You must log in or register to see media
One glaring flaw with Shearer's argument: he remained at Newcastle for a decade in spite of not winning anything.I just saw Jenas and Shearer debate this issue on MOTD2. Both had good points but, strangely, I found myself agreeing with Shearer. (Yeah I know.)
Paraphrasing...."The team hasn't won anything. When they do they'll be in a better position to negotiate in between contracts."
Players can't keep putting the onus of winning things on to the manager and the chairman of the club. Especially when they are so close.
The one exception being, and maybe this is actually the position that Rose is really talking about, if Kane had quality competition for his place similar to that which Rose and Walker had, we'd have probably won the league last season. Same could be said for Erikssen and Dele too.
One glaring flaw with Shearer's argument: he remained at Newcastle for a decade in spite of not winning anything.
Jenas probably should've brought that one up...
Making yourself look like a clueless bufoon on national television doesn't usual help somebody's argument.I'm thinking that probably helps his argument rather than hindering it. No?

The debate, for anyone that missed it: http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/40924557I just saw Jenas and Shearer debate this issue on MOTD2. Both had good points but, strangely, I found myself agreeing with Shearer. (Yeah I know.)
Paraphrasing...."The team hasn't won anything. When they do they'll be in a better position to negotiate in between contracts."
Players can't keep putting the onus of winning things on to the manager and the chairman of the club. Especially when they are so close.
The one exception being, and maybe this is actually the position that Rose is really talking about, if Kane had quality competition for his place similar to that which Rose and Walker had, we'd have probably won the league last season. Same could be said for Erikssen and Dele too.
I've seen it all now.....
You must log in or register to see media
! Shame he couldn't do the high pitched bits.
Sounds like the natives are restless Helmets on,lads!! Shame he couldn't do the high pitched bits.
Junglist massive, Yiddo massive![]()
All the pundits seem to think that players should be allowed to go to the clubs that "win things" instead of staying at the club they are at to help it "win things". Doesn't bode well for competition really, and suggests this "rule of entitlement" whereby only certain clubs will be allowed at the top of the league. I don't think such as system is sustainable in the long term.
All the pundits seem to think that players should be allowed to go to the clubs that "win things" instead of staying at the club they are at to help it "win things". Doesn't bode well for competition really, and suggests this "rule of entitlement" whereby only certain clubs will be allowed at the top of the league. I don't think such as system is sustainable in the long term.