him & Edmondson at the same time. If both were defenders or midfielders, it might have been different. When you only have one up-front spot to develop someone, I believe the club made the right decision to choose only one. Only time will tell if they chose the right one.

Diaz, however, I watched a lot. The best I can offer for him was that he was solid and dependable. And versatile. Perhaps too versatile? A future 6-7/10 journeyman, imho. For his sake, I hope I'm wrong.

Yeah Dalby had Kun, Clarke, Edmondson and Stevens in competition and those 4 either played first team or made the bench
 
Yeah Dalby had Kun, Clarke, Edmondson and Stevens in competition and those 4 either played first team or made the bench
I know I'm going against the tide here, but I still don't think Stevens is all he's cracked up to be. He fits in, rather than stands out, if you know what I mean. I so hope I'm wrong, but I don't think he'll be special or consistent enough for us. Well, that's prolly guaranteed him 200 caps & 1000 PL goals for us :D

Not too wild about Kun either, I might add. But it's early yet for him, and he's more consistent.
 
I know I'm going against the tide here, but I still don't think Stevens is all he's cracked up to be. He fits in, rather than stands out, if you know what I mean. I so hope I'm wrong, but I don't think he'll be special or consistent enough for us. Well, that's prolly guaranteed him 200 caps & 1000 PL goals for us :D

Not too wild about Kun either, I might add. But it's early yet for him, and he's more consistent.

Isn't that what they said about David Seaman <whistle> <laugh>
 
  • Like
Reactions: Whitejock
so you keep barndoor Bamford and sell a 19 yr old to Watford and he gets a Hat-Trick on his debut <doh>

<laugh>
 
I know I'm going against the tide here, but I still don't think Stevens is all he's cracked up to be. He fits in, rather than stands out, if you know what I mean. I so hope I'm wrong, but I don't think he'll be special or consistent enough for us. Well, that's prolly guaranteed him 200 caps & 1000 PL goals for us :D

Not too wild about Kun either, I might add. But it's early yet for him, and he's more consistent.
More than who? Alioski