Match Day Thread NCFC vs QPRcelona

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Forgot_My_Lines said:
It's a fan forum for opinions. That was mine. If you say plural, then people agree with me.

You have your opinions, we have ours. Welcome to a fan forum.
Click to expand...

Yep you're not the only poster to suggest that Holahan should become a coach, doesn't make it sensible though. Every time someone suggests it I ask them to explain why and I've never had a reply other than he's an experienced footballer.

You are of course correct this is a forum for opinions and within the law and the rules of the forum anyone can express any opinion they like however absurd or unsubstantiated that opinion may be.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: DHCanary and JM Fan
Forgot_My_Lines said:
It's a fan forum for opinions. That was mine. If you say plural, then people agree with me.

You have your opinions, we have ours. Welcome to a fan forum.
Click to expand...
I said earlier about him working for his coaching badges last week.<smooch>
Like Huckerby who seems to be coming along nicely .
Crook Bowen Culverhouse Phelan Bruce O'Neil Robinson have all gone on to be good coaches so there is no evidence to say Hoolahan couldn't if he choses to when he hangs up his size 7s.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Forgot_My_Lines and JM Fan
DUNCAN DONUTS said:
I said earlier about him working for his coaching badges last week.<smooch>
Like Huckerby who seems to be coming along nicely .
Crook Bowen Culverhouse Phelan Bruce O'Neil Robinson have all gone on to be good coaches so there is no evidence to say Hoolahan couldn't if he choses to when he hangs up his size 7s.
Click to expand...
I know Middleton has praised Hucks for some of his coaching and I can see some of his style of play in the way Middleton plays.
And 'on the other side of the coin' - I believe SAF was a pretty average footballer .......
 
carrowcanario said:
Yep you're not the only poster to suggest that Holahan should become a coach (1), doesn't make it sensible though. Every time someone suggests it I ask them to explain why and I've never had a reply other than he's an experienced footballer.

You are of course correct this is a forum for opinions and within the law and the rules of the forum anyone can express any opinion they like however absurd or unsubstantiated that opinion may be (2).
Click to expand...
(1) See a post below yours. Proving you wrong.

As usual.

Just because you don't agree, doesn't make it absurd.

(2) Good. Apply that, to your own drivel.
 
If I may play devil's advocate here, Wes could always take the role of 'player/coach', then if SW thinks he's not what they're looking for once he does hang up his boots he moves on.

P.S. The guy has just won POS FFS are people seriously suggesting we shouldn't keep him next year <doh>
 
  • Like
Reactions: RiverEndRick, ncgandy and Forgot_My_Lines
KIO said:
If I may play devil's advocate here, Wes could always take the role of 'player/coach', then if SW thinks he's not what they're looking for once he does hang up his boots he moves on.

P.S. The guy has just won POS FFS are people seriously suggesting we shouldn't keep him next year
Click to expand...
Keep Wes for another season, ostensibly as back up to Pritchard and Maddison, who will be far more involved next season than they were allowed to be this.
And to avoid overloading that part of the field, sell Naismith to Rangers or whoever we can recoup the biggest chunk possible of the horrendous fee we wasted on acquiring him.
That should tie up all the loose ends nicely? <ok>
 
  • Like
Reactions: DHCanary, ncgandy, DUNCAN DONUTS and 2 others
KIO said:
If I may play devil's advocate here, Wes could always take the role of 'player/coach', then if SW thinks he's not what they're looking for once he does hang up his boots he moves on.

P.S. The guy has just won POS FFS are people seriously suggesting we shouldn't keep him next year <doh>
Click to expand...

We do usually move POTS on - Croft, Snoddy, Bradders etc .....<whistle>
 
  • Like
Reactions: carrowcanario and Walsh.i.am
Just watched the highlights from the weekend, Smithies had a decent reputation a few years ago and was touted as a possible England keeper, but he looked poor for a couple of those goals.

Josh Murphy looked very lively in the highlights too, a run in the team seems to have done him a world of good, I wish we would have tried a Murphy on each wing at some point this season. Jacob was dropped for a number of games towards the end of he season?
 
  • Like
Reactions: JM Fan
Cromercanary said:
Keep Wes for another season, ostensibly as back up to Pritchard and Maddison, who will be far more involved next season than they were allowed to be this.
And to avoid overloading that part of the field, sell Naismith to Rangers or whoever we can recoup the biggest chunk possible of the horrendous fee we wasted on acquiring him.
That should tie up all the loose ends nicely? <ok>
Click to expand...

I don't believe in back-ups and squad players in the modern game. Every player should be competing for a starting place week-in and week-out. The HC has to select the line-up which he feels could win the match. Wes was playing alongside Pritchard on Saturday, as he has done several times before and it was he who tore QPR apart. Pritchard played his part as did Maddison when he came on. Pritchard and Maddison are the future, but Wes still has what it takes, as he showed on Saturday. The whole point is that competition is what brings the best out of players. Similarly with Naismith who, IMO, isn't an AM like the others. If he plays in the centre, he is more of a second striker/AM with a different role to play. If he plays WR or WL then he poses different problems than Jacob or Josh or Wildschut and that gives the HC options which keeps us from becoming too predictable. The problem is our defending as a team, but our attacking abilities are promotion capable, as being joint top scorers has shown.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KIO, goldeneadie and ncgandy
It was certainly a curious signing and it'll be interesting to see what SW and the new HC think about various players and the role they will or will not play next season.
 
RiverEndRick said:
It was certainly a curious signing and it'll be interesting to see what SW and the new HC think about various players and the role they will or will not play next season.
Click to expand...
Theoretically, we needed cover on the left due to the departures of Olsson and Brady.
But the guy spent more time on the pitch doing the lap of honour yesterday than he has during matches?? :emoticon-0112-wonde
 
We'll have to see what happens with Wildschut, but perhaps a new start in the pre-season will give him a chance to show what he can do. In theory he does offer another option with his pace, power and height and at 25 he's at a good age to push on. I hope he does. SW has finally revealed his transfer plans in more detail, confirming that Russ and Wes will stay: “Listen, we have to get the age of the squad down, we had 13 over 30 at one point, but then it is keeping the great, experienced players like Russ and Wes Hoolahan to help any younger ones”. After the 7 players who left, we now only have Russ (31), Wes (34), Tettey (31) and McGovern (32) who are over 30. Dorrans turned 30 four days ago and Jerome, Jarvis and Naismith are all 30 as well. AS SW goes on:

“With the budget constraints we have got, we are not going to be able to have two fantastic right backs on excellent salaries. We might only be able to have one and back him up with a younger guy, whether from the academy or signing a young one who isn’t on a big salary, to keep our best players. The easiest thing to do is sell one of our top players but instead we have to be creative.”

It'll be interesting to see where that 'creativity' takes us. The full interview is here:

http://www.pinkun.com/norwich-city/stuart-webber-unveils-norwich-city-s-transfer-blueprint-1-5008445
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: KIO and SuffolkCanary
You were telling us how brilliant Wildshut was and he could play in about 5 different positions a few months back.
6 starts 1 goal ?
Selling 2 International left backs and spending £7m on a player to potentially freeze out our 2 best youth prospects on the left wing was mental.
When Dijks leaves we won't have any left backs but about 6 players that can play left wing .
Ridiculous
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back