The Premier League Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Yes, when I saw some highlights last night, the commentators [different ones to here] were saying 'penalty, but little contact'. Fact is, there's zero meaningful contact and Townsend has dived. He's dived so blatantly there should be a swimming pool under his feet. Funny thing was that even at full speed, first time, without prior knowledge, I was pretty much unconvinced, which just shows how clear it was, because my eyesight is nothing special. And yes, there should be retrospective action, but I doubt they will do anything.
 
Yes, when I saw some highlights last night, the commentators [different ones to here] were saying 'penalty, but little contact'. Fact is, there's zero meaningful contact and Townsend has dived. He's dived so blatantly there should be a swimming pool under his feet. Funny thing was that even at full speed, first time, without prior knowledge, I was pretty much unconvinced, which just shows how clear it was, because my eyesight is nothing special. And yes, there should be retrospective action, but I doubt they will do anything.
No contact, starts going down, throws his right foot out as far as he can to touch the goalkeeper's stomach when he realises he better do something, face contorts in agony (he probably shouted in pain as well). That's actually really pissed me off.
 
What is more frustrating about that penalty, is that we don't even get nailed on penalties given, whilst other teams get decisions like that. :emoticon-0121-angry
 
I think I am in a minority on this. Only British fans are obsessed with diving, and foreign players/managers in the PL find it weird. Players make silly decisions, a yellow card is the right punishment.

The ref got that one wrong but I can see why - the GK randomly crunched into his own defender so it looked like a big collision. Never mind.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Saintmagic
I'm not sure diving is any more prevalent now than in the past. It may just be the incredible degree of TV coverage and scrutiny, which simply didn't exist 30 or 40 years ago.

Having said that, I'd say referees effectively encourage diving. They don't give enough fouls when players stay on their feet and as a result players feel they need to hit the deck if they want the decision to go their way.
 
Said for years that clear cases of diving should be given 5 match bans with no appeal.

That would soon put a stop to it.

That might be fine if referees didn't occasionally book and subsequently red card players for diving when they haven't on either occasion. I put up a video the other day of Forestieri of Sheff Wed being booked several times for diving. Run the video back and each time it is so easily seen that he has been clearly fouled. He was sent off for one of the so-called dives. I'll put it up again. Note: no trailing foot left for tripping over. No anticipation of tackle. No 'looking for it' tactic, nothing.

You must log in or register to see media
 
That might be fine if referees didn't occasionally book and subsequently red card players for diving when they haven't on either occasion. I put up a video the other day of Forestieri of Sheff Wed being booked several times for diving. Run the video back and each time it is so easily seen that he has been clearly fouled. He was sent off for one of the so-called dives. I'll put it up again. Note: no trailing foot left for tripping over. No anticipation of tackle. No 'looking for it' tactic, nothing.

You must log in or register to see media

I'm talking about retrospective action, in clear cut cases.
 
That might be fine if referees didn't occasionally book and subsequently red card players for diving when they haven't on either occasion. I put up a video the other day of Forestieri of Sheff Wed being booked several times for diving. Run the video back and each time it is so easily seen that he has been clearly fouled. He was sent off for one of the so-called dives. I'll put it up again. Note: no trailing foot left for tripping over. No anticipation of tackle. No 'looking for it' tactic, nothing.

You must log in or register to see media
ouch!
 
That might be fine if referees didn't occasionally book and subsequently red card players for diving when they haven't on either occasion. I put up a video the other day of Forestieri of Sheff Wed being booked several times for diving. Run the video back and each time it is so easily seen that he has been clearly fouled. He was sent off for one of the so-called dives. I'll put it up again. Note: no trailing foot left for tripping over. No anticipation of tackle. No 'looking for it' tactic, nothing.

You must log in or register to see media
Wow. Those are shocking!
 
Wow. Those are shocking!
They are pretty amazing. Look, I know nothing of Forestieri. I think someone mentioned him once as someone they'd like Saints to sign, but that's about it. So I have nno idea whether he's a serial diver who only gets the occasional errors against him, and he usually gets away with murder, I have no idea.
However, having said all that, the above examples are so cut and dried wrong decisions it really makes you wonder. And that's to one player over some part of a season.
And tbf, Forestieri looks a bit useful. :)
 
PFA shortlists announced. Kane & Lukaku up for both player and young player of the year. Other nominees are:

Player of the year - Ibrahimovic, Sanchez, Hazard & Kante

Young player of the year - Alli, Keane, Sane & Pickford