Willo or Taylor

Actually, this. Willo for now but Tayls has been out of it for ages. He always looks like he's on the brink of being great then he gets injured or plays a stinker and gets dropped. He's certainly more skillful and pacier than Willo but he's nowhere near match-sharp. Hasn't been for ages.

 

He has his good games. I'm not saying he's an overall **** player, but we could sign better and i hope we do.

 

I did agree with you on this

 

Taylor..... the best of an average pair

 

Yep, Willow is an average PL defender, Taylor is a good PL defender when he gets a good run in the team. However, if we want to challenge in the top half, we need a better CB than Taylor or Willo

 

This sums it up pretty well

 

I would choose Williamson - we do need a better partner for Colo but it will have to wait as buying a quality striker or two MUST be the priority. Not to mention another left back...

 

I think we need someone better but out of the 2, Willo everytime, Taylors a donkey (apart from a decent period i remember a few seasons back)

 

I concur. Last season Taylor looked to have an excellent understanding with Colo before his run of injuries. Plus Taylor gives you a goal threat from corners

 

Not really sure, I guess I'd rather Willo start but I'm not too bothered, both of them are decent alongside Colo.

Would ideally see a new strong CB come in to partner Coloccini next season though.

 

stupid 606, gives me an error that my post hasnt posted, so i resubmit and there's two. Then it won't let me delete the duplicate

 

Williamson

 

Taylor is ****e, Willo is average. Willo wins hands down and has since he came here!

 

Taylor is below average and should be sold.

 

agree we need someone new but out of the 2 it's Willo easily for me
would have preferred to have seen kadar giving the chance in the ccc as he has the potential to be better than both of them put together but alas it wasn't to be,missed opportunity in my opinion.

 

I'm sure last time this was done, Taylor won easily.

 

Taylor.

 

He did, it was a few weeks ago...however I still voted for Willo then!

If we can find the article could we see who voted for who and who has changed their minds?

 

Williamson every time, and this is not a reaction, I have never preferred Saylor since we signed Williamson. I would also go so far as to say I dont really care too much about another CB next year (except to replace Campbell so we have 4 options).

Also Saylor is a goal threat, but Williamson is a better one IMO, he's bigger, easier to aim for, better in the air and has been unlucky not to break his duck. I recall fans of a few former clubs saying he scored a fair few goals from corners. And Taylor has only ever scored 10 goals for us, not exactly incredible when you look at a real goalscoring CB like Huth has been recently, 8 goals this season!

 

http://www.not606.com/showthread.php/38146-Steven-Taylor-or-Mike-Williamson-to-start-against-Wolves

Think this the poll people are talking about