My mates a joiner I'll see if he can sort it for us
Silva's done one...
- Thread starter originallambrettaman
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
Mark to his friends.... well those in red and white obviously ...
Really? I've always been impressed when I've seen him but always unimpressed with Maguire. Admittedly I've seen little of either but how much of Gibson have you seen? How come he's in the England squad and Maguire isn't? I might be dumb here because I know little about him but is he English?
Because in the opinion of the manager, Gibson is better. The same way every national squad selection works.
Obvs.
Last edited:
It's because the selectors think that Gibson is better.
Maguire is really quite English.
Ok fair enough, I agree that players aren't picked on merit so I accept that.
What makes Maguire better then?
What's wrong with Gibson?
It's not that there's anything wrong with him, I just think that a team like Chelsea can do better.
Ha.
Strange how people struggle with this though.
As if Southgate’s selections iterate an absolute and infallible index of England’s contemporary best
As a onetime highly regarded central defender himself, I'd say Gareth Southgate should be fairly well qualified to pick defenders - just a thought like.
There’s a logic there but in truth playing ability or positional experience has little to do with success at management.
There are tonnes of examples of fantastic players being ****e at management.
Last edited:
I don't really know about that, my only point was - you'd think one good centre half would know what another good centre half looked like.
Naturally, I'm sure they do, it's rare they select someone who's ****. However, the national team manager is supposed to select the best from the best.
Does this mean that they would always select the correct players? How do we define correct and better than?
Anyway, my point is that it's totally subjective and to take their decision as absolute (in grading terms) is stupid as a different manager, might have a different interpretation.
If Macguire didn't do the eye catching Beckenbeur stuff (which never amounted to anything, hence Silva telling him to focus on his proper job), does anyone really believe he is that fantastic? He has reduced his mistakes to one in a couple of games or so, but England defenders should go months without a mistake,