Transfer Rumours Transfer Rumours thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Don't agree about not having windows. Means you could get players making bids for players before they play them to try unsettle them.

And itll help help the richer teams far more. They can afford to spend cash all season so if they get injurycrises can just go buy a couple more to strengthen their own team.

Teams at the botttlm will find they lose their players more frequently as well, have a good opening 10 games and clubs will come in for them.

Leicester wojldnt have have won the league if that was case last year as they'd have lost Kante at some through the season if inagine.
 
JonnyBaws said:
Some experts think that if we had a more reliable LB than Moreno then he'd be playing and Milner would be in Midfield..
If Klopp wanted to play Milner in midfield he'd have bought a LB by now!
Think, right now, given who we have in midfield and upfront, only way Milner plays CM is if we have an injury crisis, and even then don't think Klopp would want to make that switch, he trusts/needs what Milner can bring to the team from the LB position.
Click to expand...

I think Klopp just looked at Milner and the situation in our squad and with available players to buy and thought this bloke will make a very good LB and moved him there. I think he'll keep playing that position for the rest of his time with us now and will hopefully keep on improving there as he has over the course of this season. He's one of the best LBs in the league now which is pretty amazing given where he was before, we do need cover/competition though as we all know Moreno is pants putting it politely. Fortunatley Milner has a good work ethic and is motivated to do well so he doesn't necessarily need the threat of being dropped like a lot of other players shamefully seem to
 
Milner is the ultimate pro. Feel bit sorry as he moves from city as he wanted to play more at CM rather than wing and been shoved at LB but he's been so consistent that's he made place his own.

No moaning, just gets on and does the job.

I think it was Klopp that recently spoke about him (or maybe was someone else) that referred to piczcek (sp) where he started as a striker before moving to a winger and eventually a very good maurading RB. Seem similar with Milner there.

I thjnk long term yes prob need another Lb as I don't think Klopp trusts Moreno (brought him on and played him lw with Milner at Lb) so need competition and long term but I doubt anything will happen in Jan.
 
InNewYearKloppWeTrust said:
Don't agree about not having windows. Means you could get players making bids for players before they play them to try unsettle them.
Click to expand...

FFS...<doh>

That never happened before the windows were introduced btw. There wasn't as much focus on transfers back then because there wasn't a short space of time when they all happened, it was only the final months that transfers weren't allowed (therefore eliminating that tactic you suggest since it would only happen between rivals)
 
Zanjinho said:
FFS...<doh>

That never happened before the windows were introduced btw. There wasn't as much focus on transfers back then because there wasn't a short space of time when they all happened, it was only the final months that transfers weren't allowed (therefore eliminating that tactic you suggest since it would only happen between rivals)
Click to expand...

When were they introduced? Thought they'd been around all time I've watched football so don't really know what happened before. But was no where near as much money in it and pressure to stay in premier league or getting CL etc
 
InNewYearKloppWeTrust said:
When were they introduced? Thought they'd been around all time I've watched football so don't really know what happened before. But was no where near as much money in it and pressure to stay in premier league or getting CL etc
Click to expand...

Not sure, mid-nineties I think


EDIT: made compulsory by Fifa for the 2002-03 season. That's when the PL adopted it too
 
Zanjinho said:
Not sure, mid-nineties I think


EDIT: made compulsory by Fifa for the 2002-03 season. That's when the PL adopted it too
Click to expand...

Later than I thought then. Although o was prob just about getting into it properly at that point so prob why don't really remember how worked before that
 
InNewYearKloppWeTrust said:
Later than I thought then. Although o was prob just about getting into it properly at that point so prob why don't really remember how worked before that
Click to expand...

Before the window you could buy a player at any time up to about 12noon on a friday and have time to register them to play saturday.

I think there might have been some time where it did sort of end for the season


The one thing it didnt have was this agent and press frenzy but i couldnt say if thats just from the money and technological changes at this point.

Sky have always driven the deadline day frenzy i know that.

And i think bungs were always part of transfers. A deadline might have made them juicier i dont know but many old nanagers were famed for it
 
Never say Milk again said:
I'm not against transfers (although, if a clubs way of staying financially viable is through transfers alone they have problems).

I'm against specific windows for transfers. I think it inflated prices and unlike it's intention to level the playing field by not letting big teams buy their way out of injury crisis it has the opposite effect because the bigger the team the more they can spend on backup players and often have 2 teams of almost equally strong players.

I'd rather they cap the number of players that may be transferred in one season than have transfer windows.
Click to expand...

Outside of the premiership (and possibly the top half of the championship) this is the business model adopted by a fair few clubs. Find a young "gem" start to develop them and move them on for big bucks.
 
pieguts said:
Outside of the premiership (and possibly the top half of the championship) this is the business model adopted by a fair few clubs. Find a young "gem" start to develop them and move them on for big bucks.
Click to expand...


I'm not saying it doesn't happen. It just isn't a long term financiallu viable plan. A couple of seasons without a great young player to sell and you're bankrupt.

Russian roulette. Eventually you get a bullet.
 
Never say Milk again said:
I'm not saying it doesn't happen. It just isn't a long term financiallu viable plan. A couple of seasons without a great young player to sell and you're bankrupt.

Russian roulette. Eventually you get a bullet.
Click to expand...

Yeah but if you cant get 10k fans in the door you cant do anything either.

Clubs cut their cloth to meet their measure.

If champ club are now chucking 10mil at players due to parachute payments system then getting to the pig trough now becomes all but impossible which makes the bournemouth story all the more heartening imo
 
Are you lot convinced klopp is looking for a lb and goalie?

Reason I ask is its not something he has made any effort to address with Milner and Karl us with migs doing a job.

We all want a cb as well as not many convinced by Lovern, but he partners matip well enough and have cover.

Attack can always be tweaked, maybe he is looking to strengthen there first as backup options we are quite light on.

Yes we are still ****e at the back,but we keep scoring plenty other end hopefully with time the defence will sort itself out and grow in confidence.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back